Short reportChanges in medical end-of-life practices during the legalization process of euthanasia in Belgium
Introduction
In several countries, regulation of physician-assisted suicide and the role of medical care in the process of death and dying are increasingly discussed (Charatan, 2006; Doyal & Doyal, 2001; Finlay, Wheatley, & Izdebski, 2005). However, until now, only the Netherlands and Belgium have formally legalized euthanasia, both in 2002 (Deliens & van der Wal, 2003). In the Netherlands, the legalization of euthanasia was the outcome of a social process, lasting about two decades (Griffiths, Weyers, & Blood, 1998), and with active involvement of the Parliament, the judicial system, healthcare professionals, patients’ lobbying groups, and ethicists (Weyers, 2001). The Dutch government also repeatedly commissioned researchers to investigate the incidence of euthanasia and other medical end-of-life decisions with a possible or certain life-shortening effect (ELDs) (van der Heide et al., 2003; van der Maas et al., 1996). In Belgium, the process of legalization of euthanasia, preceded by a debate in 1997 in the Belgian Council for Bioethics (Adams, 2001) was actually put on the political agenda in 1999, resulting in parliamentary hearings in the Senate in 2000 (Broeckaert, 2001). A vigorous debate followed in the media, and among healthcare professional organizations (Schotsmans & Broeckaert, 1999; Weber, 2001). On May 2002, the euthanasia law was already approved, allowing physicians to administer lethal drugs to adult patients under strict conditions of carefulness (Wet betreffende euthanasie 28 mei 2002, 2002). In contrast with the Netherlands, the legalization process in Belgium was thus finalized rather quickly, without broad professional consensus, and accompanied by an intensive political and social debate.
The aim of this paper is to investigate possible changes in medical end-of-life decisions with a possible or certain life-shortening effect (ELDs) occurring during such tumultuous transition period, and to look for possible explanations.
Section snippets
Study design
We compared two identical nationwide death certificate studies establishing the incidence and characteristics of ELDs in Flanders, Belgium, one conducted in 1998, before the real debate on the legalization of euthanasia started, and the other in 2001 at the end of the debate (Deliens et al., 2000; van der Heide et al., 2003). In both studies, we took a random sample (N=3999 in 1998 and N=5005 in 2001) of all deaths from the official death registries. Physicians who had signed a sampled death
Shifts in population mortality
In 1998 as well as in 2001, the annual mortality rate in Flanders was 0.9% for a stable population of six million inhabitants. The distribution of deaths’ characteristics (age, sex, educational level, cause of death) was very similar in both years. A quarter of all people died at home. Compared with 1998, somewhat less people in 2001 died in a hospital (56% versus 50%) and somewhat more in a nursing home (17% versus 21%) (not shown in table).
Incidence and characteristics of end-of-life decisions
The proportion of sudden deaths, non-sudden deaths
Discussion
We observed remarkable shifts within medical end-of-life practices between early 1998 when the legalization process of euthanasia in Belgium started and late 2001 just before the end of this process. First, in 2001 there was a substantial reduction in the incidence of euthanasia, the use of life-ending drugs without the patient's explicit request and the alleviation of suffering with the co-intention to hasten deaths, while the incidence increased for alleviation of suffering taking into
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the Federal and Flemish Departments of Public Health for their cooperation in the data collection, and all the physicians who provided the study data in both years. We thank Greta Van Der Kelen and Jan Bernheim for their contribution in the study conception, data analysis and interpretation of the results. We thank Johan Vanoverloop for his statistical advice and Helen White for her linguistic help. The studies were supported by grants from the Fund for Scientific
References (20)
- et al.
End-of-life decisions in medical practice in Flanders, Belgium: A nationwide survey
Lancet
(2000) - et al.
The euthanasia law in Belgium and the Netherlands
Lancet
(2003) - et al.
End-of-life decision-making in six European countries: Descriptive study
Lancet
(2003) Belgian euthanasia proposal meets resistance
The Lancet
(2001)Euthanasia: The process of legal change in Belgium
Belgium: Towards a legal recognition of euthanasia
European Journal of Health Law
(2001)US supreme court upholds Oregon's death with dignity act
British Medical Journal
(2006)- Dagblad De Standaard Online. (2006). Dossier Euthanasie. [Newspaper De Standaard Online. (2006). Dossier Euthanasia]...
- et al.
Why active euthanasia and physician assisted suicide should be legalised
British Medical Journal
(2001) - et al.
The house of lords select committee on the assisted dying for the terminally ill bill: Implications for specialist palliative care
Palliative Medicine
(2005)
Cited by (46)
Changing Practices in the Use of Continuous Sedation at the End of Life: A Systematic Review of the Literature
2020, Journal of Pain and Symptom ManagementComparing Advance Care Planning in Young-Onset Dementia in the USA vs Belgium: Challenges Partly Related to Societal Context
2020, Journal of the American Medical Directors AssociationDrugs Used for Euthanasia: A Repeated Population-Based Mortality Follow-Back Study in Flanders, Belgium, 1998–2013
2018, Journal of Pain and Symptom ManagementCitation Excerpt :The study design, sampling, and mailing procedure are described in detail elsewhere.14–17 A similar study was also performed in 2001, during a period in which the euthanasia debate reached its culmination point, eventually leading to the legalization of euthanasia in 2002.18 Because of the potential bias related to conducting the study during the euthanasia legalization process, such as socially desirable answers, and the limited number of euthanasia cases (n = 18), data for 2001 are not included in the analyses.
Do physicians discuss end-of-life decisions with family members? A mortality follow-back study
2018, Patient Education and CounselingWhat lies behind a request for euthanasia or assisted suicide? A pilot study
2015, Medecine PalliativeThe experiences of relatives with the practice of palliative sedation: A systematic review
2012, Journal of Pain and Symptom ManagementCitation Excerpt :Dutch nationwide studies showed that palliative sedation is increasingly used in The Netherlands, up to 8.2% of all deaths in 2005.6,7 Palliative sedation is used in all settings where patients die, but most often in hospitals and for patients with cancer.5,8–11 Within palliative care settings, incidence estimates of the use of sedatives prior to death range from 15% up to more than 60% of patients.12–16