Abstract
Complex modulus and fatigue behavior are important characteristics for all materials. Some European countries have developed performance oriented requirements for bituminous mixtures. Using such requirements it is expected that the life of pavements can be improved. According to the European standards, these properties are characterized by various methods including two point bending (2PB) on trapezoidal specimen and four point bending (4PB) on prismatic specimen. It is known that the fatigue results obtained are highly dependent, in addition to the mixture variables and environmental variables, on specimen fabrication procedure and test equipment and procedure. Therefore the question remains how comparable are the results obtained from these tests? Up to date, a significant amount of data on comparison of the results of such tests is absent. This paper presents results of a Swiss inter-laboratory study on 2PB and 4PB tests for complex modulus and fatigue conducted on a wide pallet of specimen produced from aged field sections. The results show that a good linear regression for complex modulus values were obtained, however, the fatigue performance ranking obtained from the two tests were dissimilar.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Partl MN et al (eds) (2013). Advances in inter-laboratory testing and evaluation of bituminous materials. State of the Art Report of the Rilem Technical Committee 206-ATB
EN 12697-26 (2012) Bituminous mixtures—test methods for hot mix asphalt—part 26: stiffness
EN 12697-24 (2007) 2004+A1, bituminous mixtures—test methods for hot mix asphalt—part 24: resistance to fatigue
Wu H, Huang B, Shu X (2014) Document characterizing fatigue behavior of asphalt mixtures utilizing loaded wheel testers. J Mater Civ Eng 26(1):152–159
Di Benedetto H, de La Roche C, Baaj H, Pronk A, Lundström R (2004) Fatigue of bituminous mixtures. Mater Struct 37:202–216
Pittet M (2000) Essais d’exactitude pour essai de module complexe et essai de fatigue pour normes EN 12697-24 et EN 12697-26. Détermination de la répétabilité et de la reproductibilité
Pittet M (2006) A2 Erstfeld-Amsteg. Module et résistance à la fatigue d’un enrobé AC EME 22 C1
Gubler R, Partl MN, Canestrari F, Grilli A (2005) Influence of water and temperature on mechanical properties of selected asphalt pavements. Mater Struct 38:523–532
Pais J (ed) (2009) Four point bending proceedings of the second workshop. University of Minho, Guimaraes. 24–25th Sept 2009
AkhtarhuseinTayebali A, Deacon JA, Monismith CL (1996) Development and evaluation of dynamic flexural beam fatigue test system. Transp Res Rec 1545:89–97
Puchard Z, Gorgenyi A (2012) Hungarian experience with different bending devices. In: Pais JC (ed) Four-point bending. Taylor and Francis Group, London
SN 640 431-1b-NA, Bituminous mixtures- material specifications- part 1: aspahlt concrete National Annex. Asphaltmischgut- Mischgutanforderungen-teil 1: Asphaltbeton; nationaler Anhang available in German and French
Pais C, Harvey JT (2012) Four point bending. CRC Press, Taylor and Francis, Davis
Matthews JM, Monismith CL, Craus J (1993) Investigation of laboratory fatigue testing procedures for asphalt aggregate mixtures. J Transp Eng 119(4):634–654
Picado-Santos L, Almeida A, Pais J, Antunes ML, Batista F (2009) Assessment of stiffness and fatigue tests in Portugal. In: Pais J (ed) Four point bending proceedings of the second workshop. University of Minho, Guimaraes. 24–25th Sept 2009
Francken L (ed) 1998 Bituminous binders and mixes. Rilem Report 17. E & FN Spon, London
Dondi G, Pettinari M, Sangiorgi C, Zoorob S (2013) Traditional and dissipated energy approaches to compare the 2PB and 4PB flexural methodologies on warm mix asphalt. Constr Build Mater 47(2013):833–839
Acknowledgments
This research project was supported by the Swiss Roads Office (FEDRO) grant number VSS 2006/503. The authors would like to acknowledge the help of Simon Kuentzel, Andreas Treuholz and Martin Hugener in performing the experiments in this project at Empa. The specimen were cut and prepared by Christian Meierhofer and Roland Takacs. At LAVOC, data analysis and specimen preparation were done by Jean-Claude Reymond and Jean-Wilfried Fils-Aimé.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Poulikakos, L.D., Pittet, M., Dumont, AG. et al. Comparison of the two point bending and four point bending test methods for aged asphalt concrete field samples. Mater Struct 48, 2901–2913 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1617/s11527-014-0366-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1617/s11527-014-0366-8