Elsevier

Journal of Biomechanics

Volume 65, 8 December 2017, Pages 138-144
Journal of Biomechanics

Upper body accelerations during planned gait termination in young and older women

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2017.10.019Get rights and content

Abstract

Transitory tasks, such as gait termination, involve interactions between neural and biomechanical factors that challenge postural stability and head stabilization patterns in older adults. The aim of the study was to compare upper body patterns of acceleration during planned gait termination at different speeds between young and older women. Ten young and 10 older women were asked to carry out three gait termination trials at slow, comfortable and fast speed. A stereophotogrammetric system and a 15-body segments model were used to calculate antero-posterior whole-body Center of Mass (AP CoM) speed and to reconstruct the centroids of head, trunk and pelvis segments. RMS of three-dimensional linear accelerations were calculated for each segment and the transmission of acceleration between two segments was expressed as a percentage difference. Older women reported lower AP CoM speed and acceleration RMS of the three upper body segments than young women across the three speed conditions. A lower pelvis-to-trunk attenuation of accelerations in the transverse plane was observed in older compared to young women, and mainly in the medio-lateral direction. As possible explanations, older women may not need to reduce acceleration as young women because of their lower progression speed and the subsequent acceleration at upper body levels. On the other hand, older women may prioritize a decrease in the whole body progression speed at expense of the involvement of upper body segments. This limits the attenuation of the accelerations, particularly in the transverse plane, implying an increased dynamic unbalance in performing this transitory task.

Introduction

Stabilization of the head with respect to the environment is fundamental to preserve whole body balance during locomotion (Cromwell et al., 2001, Mulavara and Bloomberg, 2003, Pozzo et al., 1990). As an inertial guide platform, head stability helps to maintain gaze by optimizing input from visual, vestibular and somatosensory systems (Cromwell et al., 2004, Pozzo et al., 1990). This mechanism is threatened over each gait cycle by the heel strike that provokes a sudden impact acceleration, which is transmitted from the lower body structures to the head (Cappozzo, 1991, Mulavara and Bloomberg, 2003). During level walking, young adults adopt a ‘‘head stabilization in space’’ strategy performed at the upper body level and aimed at attenuating the acceleration transmitted from pelvis to head, following a strain-reducing criterion (Cappozzo, 1991).

Head stability is influenced by gait speed (Menz et al., 2003a, Moe-Nilssen, 1998), with increasing upper body accelerations at fast speed (Hirasaki et al., 1999, Kavanagh et al., 2006, Menz et al., 2003a). In fact, older individuals typically adopt a slowness strategy by reducing walking speed and head accelerations in the antero-posterior (AP) and vertical (VT) directions, but not in the medio-lateral (ML) direction, compared to young individuals during level walking (Mazzà et al., 2008, Menz et al., 2003b). This reduced attenuation of ML acceleration may further deteriorate in more challenging circumstances than walking, leading to augmented head lateral acceleration and, thus, to an unstable reference platform for vision and vestibular systems (Lord et al., 1996).

Transitory locomotor tasks, in particular, involve complex interactions between neural and mechanical factors which may challenge upper body stability (Laudani et al., 2006) and whole-body balance to a greater extent than unconstrained walking (Nagano et al., 2013). This challenge may help to explain why the number of falls in older individuals are frequent during locomotor transitions such as gait termination (Sparrow and Tirosh, 2005, Winter, 1995). From a biomechanical perspective, gait termination is defined as a transition between steady-state walking and upright standing, which requires a minimal level of extensor torque in lower limb joints and an adjustment of foot placement: both factors are aimed at keeping the Center of Mass (CoM) behind the feet center of pressure (CoP). This regulation of CoM-CoP vector generates decelerating forces that are therefore able to reduce forward speed and terminate gait (Jian et al., 1993). The literature reports that older adults have a diminished activation of lower limb extensor muscles when terminating gait in response to a visual cue (Tirosh and Sparrow, 2005, Tirosh and Sparrow, 2004), thus outlining a reduced involvement of lower body without taking into account the role of the upper body in performing the gait termination task. In fact, as the upper body represents 2/3 of the whole body mass, its movement could effectively help in completing the task by controlling the CoM position and, therefore, peculiar acceleration patterns could be expected for this transitory task. To the authors’ knowledge, there is no study in the literature looking at the pattern of upper body accelerations during gait termination and how these accelerations are transmitted through the body along the three directions of space. These quantities are directly related to dynamic balance and have the potential to unveil peculiar motor strategies adopted by either young or older individuals (Mazzà et al., 2008).

The aim of this study was to compare upper body patterns of acceleration during planned gait termination between young and older women. It was hypothesized that older women might present lower attenuation of acceleration from pelvis to head than young, especially in the ML direction.

Section snippets

Participants

Ten healthy young women (age: 23.1 ± 1.1 years; height: 1.66 ± 0.06 m; body mass: 56.9 ± 6.6 kg) and ten healthy and independent community-dwelling older women (age: 73.8 ± 2.4 years; height: 1.60 ± 0.06 m; body mass: 62.1 ± 13.6 kg) volunteered to participate in this study. The homogeneity of the two groups with respect to the body mass parameter was verified through an independent sample t-test (p > .05). The age groups were divided according to the following inclusion criterion: 20–30 years

Results

Both mean AP CoM speed and duration in each phase are reported in Table 1. Older women had lower AP CoM speed than young women in the Approaching and Breaking Phases at each of the three speeds (F >23.384; p < .001) and in the Stabilization Phase only at fast speed (F = 10.266; p < .005). While a progressive increase of AP CoM speed was reported between speed conditions at each of the three phases in young women, such increase was observed only at the Approaching Phase in older women. The

Discussion

The main finding of this study was that older women showed lower acceleration RMS and attenuation of acceleration from pelvis to head than young, with specific patterns in each gait termination phase. In the Approaching Phase, older women showed lower ML accelerations at pelvis than young women and, associated to this, lower attenuation from pelvis to trunk on the same axis. In the Braking Phase, older women exhibited lower pelvis-to-trunk attenuation even in the AP direction. Finally, in the

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to thank Dr. Amy Maslivec for her support in data acquisition.

References (30)

Cited by (6)

  • Non-specific chronic low back pain elicits kinematic and neuromuscular changes in walking and gait termination

    2021, Gait and Posture
    Citation Excerpt :

    During GT trials, RHC1, LHC and RHC2 events were used to divide the task into two phases: i) Approaching Phase (Ph1), lasting from RHC1 to LHC, and ii) Braking Phase (Ph2), lasting from LHC to RHC2 (Fig. 1). For these trials, the instant of complete stop was also identified as when AP CoM speed fell below 0.05 m/s [21]; instantaneous walking speed at RHC1, LHC and RHC2 was estimated from AP CoM speed to evaluate the rate of deceleration over the GT task. Length and time of the left step following the stopping signal were calculated as in the UW condition.

  • Age-related changes in upper body contribution to braking forward locomotion in women

    2019, Gait and Posture
    Citation Excerpt :

    The upper body represents 2/3 of the whole body mass and therefore its motion has a fundamental role in controlling whole-body COM position during gait termination. Noteworthy, older women have been shown to poorly dampen acceleration across upper body segments during planned gait termination at different walking velocities compared to young women [18]. However, the peculiar changes in upper body coordination and its contribution to the braking mechanism during planned gait termination have not been identified yet.

  • Mechanisms of head stability during gait initiation in young and older women: A neuro-mechanical analysis

    2018, Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology
    Citation Excerpt :

    No difference between groups existed for ML acceleration attenuation, and similar to previous studies (Kavanagh et al., 2005; Mazzà et al., 2008), both groups found it difficult to attenuate ML accelerations during the execution phase. Our data are in accordance with previous gait studies demonstrating higher AP RMS of upper body segments in young compared to older during walking (Mazzà et al., 2008) and gait termination (Rum et al., 2017). Despite young producing higher AP RMS acceleration of each upper body segment, young were able to attenuate such accelerations from the lower to the upper parts of the upper body segments to a greater extent compared to older.

  • Using Arm Swing Movements to Maintain the Walking State in a Self-Balanced Lower-Limb Exoskeleton

    2022, Proceedings - IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation
View full text