Depth of comprehension and sentence memory1

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-5371(74)80034-4Get rights and content

Effects of comprehension depth upon sentence recall are examined. Three language information-processing tasks were performed on semantically heterogeneous sentences. In a within-subjects condition, subjects (a) judged sentence meaningfulness, (b) judged whether a sentence followed from context, (c) invented a sentence to follow a stimulus sentence. Tasks (b) and (c) have previously been shown to induce deeper comprehension than Task (a). Between-subjects conditions were size of recall cue; group versus individual administration; and incidental versus intentional learning. Meaning recall and exact word recall were used to assess sentence memory. Both measures warranted essentially similar conclusions. Most importantly, deeper comprehension leads to better recall; this outcome supports use of memory measures as an estimate of comprehension. Size of cue substantially affects recall; group versus individual administration and incidental versus intentional learning do not.

References (23)

  • CraikF.I.M.

    A “levels of analysis” view of memory

  • Cited by (31)

    • Feedback complexity and corrective efficiency

      1985, Contemporary Educational Psychology
    • The memorial consequences of generation and transformation

      1982, Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior
    • Feedback and content review in programmed instruction

      1979, Contemporary Educational Psychology
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    1

    This research was supported in part by General Research Fund Grant 3303 and Biomedical Sciences Grant 4943, both from the University of Kansas. The author gratefully acknowledges the assistance of Roy Lachman for his helpful comment and criticisms, and of Mark Dirks, Michael Colley, J. R. Holloway, Debbee Ruttenberg, and John Stransky for running the subjects.

    View full text