Linear stability analysis of coupled parallel flexible plates in an axial flow
Introduction
The flapping motion of flexible plates or flags placed in a parallel imposed flow has been the subject of a large number of both experimental (Zhang et al., 2000, Shelley et al., 2005) and numerical studies (Connell and Yue, 2007, Zhu and Peskin, 2002). The flapping motion results from the fluttering instability of the plate's straight position under the competing effects of solid inertia, aerodynamic pressure forcing and solid flexural rigidity. In that regard, the nature of the instability is similar to that of flow-conveying pipes (Païdoussis, 1998). Beyond the fundamental interest of this instability and the resulting flapping motions, this mechanism is at the origin of the flapping of flags in the wind and is also of interest for engineering (Watanabe et al., 2002) and biomedical applications (Huang, 1995, Balint and Lucey, 2005). Hydroelastic instabilities of parallel-plate assemblies are also important in the study of industrial cooling systems, as found in some nuclear reactors (Miller, 1960, Kim and Davis, 1995, Guo and Païdoussis, 2000a).
Several models have been proposed to understand the instability threshold in the case of a single elastic plate. Shelley et al. (2005) considered the one-dimensional linear stability of a flag of infinite span and length under parallel flow forcing. Lemaitre et al. (2005) used a slender-body approximation to study the linear stability of long elastic ribbons. Kornecki et al. (1976) studied the linear stability of a finite-length cantilevered plate of infinite span, using a representation of the vortical wake as a vortex sheet (Theodorsen, 1935, Bisplinghoff et al., 1955), and Argentina and Mahadevan (2005) used a similar approach to study the influence of in-plane tension and finite span on the stability threshold. Guo and Païdoussis (2000b) considered the stability of a finite-length two-dimensional plate in a channel with various boundary conditions, using a simpler representation of the wake. Eloy et al. (2007) used the same approach to investigate the influence of three-dimensional effects on the stability of a finite-length cantilevered plate.
In the case of multiple parallel elastic plates, the imposed flow acts both as a forcing and a coupling mechanism between the motion of the plates. When the distance between the plates is of the order of or less than their length, it is expected that their dynamics will be strongly coupled. Zhang et al. (2000) generalized their soap-film experiment to two parallel filaments and showed that the filaments’ dynamics became coupled and that, depending on their relative distance, in-phase and out-of-phase modes could be observed (Fig. 1). This observation was confirmed by Jia et al. (2007) who also considered filaments of various lengths. Depending on the length of the filaments, they observed either a transition from out-of-phase to in-phase flapping when bringing the filaments close together, or a persistence of the out-of-phase mode even at small separation. These results suggest that the nature of the observed regime is strongly dependent on more than just the relative distance between the different plates or filaments. Numerical simulations (Zhu and Peskin, 2003, Farnell et al., 2004, Huang et al., 2007, Michelin and Llewellyn Smith, 2009) have also reported the existence of these two classes of regimes. Tang and Païdoussis (2009) presented a numerical study of the stability criteria for the in-phase and out-of-phase modes. More recently, Schouveiler and Eloy (2009, private communication) considered three and more coupled plates in a wind-tunnel experiment and observed various mode structures (Fig. 1). In particular, in the symmetric mode, the middle plate was observed to remain still. Guo and Païdoussis (2000a) studied the linear stability of an infinite number of parallel plates of finite aspect ratio, clamped on their side edges and free at the leading and trailing edges. They however focused only on one particular type of modes (the out-of-phase mode, where the motions of two consecutive plates are always opposite), using the resulting symmetries to significantly reduce the complexity of the system.
The purpose of the present study is to propose a linear stability analysis of N coupled flexible plates of infinite span, clamped at their leading edge in a uniform imposed flow. We investigate the existence and nature of coupled modes, that were previously observed experimentally and numerically (Zhang et al., 2000, Zhu and Peskin, 2003, Jia et al., 2007), as well as the influence of the plates’ separation on the stability of the trivial state of rest and the structure of the linearly dominant flapping modes. In Section 2, the double-wake method used in Guo and Païdoussis (2000b) and Eloy et al. (2007) for a single plate is extended to the case of an arbitrary number of equidistant parallel plates. In Sections 3 and 4, results on the linear stability of respectively two and three plates and the structure of the most unstable modes are discussed. Section 5 proposes an overview of expected results at larger N as well as a discussion of the influence of N on the critical stability curve for a fixed distance between the plates, and the nature of the corresponding dominant modes. Finally, conclusions are drawn in Section 6.
Section snippets
Description of the problem
We are interested here in the linear stability of N horizontal identical flexible and inextensible plates, placed in a parallel imposed flow along the horizontal direction. The plates’ span is assumed to be infinite so that the flow and plates’ displacements can be considered two-dimensional. The plates are clamped at their leading edge and are equally spaced along the vertical axis at a distance D from each other: the leading edge of plate j () is located at . All plates have
Stability of two coupled plates
In this section, we focus on the case of two identical flexible plates placed at a relative distance d from each other. The method outlined in the previous section is used setting .
Stability of three coupled plates
In the case of three evenly spaced identical plates, three different types of modes are obtained that correspond to the mode types observed experimentally (see Fig. 1):
- (i)
an in-phase mode (I) where all three plates flap in phase; the correlation coefficients as defined in (33) satisfy and the outer plates have the same motion;
- (ii)
an out-of-phase mode (O) where the outer plates flap in phase with the same amplitude and the middle plate flaps with a phase equal to with respect to the
Symmetry argument
In the previous sections, we have observed that all the modes are always symmetric or antisymmetric in structure with respect to the axis of symmetry (between the two plates for or on the middle plate for ). We attempt here to provide a physical argument for this observation. A mathematical proof involving the structure of the matrices in (30) is presented in Appendix B.
The orientation of the horizontal axis is physically determined by the forcing flow. The orientation of the vertical
Conclusions
Using the double-wake approach, we have performed the linear stability analysis of an array of N parallel and identical flexible plates clamped at their leading edge in a horizontal flow. The behavior of two and three plates was discussed in more detail, as well as the limit of an infinite number of plates.
This method allows one to reproduce important properties of the coupled motion of two plates observed in numerical and experimental studies. For a finite relative distance d between the
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by the Human Frontier Science Program Research Grant RGY 0073/2005.
References (29)
- et al.
Instability of a cantilevered flexible plate in viscous channel flow
Journal of Fluids and Structures
(2005) - et al.
Flutter of a rectangular plate
Journal of Fluids and Structures
(2007) - et al.
Coupled states of flapping flags
Journal of Fluids and Structures
(2004) Flutter of cantilevered plates in axial flow
Journal of Fluids and Structures
(1995)- et al.
Simulation of flexible filaments in uniform flow by the immersed boundary method
Journal of Computational Physics
(2007) - et al.
Hydrodynamic instabilities in flat-plate-type fuel assemblies
Nuclear Engineering and Design
(1995) - et al.
On the aeroelastic instability of two-dimensional panels in uniform incompressible flow
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(1976) - et al.
Instability of a long ribbon hanging in axial air flow
Journal of Fluids and Structures
(2005) - et al.
The coupled dynamics of two cantilevered flexible plates in axial flow
Journal of Sound and Vibration
(2009) - et al.
An experimental study of paper flutter
Journal of Fluids and Structures
(2002)
Simulation of flapping flexible filament in a flowing soap film by the immersed boundary method
Journal of Computational Physics
Fluid-flow-induced flutter of a flag
Proceeding of the National Academy of Science
Aeroelasticity
Flapping dynamics of a flag in uniform stream
Journal of Fluid Mechanics
Cited by (50)
Coupling performance of two tandem and side-by-side inverted piezoelectric flags in an oscillating flow
2023, Journal of Fluids and StructuresInfluence of boundary conditions on a flutter-mill
2020, Journal of Sound and VibrationEnergy harvesting of two inverted piezoelectric flags in tandem, side-by-side and staggered arrangements
2020, International Journal of Heat and Fluid FlowDeflection predictions of involute-shaped fuel plates using a fully-coupled numerical approach
2019, Annals of Nuclear EnergyCitation Excerpt :Several researchers sought to determine the natural frequencies of the plates including Kim and Scarton (1977), who combined turbulent effects with a frequency analysis of thin plates. In a different study, Cui et al. (2008) used a whetting method to determine the frequencies, and Michelin and Llewellyn Smith (2009) analyzed flutter by examining n-series of plates. Although these techniques provided good insight into the deflection of parallel plates, there is still much to be studied about fluid-structure interactions in such systems.
Interaction of gap flow with flapping dynamics of two side-by-side elastic foils
2019, International Journal of Heat and Fluid FlowStability and coupled dynamics of three-dimensional dual inverted flags
2019, Journal of Fluids and Structures