Abstract
Although the hypothesis that small firms create the majority of net new jobs is widely believed, a number of researchers have attacked this using empirical data. Since these attacks have been presented as corrections of past methodological errors, their authors may influence policy makers. This paper argues that the substance of these attacks is a difference in theoretical perspectives even though the researchers claim to focus on methodological differences. This paper explains the two underlying economic theories and then reviews the job creation research to demonstrate the relationship between theory and methodology.
The theory discussion and methodological results demonstrates that all methodologies used to calculate small firms share of net new jobs are incorrect for analyzing the dynamics of capitalism. The appropriate methodology for understanding economic growth is analysis of new employment created over time by cohorts of newly formed firms. Recognition of this fact, combined with describing the empirical research supporting this approach, reinforces the use of economic development policies designed to promote entrepreneurship.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Armington, Catherine and Marjorie Odle, 1982, ‘Small Business — How Many Jobs?’ The Brookings Review, Winter, pp. 14–17.
Birch, David L., 1979, The Job Generation Process, Unpublished report prepared by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Program on Neighborhood and Regional Change for the Economic Development Administration, U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington, D.C.
Birch, David L. and Susan MacCracken, 1982, ‘Corporate Evolution: A Micro-Based Analysis’. Unpublished research report prepared for the U.S. Small Business Administration, Washington, D.C.
Boulding, Kenneth E., 1981, Evolutionary Economics, Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
Brown, Charles, Judith Connor, Steven Heeringa and John Jackson, 1990a, ‘Studying (Small) Businesses with the Michigan Employment Security Commission Longitudinal Data Base’, Small Business Economics 2, 261–277.
Brown, Charles, James Hamilton and James Medoff, 1990b, Employers Large and Small, Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Carroll, Glenn R., 1987, Publish and Perish: The Organizational Ecology of Newspaper Industries, Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press.
Carroll, Glenn R. and Jacques Delacroix, 1982, ‘Organizational Mortality in the Newspaper Industries of Argentina and Ireland: An Ecological Approach’, Administrative Science Quarterly 28, 169–198.
Davis, Steven J., John Haltiwanger and Scott Schuh, 1993, ‘Small Business and Job Creation: Dissecting the Myth and Reassessing the Facts’, Working Paper No. 4492, National Bureau of Economic Research: Cambridge, MA.
Davis, Steven J., John Haltiwanger and Scott Schuh, 1994, ‘Small Business and Job Creation: Dissecting the Myth and Reassessing the Facts’, Business Economics 19(3), July, 13–20.
Delacroix, Jacques and Glenn R. Carroll, 1983, ‘Organizational Foundings: An Ecological Study of the Newspaper Industries of Argentina and Ireland’, Administrative Science Quarterly 28, 274–291.
Delacroix, Jacques and Michael E. Solt, 1988, ‘Niche Formations and Foundings in the California Wine Industry, 1941–84’, in Glenn R. Carroll (ed.), Ecological Models of Organizations, Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
Dennis, William J., Jr., Bruce D. Phillips and Edward Starr, 1994, ‘Small Business Job Cration: The Findings and Their Critics’, Business Economics XXIX(33), 23–30.
Dunne, Timothy, Mark J. Roberts and Larry Samuelson, 1988, ‘Patterns of Firm Entry and Exit in U.S. Manufacturing Industries’, Rand Journal of Economics 19(4), 495–515.
Hannan, Michael T. and John Freemen, 1987, ‘The Ecology of Organizational Founding: American Labor Unions, 1836–1985’, American Journal of Sociology 92, 910–943.
Hannan, Michael T. and John Freeman, 1988, ‘The Ecology of Organizational Mortality: American Labor Unions, 1836–1985’, American Journal of Sociology 94, 25–52.
Hannan, Michael T. and John Freeman, 1989, Organizational Ecology, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Harrison, Bennett, 1994, ,Lean and Mean, Basic Books: New York.
Ijiri, Yuri and Herbert A. Simon, 1964, ‘Business Growth and Firm Size’, American Economic Review 54 (March), 77–89.
Jackson, John E., 1995, ‘Firm Size and the Dynamics in a Market Economy’, unpublished working paper, Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan: Ann Arbor, MI.
Kirchhoff, Bruce A. and Bruce D. Phillips, 1989, ‘Innovation and Growth Among New Firms in the U.S. Economy’, Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research, Babson College: Wellesley, MA, pp. 173–188.
Kirchhoff, Bruce A., 1994, Entrepreneurship and Dynamic Capitalism, Praeger: Westport, Conn.
Lovemen, Gary and Werner Sengenberger, 1990, ‘Introduction: Economic and Social Reorganization in the Small and Medium Sized Enterprise Sector’, in Werner Sengenberger, Gary Lovemen and Michael J. Piore (eds.), The Re-emergence of Small Enterprises: Industrial Restructuring in Industrialized Countries, Geneva: International Institute for Labour Studies, International Labour Office.
McGuckin, Robert and Albert Nucci, 1992, ‘Survival Patterns for Small Businesses: Who Survives?’, 1991 Research Conference Report, Document 7302 (Rev. 3–92), pp. 29–33, U.S. Department of the Treasury, Internal Revenue Service, Washington, DC.
Nasar, Sylvia, 1994, ‘Myth: Small Business as Job Engine’, New York Times (March 25), D1–2.
Phillips, Bruce D. and Bruce A. Kirchhoff, 1989, ‘Formation, Growth, and Survival: Small Firm Dynamics in the U.S. Economy’, Small Business Economics 1, 65–74.
Picot, G., J. Baldwin and R. Dupuy, 1994, ‘Have Small Firms Created a Disproportionate Share of New Jobs in Canada? A Reassessment of the Facts;’ a paper presented at the Canadian Economics Association Meetings, June, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Wagner, Joachim, 1994, ‘The Post-Entry Performance of New Small firms in German Manufacturing Industries’, The Journal of Industrial Economics 42(2), June, 141–154.
Scherer, F. M., 1980, Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance, Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.
Schumpeter, Joseph, 1975 (1942), Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy, New York: Harper and Row.
Smith, Adam, 1965 (1776), The Wealth of Nations, New York: Random House/Modern Library.
U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, 1981, 1977 Enterprise Statistics, Washington, DC, U.S. Government Printing Office.
U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, 1991, 1987 Enterprise Statistics, Washington, DC, U.S. Government Printing Office.
U.S. Small Business Administration, 1989, The State of Small Business: A Report of the President, Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Walsh, Vivian C., 1970, Introduction to Comtemporary Microeconomics, New York: McGraw-Hill.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kirchhoff, B.A., Greene, P.G. Understanding the Theoretical and Empirical Content of Critiques of U.S. Job Creation Research. Small Business Economics 10, 153–169 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007901132681
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007901132681