Trends in Ecology & Evolution
ReviewTragedies and Crops: Understanding Natural Selection To Improve Cropping Systems
Section snippets
TOCs in Plants and Links to Crop Management and Breeding
Understanding how properties of plant communities arise from the traits of constituent plants is complicated by the fact that plants interact with each other, as well as with other organisms (e.g., pathogens, herbivores, or mutualists; see Glossary). The effect of a given set of traits on plant performance should therefore be viewed in relation to strategies of the other organisms in the system [1]. An issue that is receiving increasing attention in the plant ecological literature is the
Has Crop Breeding Selected Against a TOC?
Several developments make agricultural systems prone to the development of a TOC (Table 2). Wild progenitors of current herbaceous crops may have exhibited rather competitive traits compared to phylogenetically-comparable other species, while several traits contributing to competitive ability for light also increased during subsequent crop evolution 11, 12. Furthermore, planting density of crops has increased over the past century [13]. This increases resource competition, which might favor
Scope for Further Improvements in Crops Through Suppression of Naturally Evolved TOCs
If crop breeding has resulted in increases in yields through suppression of TOC-related trait expression, to what extent is there scope for further improvements along these lines? It is important to note here that crop selection has traditionally been based on visual assessments of phenotypes in the field, based on performance (e.g., yields) or easily visible traits [21] (Box 2). Less-visible traits such as roots have received much less explicit attention. Similarly, the physiological
Selective Effects of Agriculture
The previous section discussed how naturally evolved TOCs can be targets for crop breeding or improvements in crop management. However, agriculture itself entails environmental changes (e.g., application of fertilizers and pesticides; the introduction of new plant types) which might have selective effects on different organisms in the agro-ecological community (Table 2). Using the example of soil mutualistic organisms, we illustrate how these effects might favor selection for TOCs, and argue
Concluding Remarks and Future Directions
It is clear that understanding the extent and way in which natural selection under competition can lead to TOCs provides opportunities for crop breeding and management. EGT provides the key analytical tool to guide this understanding. Nevertheless, most EGT studies employ highly abstract model approaches that are mathematically tangible but lack concrete relevance for real-life situations. Probably due to this, at least in part, EGT is still poorly used in crop science or even in general plant
Acknowledgments
We thank Heinjo During, Wopke van der Werf, Ruben Milla, and an anonymous reviewer for fruitful discussions and comments on earlier versions of this manuscript. We are also grateful to a grant-in-aid provided by the Department of Plant Sciences at Wageningen University to N.P.R.A.
Glossary
- Cheater
- an individual that gains a benefit from the collective without investing in the collective itself. These individuals can also be called ‘free riders’ [3].
- Cooperation
- behavior whose evolutionary stability depends on actual benefits to another [69].
- Evolutionary game theory (EGT)
- the application of game theory to evolving populations of organisms in biology [1]. Distinctions with classic game include considering strategies as inheritable traits rather than as deliberate choices, and the
References (79)
The tragedy of the commons in evolutionary biology
Trends Ecol. Evol.
(2007)- et al.
Plant height and evolutionary games
Trends Ecol. Evol.
(2003) Plant domestication through an ecological lens
Trends Ecol. Evol.
(2015)Donald's ideotype and growth redundancy: a game theoretical analysis
Field Crop. Res.
(1999)Physiological phenotyping of plants for crop improvement
Trends Plant Sci.
(2015)Detect thy neighbor: Identity recognition at the root level in plants
Plant Sci.
(2012)Can a high red:farred ratio replace high temperature-induced inflorescence development in Phalaenopsis
Environ. Exp. Bot.
(2016)Evolutionarily stable leaf area production in plant populations
J. Theor. Biol.
(2002)- et al.
Field high-throughput phenotyping: the new crop breeding frontier
Trends Plant Sci.
(2014) - et al.
Game-theory in the ecological context
Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst.
(1983)