Elsevier

Ultramicroscopy

Volume 111, Issue 11, November 2011, Pages 1574-1580
Ultramicroscopy

KSpaceNavigator as a tool for computer-assisted sample tilting in high-resolution imaging, tomography and defect analysis

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultramic.2011.08.003Get rights and content

Abstract

This article describes a novel software tool, the KSpaceNavigator, which combines sample stage and crystallographic coordinates in a control sphere. It also provides simulated kinematic diffraction spot patterns, Kikuchi line patterns and a unit cell view in real time, thus allowing intuitive and transparent navigation in reciprocal space. By the overlay of experimental data with the simulations and some interactive alignment algorithms, zone axis orientations of the sample can be accessed quickly and with great ease. The software can be configured to work with any double-tilt or tilt–rotation stage and overcomes nonlinearities in existing goniometers by lookup tables. A subroutine for matching the polyhedral shape of a nanoparticle assists with 3D analysis and modeling. The new possibilities are demonstrated with the case of a faceted BaTiO3 nanoparticle, which is tilted into three low-index zone axes using the piezo-controlled TEAM stage, and with a multiply twinned tetrahedral Ge precipitate in Al, which is tilted into four equivalent zone axes using a conventional double-tilt stage. Applications to other experimental scenarios are also outlined.

Highlights

► Software system for crystal tilting in tomography and diffraction contrast imaging. ► Intuitive graphical control interface allows navigation in crystal coordinates. ► System applicable to manual or automated double-tilt and tilt–rotation stages. ► Range of applications from fully manual to fully computer-controlled sample stages.

Introduction

High-resolution TEM images provide detailed information about the atomic arrangement of nanoparticles when viewed along rational crystallographic directions [1], [2]. A necessary prerequisite is the ability to properly tilt a crystalline sample into a precise zone axis orientation. However, the alignment of small crystallites along a specific zone axis is usually approached by trial and error, and depends critically on the skill and experience of the operator.

There is a growing need for controlled tilting to different zone axis orientations in order to understand the 3D structure of nanoparticles, both in terms of their atomic arrangement and in terms of their external shape, which cannot be determined from a single projection. For example, if the projected shape is square, this could imply that the particle is a cube bounded by {100} planes, or it could be a truncated octahedron bounded by {11} and {100} planes (see Fig. 1). Such ambiguities make it important to observe individual nanoparticles in different orientations along specific zone axes in order to understand their shape in 3D [3]. To achieve such tilts with the precision needed for high-resolution imaging, and with sufficient range to access widely separated zone axes is a major unsolved task for electron microscopy and a requirement for discrete tomography [4], [5], [6]. In addition, the radiation sensitivity of most materials [7] makes it important to minimize the exposure to the electron beam. Thus, tilting a sample to multiple specific orientations with minimal electron dose presents an important challenge.

Usually, sample tilting is done iteratively, by switching between the image and diffraction modes. The sample position is visible in the image mode while the sample orientation is seen in the diffraction mode. For sufficiently thick samples, a zone axis orientation is reached by following a Kikuchi band to a crossover. During tilting, the area of interest is kept in the field of view by following the sample in the image mode. The navigation from one orientation to another requires experience and patience, even when working with large crystals. If the sample is very small, such as a colloidal particle or a nanocrystalline grain, the method usually fails due to the lack of Kikuchi lines and the imprecision of the stage movements.

Another frequent cause of failure in complex tilt series is the limited range of the stage. The accessibility of a target pole within the tilt limits of the stage is usually assessed by trial and error. This often leads to incomplete experimental series when critical sample orientations turn out to be inaccessible in the course of an experiment.

To overcome these difficulties requires a software tool that correlates the orientation of the sample with the orientation of the stage. The present work describes such a software tool and illustrates how it is possible to tilt a sample to several precise zone axis orientations, even if the sample is an individual nanocrystal on a carbon support or a nanoscale precipitate in a polycrystalline matrix.

Section snippets

Description and functionality of the KSpaceNavigator

Since digital diffraction patterns can be readily recorded either by CCD or fluorescent screen cameras, the main task is to analyze the sample orientation precisely from the diffraction pattern and establish the transformation matrix that converts stage coordinates to sample coordinates. When the sample structure is known, a model of the sample can be aligned to the experimental data. If this alignment is sufficiently precise, and if it accounts for nonlinearities in the system, it becomes

Calibration and setup with an actual instrument

To match the software to an existing microscope, two microscope parameters need to be determined initially: (a) the alpha tilt axis with respect to the screen image of the diffraction pattern, and (b) the camera constant. This basic calibration step needs to be done only once for each microscope. In order to calibrate the alpha tilt, it is best to use a single crystal sample of a suitable thickness to produce a clear Kikuchi pattern, for example Si(100). In order to calibrate the camera

Application to an individual nanoparticle using the TEAM stage

The TEAM I microscope, an FEI Titan 80-300 with spherical aberration corrector for the probe and chromatic and spherical aberration corrector for the image is equipped with the TEAM stage, a novel piezo-driven tilt–rotation device [11]. To demonstrate the tilt procedure, BaTiO3 nanoparticles on an ultrathin carbon film were used. The particles were deposited from a liquid suspension and covered with a ligand hull to bind them to the substrate [12].

A suitable nanoparticle was identified, and as

Application to a precipitate using a conventional double-tilt stage

The utility of the KspaceNavigator software is not limited to the TEAM stage, or to other computer-controlled stages. As shown below, the software can be used equally well for diffraction contrast imaging in conventional, manually controlled double-tilt stages. Experiments such as a g·b analysis to determine the Burgers vector of a dislocation, the displacement vector of a stacking fault or the strain field of an inclusion are key to the analysis of materials and their structural defects [2],

Conclusion

This work describes the KSpaceNavigator, a set of software tools to control sample orientation precisely and reliably, using a control sphere that allows navigating in crystal coordinates, even for individual nanocrystals. The software can be used with any double-tilt or tilt–rotation stage, under manual or computer control. Its functionality is illustrated with zone axis tomography of a faceted nanoparticle using the fully automated piezoceramic TEAM stage, and with dark field imaging of a

Acknowledgments

Helpful discussion with Colin Ophus concerning the generation of Wulff shapes is acknowledged. We are grateful to M. Polking for supplying the nanoparticles used to illustrate the technique and for P. Ercius for useful comments on the manuscript. This work is supported by the US Department of Energy under Contract #DE-AC02-05CH11231.

References (20)

  • J.R. Jinschek et al.

    Ultramicroscopy

    (2008)
  • A. Wang et al.

    Ultramicrocopy

    (2010)
  • R.F. Egerton et al.

    Micron

    (2004)
  • K. Inoke et al.

    Acta Materialia

    (2006)
  • J.C.H. Spence

    Experimental High-Resolution Electron Microscopy

    (2003)
  • D.B. Williams et al.

    Transmission Electron Microscopy: A Textbook for Materials Science

    (2009)
  • L. Cervera Gontard et al.

    Journal of Microscopy

    (2008)
  • S. Van Aert et al.

    Nature

    (2011)
  • American Mineralogist Crystal Structure Database....
  • COD, The Crystallographic Open Database....
There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (16)

  • Low-dose electron microscopy of nanoporous materials

    2023, Encyclopedia of Nanomaterials
  • A simple program for fast tilting electron-beam sensitive crystals to zone axes

    2020, Ultramicroscopy
    Citation Excerpt :

    Kikuchi patterns under convergent-beam electron diffraction (CBED) mode have been widely used for accurately determining orientations of materials [7–10], while the high density of electrons will destroy the materials quickly. A tool “KSpaceNavigator” [11] has been developed for sample tilting in high-resolution imaging, tomography and defect analysis. Nevertheless, the orientation is determined by directly comparing the simulated and experimental SAED patterns, which requires certain knowledge of crystallography and manually tilting of a control sphere in reciprocal space.

  • Weighted simultaneous iterative reconstruction technique for single-axis tomography

    2014, Ultramicroscopy
    Citation Excerpt :

    In real space, this corresponds to a reduced resolution in the tomogram in the direction of the missing wedge. Therefore, considerable effort is put into the development of adapted specimen geometries (e.g. needles [9]), holder designs (e.g. On-Axis Rotation Tomography Holder), and novel goniometers (e.g. TEAMstage [10]) facilitating at 180° tilt series acquisition. Accurate and stable rotation holders also reduce spurious drift of the sample which eases the requirements to the alignment procedure following the acquisition.

  • Electron holographic tomography

    2013, Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science
    Citation Excerpt :

    In real space, this corresponds to a reduced resolution in the tomogram in the direction of the missing wedge. For this reason, considerable effort has been put into the development of adapted specimen geometries (e.g. needles [26]), holder designs [27], and novel goniometers (e.g. TEAM-stage [28]) facilitating a 180° tilt series acquisition. A tilt series of phase images is a suitable dataset to perform tomography because each point of a phase image represents a defined line integral of the object potential (Eq. (1)) times CE.

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text