Previous studies have reported low negative predictive values (NPV) for computed tomography (CT)-guided fine needle aspiration of lung nodules in excluding malignancy. Our aim was to determine the NPV of transthoracic core needle biopsy in a tertiary care hospital with a large cancer patient population. The results of 226 consecutive CT-guided transthoracic core needle biopsies were reviewed. Results were classified into one of the following four groups: positive or suspicious for malignancy, benign specific, benign non-specific, and non-diagnostic. The benign specific group included entities such as fungus, hamartoma and schwannoma. In the benign non-specific group, histologic findings such as scar and inflammation were reported. The non-diagnostic group included cases with only normal pulmonary tissue in the specimen and/or insufficient tissue to render any diagnosis. The results were correlated with subsequent proof obtained via surgery or clinical and imaging follow-up. Out of a total of 226 biopsies, 158 were positive or suspicious for malignancy, 8 were benign specific, 32 were benign non-specific and 28 were non-diagnostic. Forty-three benign non-specific or non-diagnostic cases had subsequent proof, and malignancy was subsequently confirmed in 16/43 cases (5/21 non-specific and 11/22 non-diagnostic cases). The NPVs were 76% and 50% for benign non-specific and non-diagnostic biopsies, respectively. The overall NPV and false negative rate were 68% and 9%, respectively. A core biopsy revealing non-specific benign tissue or insufficient tissue for diagnosis is unreliable in excluding malignancy, and patients with these types of biopsy results should have resampling of tissue or close clinical and imaging follow-up.

Author

Leslie E Quint, Matthew Kretschmer, Andrew Chang and Bin Nan

Contact Details

Corresponding address:
Leslie E Quint, MD, Professor,
Department of Radiology, Box 0030,
University of Michigan Health System,
1500 E. Medical Center Drive,
Ann Arbor, MI 48109-0030, USA

Reference

ICIS Cancer Imaging Volume 6 Issue 1
DOI: 10.1102/1470-7330.2006.0027

Date Posted

8 November 2006

Print PDF

Size

597.04 KB

Minimum Estimated Download Times

ADSL 2Mb/s (Broadband):	2 seconds
ADSL 512Kb/s (Broadband):	9 seconds
64 Kb/s (ISDN):	1 minute 14 seconds
33.3 Kb/s (Typical Modem):	2 minutes 23 seconds

Screen PDF

Size

435.93 KB

Minimum Estimated Download Times

ADSL 2Mb/s (Broadband):	1 second
ADSL 512Kb/s (Broadband):	6 seconds
64 Kb/s (ISDN):	54 seconds
33.3 Kb/s (Typical Modem):	1 minute 44 seconds

No part of this publication or site may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the Publisher, e-MED Limited, Permissions, PO Box 61053, London, SE16 7YZ. Tel: +44 (0)207 231 7773 Fax: +44 (0)560 126 4446, permissions@cancerimaging.org.