Elsevier

Journal of Hazardous Materials

Volume 268, 15 March 2014, Pages 177-184
Journal of Hazardous Materials

Improving the treatment of non-aqueous phase TCE in low permeability zones with permanganate

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2014.01.007Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Transport experiments used transmissive and low permeability zones (LPZs).

  • 14C-labeled TCE was used to quantify oxidation of DNAPL in LPZs by permanganate.

  • Stabilization aids prevented MnO2 rind formation.

  • DNAPL oxidation improved when xanthan and stabilization aids were used.

Abstract

Treating dense non-aqueous phase liquids (DNAPLs) embedded in low permeability zones (LPZs) is a particularly challenging issue for injection-based remedial treatments. Our objective was to improve the sweeping efficiency of permanganate (MnO4) into LPZs to treat high concentrations of TCE. This was accomplished by conducting transport experiments that quantified the penetration of various permanganate flooding solutions into a LPZ that was spiked with non-aqueous phase 14C-TCE. The treatments we evaluated included permanganate paired with: (i) a shear-thinning polymer (xanthan); (ii) stabilization aids that minimized MnO2 rind formation and (iii) a phase-transfer catalyst. In addition, we quantified the ability of these flooding solutions to improve TCE destruction under batch conditions by developing miniature LPZ cylinders that were spiked with 14C-TCE. Transport experiments showed that MnO4 alone was inefficient in penetrating the LPZ and reacting with non-aqueous phase TCE, due to a distinct and large MnO2 rind that inhibited the TCE from further oxidant contact. By including xanthan with MnO4, the sweeping efficiency increased (90%) but rind formation was still evident. By including the stabilization aid, sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP) with xanthan, permanganate penetrated 100% of the LPZ, no rind was observed, and the percentage of TCE oxidized increased. Batch experiments using LPZ cylinders allowed longer contact times between the flooding solutions and the DNAPL and results showed that SHMP + MnO4 improved TCE destruction by ∼16% over MnO4 alone (56.5% vs. 40.1%). These results support combining permanganate with SHMP or SHMP and xanthan as a means of treating high concentrations of TCE in low permeable zones.

Introduction

The release of dense non-aqueous liquids (DNAPL) into the subsurface typically results in the formation of disconnected blobs and ganglia depending on the soil's physical heterogeneity [1], [2]. Dissolved contaminants migrating from DNAPL source zones will often diffuse from transmissive regions into low permeable zones (LPZs). The residual build up of contaminants in LPZs over time becomes particularly challenging for injection-based remedial treatments because chemical oxidants typically bypass low porosity zones. Given that the mass of contaminant stored in low permeability soils can be substantial and that these LPZs can serve as a long-term source of contamination, removing chlorinated solvents like trichloroethene (TCE) from low permeablity zones is recognized as one of the most difficult problems associated with groundwater pollution [3].

Although permanganate is extremely efficient in oxidizing TCE [4], [5], treating non-aqueous phase TCE trapped in low permeable zones has significant challenges. When permanganate (MnO4) is used, the three hurdles to successfully treating non-aqueous phase TCE in LPZs include: (i) getting the MnO4 to penetrate and not bypass lower porosity zones where the contaminant is located, (ii) minimizing MnO2 rind formation at the MnO4–DNAPL interface, which can block or inhibit the DNAPL from further oxidant contact, and (iii) overcoming the kinetic constraints of treating a sparingly soluble DNAPL with an aqueous-phase oxidant. While significant progress has been made in combating these challenges, improving the treatment of chlorinated solvents in LPZs is still an active area of research.

To get remedial fluids to penetrate LPZs, shear-thinning polymers like xanthan have been used as a co-injected remedial agent to increase the viscosity of the displacing fluid [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], [11], [12], [13] and stimulate cross-flow between layers that differ in permeability [14], [15]. Smith et al. [16] provided the first evidence that xanthan was compatible with MnO4 and could be used as a polymer-enhanced chemical oxidation treatment for perchloroethylene (PCE). Their work provided important groundwork for further studies aimed at determining what polymer and oxidant concentrations were needed to effectively oxidize chlorinated solvents in low permeability zones during transport. McCray et al. [17] showed that use of xanthan increased the sweeping efficiency of MnO4 into LPZs (containing non-aqueous phase PCE) and improved the percentage PCE oxidized. Recently, Chokejaroenrat [18] found that adding xanthan enhanced MnO4 delivery into LPZs to treat aqueous-phase TCE and minimized the potential for rebound.

Treating non-aqueous phase TCE with MnO4 is more challenging than treating aqueous phase TCE due to the higher propensity for manganese dioxide (MnO2) to form. Many researchers who have treated non-aqueous phase DNAPL with MnO4 have reported the formation of distinct MnO2 rinds, which can protect the contaminant from further contact with the oxidant e.g., [19], [20], [21], [22], [23], [24]. Moreover, substantial MnO2 deposits have the potential to alter the advective flow of the oxidant from the target zone [23], [25], [26], [27]. One way researchers have combated this problem is by recognizing that soluble Mn(IV) and colloidal Mn(IV) precede the aggregation and formation of the insoluble MnO2 product. This has given rise to the use of stabilization aids. Mata-Perez and Perez-Benito [28] found that the conversion rate of soluble Mn(IV) to MnO2(s) could be delayed when phosphate was present. Kao et al. [29] found that ∼82% of MnO2 production could be inhibited by including Na2HPO4 with MnO4 without affecting TCE loss. Crimi and Ko [30] tested a variety of stabilization aids and reported that sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP) was superior in minimizing MnO2 formation.

Phase transfer catalysts are agents that facilitate reactions between two or more phases (i.e., polar, non-polar) and allow reactions to occur that otherwise might be inhibited [31]. The idea for using phase-transfer catalysts would be to allow some of the oxidant (i.e., MnO4) to partition into the non-aqueous phase DNAPL so that oxidation can occur in both the organic and bulk aqueous phases and reduce the time needed to remove the non-aqueous phase product. Seol and Schwartz [32] and Seol et al. [33] used the phase transfer catalyst, pentyltriphenylphosphonium bromide (PTPP) in bench studies and reported increased dechlorination of both TCE and PCE. Although the initial results were promising, reports of using phase-transfer catalysts under transport conditions have not yet been reported.

In this study, our objective was to improve the sweeping efficiency of MnO4 into LPZ and increase the percentage of 14C-TCE oxidized by MnO4. This was accomplished by creating a LPZ that had a high concentration of TCE and then treating with a variety of solutions that paired permanganate with: (i) a shear-thinning polymer; (ii) stabilization aids that minimized MnO2 formation and (iii) a phase-transfer catalyst. Both transport and batch experiments were performed to quantify the efficacy of these chemical additives to improve TCE oxidation.

Section snippets

Chemicals and soils

Trichloroethene (TCE; C2HCl3; ACS reagent, ≥99.5%), Oil-Red-O (an organic-soluble dye, C26H24N4O), hydrazine hydrate (35 wt% in H2O), xanthan gum (CAS-11138-66-2) and ethyl acetate were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO). Potassium permanganate (KMnO4) was obtained from Fisher Scientific (Pittsburgh, PA). Additional chemicals included: acetonitrile (Midland Scientific), nitric acid (J.T. Baker, Phillipsburgh, NJ), and sodium hydroxide (Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh, PA).

Stabilization

Transport experiments

Multiple transport experiments were performed and photographed to systematically evaluate the ability of MnO4 to penetrate the LPZ and react with the non-aqueous phase TCE, with and without chemical additives (Fig. 3). Using only MnO4, the injection front moved quickly through the transmissive zone and eventually into the LPZ (Fig. 3, Exp. A). Within 1.5 PV, a distinct rind of precipitated MnO2 began to form around the non-aqueous phase TCE. Eventually, the rind engulfed much of the LPZ and

Discussion

SHMP and TKPP are considered dispersants or stabilization aids, which mean they stabilize colloids by inhibiting particle aggregation, which leads to precipitation. The multiple mechanisms by which this occurs with MnO4 have been detailed elsewhere [30], [43], [44], [45], [46] but in brief the colloidal stability of hydrous oxides is strongly dependent on their net charge. The higher the net charge of the oxide surface, either positive or negative, the greater the repulsive forces of the

Conclusion

Improvements in the treatment of high concentrations of TCE in low permeability zones were accomplished by pairing permanganate with xanthan and stabilization aids. Using xanthan with MnO4 improved the sweeping efficiency of permanganate into LPZs but MnO2 rinds prevented good contact between the oxidant and the DNAPL. By including sodium hexametaphosphate (SHMP) with xanthan, MnO4 covered all of LPZ and no MnO2 rinds were observed. Batch experiments with LPZ cylinders also demonstrated that

References (50)

  • X.D. Li et al.

    DNAPL remediation with in situ chemical oxidation using potassium permanganate. Part II. Increasing removal efficiency by dissolving Mn oxide precipitates

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2004)
  • L.K. MacKinnon et al.

    Laboratory-scale in situ chemical oxidation of perchloroethylene pool using permanganate

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2002)
  • M.A. Urynowicz et al.

    Interphase mass transfer during chemical oxidation of TCE DNAPL in aqueous system

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2005)
  • J.L. Heiderscheidt et al.

    Intermediate-scale 2-D experimental investigation of in situ chemical oxidation using potassium permanganate for remediation of complex DNAPL source zones

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2008)
  • J.C. Marble et al.

    In situ oxidation and associated mass-flux-reduction/mass-removal behavior for systems with organic liquid located in lower-permeability sediments

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2010)
  • S.H. Conrad et al.

    Bench-scale visualization of DNAPL remediation processes in analog heterogeneous aquifers: surfactant floods and in situ oxidation using permanganate

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2002)
  • C.M. Kao et al.

    Application of potassium permanganate as an oxidant for in situ oxidation of trichloroethylene-contaminated groundwater: a laboratory and kinetics study

    J. Hazard. Mater.

    (2008)
  • M. Crimi et al.

    Control of manganese dioxide particles resulting from in situ chemical oxidation using permanganate

    Chemosphere

    (2009)
  • Y. Seol et al.

    Phase-transfer catalysis applied to the oxidation of nonaqueous phase trichloroethylene by potassium permanganate

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2000)
  • T.C. Sale et al.

    Effects of reduced contaminant loading on downgradient water quality in an idealized two-layer granular porous media

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2008)
  • D.M. O’Carroll et al.

    Infiltration of PCE in a system containing spatial wettability variations

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2004)
  • K.C. Huang et al.

    Chemical oxidation of trichloroethylene with potassium permanganate in a porous medium

    Adv. Environ. Res.

    (2002)
  • M. Crimi et al.

    Enhanced permanganate in situ chemical oxidation through MnO2 particle stabilization: evaluation in 1-D transport systems

    J. Contam. Hydrol.

    (2009)
  • H.F. Stroo et al.

    Remediating chlorinated solvent source zones

    Environ. Sci. Technol.

    (2003)
  • K.E. Martel et al.

    Laboratory study of polymer solutions used for mobility control during in situ NAPL recovery

    Ground Water Monit. Rem.

    (1998)
  • Cited by (38)

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text