doi:10.1016/j.steroids.2005.03.003
Copyright © 2005 Published by Elsevier Inc.
Applications of the Vitamin D sterol–Vitamin D receptor (VDR) conformational ensemble model
Mathew T. Mizwicki, June E. Bishop and Anthony W. Norman
, 
Department of Biochemistry, University of California, Riverside, CA 92521, USA
Available online 8 April 2005.
References and further reading may be available for this article. To view references and further reading you must
purchase this article.
Abstract
Over the past 20 years much has been learned about the cellular actions of the steroid hormone 1α,25(OH)2-Vitamin D3 (1,25D). Perhaps most importantly structure–function studies led to the discovery that different chemical and physical features of 1,25D are preferred to initiate either exonuclear, non-genomic or endonuclear, genomic cellular signaling. It is well documented that both a 1α-OH and 25-OH, and a 6-s-trans, bowl-shaped, sterol conformation are absolutely required for efficient gene transcription, while 6-s-cis locked analogs and 1-deoxy, 25(OH)D3 metabolites activate a variety of non-genomic, rapid responses. These results and the observation that S237 (helix-3; H3) and R274 (H5) are the most static residues in the human 1,25D-Vitamin D receptor (VDR) X-ray construct (see B-values in pdb: 1DB1) and form H-bonds with the 1α-OH of 1,25D in the X-ray, genomic pocket (G-pocket), provided the basis for the molecular modeling experiments that led to the discovery of a putative VDR alternative ligand binding pocket (A-pocket). The conformational ensemble model generated from the in silico results provides an explanation for how the VDR can function as a receptor propagating both genomic and non-genomic signaling events. In this report the theoretical gating properties controlling ligand access to the A- and G-pockets will be compared and the model will be used to provide a molecular explanation for the confusing structure–function results pertaining to 1,25D, its side-chain metabolite, 23S,25R-1α,25(OH)2-D3-26,23-lactone (BS), and its synthetic two side-chain analog, 21-(3′-hydroxy-3′-methylbutyl)-1α,25(OH)2-D3 (KH or Gemini). In addition, evidence that the model is consistent with the pH requirement for Vitamin D sterol–VDR crystallization will be presented.
Keywords: 1α,25(OH)2-Vitamin D3; VDR; Nuclear receptor; Non-genomic; Rapid response; Steroid
 |
Fig. 1. (A) Schematic of the VDR (gray toned olive) and Vitamin D sterol (1,25D structure; see [43] and [44] for review of Vitamin D chemistry) conformational ensembles. All items referred to in the text are labeled in the figure. The mouse-trap model posits that some regions of the VDR are highly flexible in the absence of ligand and that the apo-NR is conformer-1 (1) and that binding of a genomic agonist induces H12 to close (3), thereby activating the transcription factor. The VDR ensemble model posits that ligand can sample the A-pocket regardless of the H12 conformation [11]. (B) Ribbon diagram of the VDR X-ray crystal structure [45]. The C-terminal end of helix-11 (H11) and H12 are colored orange. H2 and the β-sheet are colored yellow and the loops between H1/H2 and H5/β-sheet are colored purple. The position of the β-sheet after JN was successfully docked in the A-pocket is indicated by a gray ribbon. The genomic pocket is defined by a red Connolly surface and labeled 1,25D. The alternative pocket is defined by a blue Connolly surface and labeled JN. The surface area of the His-Rich region (imidizole R-groups rendered in wire-frame) that is exposed to solvent is depicted as a blue dotted surface. All amino acids mentioned in the text are shown in wire-frame and labeled. (C) Approximate 120° clockwise rotation of (B). The histidine residues forming the solvent exposed His-Rich region are labeled. Oxygen atoms of explicit water molecules with X-ray B-values ≤ 30 Å2 (average B-value = 24 Å2; pdb code:1DB1) are depicted as red spheres. The coordination of these water molecules is emulated by the red dotted surface. (D) The starting conformer of the β-sheet (line ribbon, colored orange) was superimposed with the final minimized (see methods [32]) VDR LBD conformer (solid gray ribbon) docked with JN (Connolly surface rendered transparent) in the A-pocket. The starting orientation of important A-pocket amino acid residues are displayed in wire-frame, colored orange, and labeled. The final position of these residues are shown in wire-frame and colat colored. The > 3.0 Å movements of Y295 and F150 are depicted by solid red indicators. The positions of oxygen atoms (colored blue), comprising the H2O-channel that solvates H229, are shown with their Connolly surface rendered transparent. The H229 H-bonding network formed when 1,25D occupies the G-pocket is depicted by red dotted lines, while the H-bonding network when JN occupies the A-pocket is shown by black dotted lines. (E) The figure depicts the H-bonding network (black dotted lines) stabilizing pseudo-6-s-trans 1,25D molecule in the G-pocket with the highlighted ribbon backbone shown in (B) rendered to three lines. The H2O-channels (blue dotted Connolly surface) that solvate R274 and H397 are rendered so that the oxygen atom that directly coordinates to R274 or H397 is shown as a larger red sphere than the remainder of the channel oxygen atoms.
Fig. 2. Chemical structures of 1α,25(OH)2-Vitamin D3 (1,25D), 20-epi-1α,25(OH)2-Vitamin D3 (IE), 21-(3′-hydroxy-3′-methylbutyl)-1α,25(OH)2-D3 (KH), 1α,25(OH)2-lumisterol3 (JN), 23S,25R-1α,25(OH)2-D3-26,23-lactone (BS), and 25(OH)-Vitamin D3 (25D) are shown. Each compound's relative competitive index (RCI) value, and Riverside two letter code, are indicated. The RCI value is obtained using a steroid competition assay (see Methods).
Fig. 3. (A) SDS-PAGE gel of partial trypsin digest of 35S-VDRwt incubated with 10−5 M 1,25D, BS, and KH or (B) 10−5 M 1,25D and IE. The three possible H12 conformations that are believed to produce the
34 kDa (c1),
32 kDa (c2), and
30 kDa (c3) VDR-tryptic fragments are shown in Fig. 1A (manuscript submitted).
Table 1.
Calculated G- and A-pocket potential interaction energies (IE) of 1,25D and five related analogs

The chemical name and structures of 1,25D and its five analogs are presented in Fig. 2.
a Analog IE has a 20-epi side-chain stereochemistry. As a consequence its dot map profile
[32],
[41] and
[59] indicates there are substantially less side-chain conformers that fit the A-pocket, but more that fit the G-pocket compared to 1,25D. In addition, in the A-pocket the 25-OH group of IE is more solvent exposed than 1,25D's.