Rewriting deficit storylines: the positioning of one fourth-grader as comics expert
English Teaching: Practice & Critique
ISSN: 1175-8708
Article publication date: 11 March 2021
Issue publication date: 2 September 2021
Abstract
Purpose
This study took place in an elementary English language arts classroom during a comics writers workshop unit and focused on one fourth-grade author. This paper aims to explain how a fourth-grade student receiving special education services positions himself and is positioned by others as an expert during a unit on comics. When students’ knowledge about multimodal composition is recognized and valued, the classroom community can become a place where students can author themselves into positions of power and authority.
Design/methodology/approach
Informed by sociocultural theory, social semiotics and positioning theory, the authors conducted a qualitative study to analyze the focal participant’s published comic, classroom interactions and interview data using open and in vivo coding systems.
Findings
The findings documented how the focal participant was positioned as an expert by others and how he positioned himself as an expert. The findings also explore how this fourth-grade comics expert left an authorial residue that extended beyond the boundaries of this particular comics unit, impacting his teachers and future iterations of the comics workshop.
Originality/value
Scholars have theorized multimodal approaches to reading and writing pedagogy as an equitable enterprise that values meaning-makers using a wide variety of semiotic resources. This study shows how incorporating an explicit multimodal composition opportunity allowed one fourth-grade author space to craft a comic and re-author traditional classroom positions of power.
Keywords
Citation
Reid, S.F. and Moses, L. (2021), "Rewriting deficit storylines: the positioning of one fourth-grader as comics expert", English Teaching: Practice & Critique, Vol. 20 No. 3, pp. 298-312. https://doi.org/10.1108/ETPC-07-2020-0075
Publisher
:Emerald Publishing Limited
Copyright © 2020, Emerald Publishing Limited