Effects of resection thickness on mechanics of resurfaced patellae
Introduction
Early total knee replacement (TKR) procedures with resurfaced patellae reported high incidence of patellofemoral (PF) complications, contributing to up to 50% of all revisions (Brick and Scott, 1988). However, improvements in component design and materials have reduced the incidence of revisions due to PF issues. Recent studies have reported incidence of anterior patellar pain of 12% and patellar fracture rates from 0.68% to 5.2% in the TKR population (Helmy et al., 2003, Dalury and Dennis, 2003, Seijas et al., 2009). While occurrence of patellar fracture is relative low, revision surgeries have reported poor outcomes with high complication rates and reoperation (Ortiguera and Berry, 2002), leaving patellar fracture as a significant concern for the comfort and functionality of the TKR population. Patellar resection thickness has been cited as a contributor to patellar fracture, anterior knee pain and extensor mechanism efficiency (Seo et al., 2012), however, the influence of resection thickness on patellar mechanics remains unclear.
During TKR, surgeons typically aim to restore pre-operative patellar thickness, with reports suggesting that this may aid in preserving the natural mechanics of the joint (Hsu et al., 1996). There are a number of concerns associated with resection of the patellar bone that may potentially lead to complications of the PF joint. Overstuffing of the PF joint may induce ligament and muscle tightness as well as limit knee flexion (Marmor, 1988, Mihalko et al., 2006), while excessive resection of the native patellar bone stock may increase strain and the risk of patellar fracture in the remaining patellar bone (Goldstein et al., 1986, Reuben et al., 1991), increase the risk of crepitation (Hoops et al., 2012), and reduce the quadriceps muscle moment arm, leading to a decrease in extension efficiency (Mountney et al., 2008). Studies have recommended against resected bone of less than 15 mm due to increased patellar bone strain at increased resection depths (Reuben et al., 1991), while others have reported no difference in clinical outcome between groups with bone remnants of less 12 mm and those with bone remnants of greater than 12 mm (Koh et al., 2002).
While clinical studies serve to identify factors which differentiate between surgical outcomes based on retrospective analysis, this necessitates high-volume datasets with numerous confounding factors which make it difficult or infeasible to identify the impact of a specific surgical decision, such as patellar bone resection thickness, on patellar mechanics. In vitro and in silico studies have the advantage of evaluating such factors in a controlled environment, isolated from additional sources of variability. A number of cadaveric studies have sought to investigate the effect of patellar resection thickness on patellar mechanics (using patellar strain as a surrogate measure for risk of patellar facture and anterior knee pain), with studies measuring strain on the anterior surface using uniaxial strain gauges reporting an increase in superficial strain proportional to the amount of bone removed (Wulff and Incavo, 2000, Lie et al., 2005, Reuben et al., 1991).
Recent computational modeling work has developed subject-specific finite element (FE) PF models with heterogeneous patellar bone material properties mapped from computed tomography (CT) images (Fitzpatrick et al., 2011). These models have been used to compare patellar mechanics in natural, implanted and unresurfaced conditions (Fitzpatrick and Rullkoetter, 2012). To date, however, they have not been used assess the influence of surgical decisions, such as patellar resection thickness, on mechanics of the patella. The objective of the current study was to determine how patellar resection thickness impacts patellofemoral mechanics, including kinematics and strain in the bone, and hence provide insight into the risk of fracture and anterior knee pain.
Section snippets
Methods
Specimen-specific FE models of the knee joint were developed in Abaqus/Explicit (SIMULIA, Providence, RI) from CT scans of three cadaveric male knees (65.7±9.9 years; 1.79±0.04 m; 76.9±13.6 kg) (Fig. 1). The specimen-specific models were implanted with a semi-constrained, posterior-stabilized TKR with dome patella (positioned under the guidance of an orthopedic surgeon) which included a fully deformable polyethylene button with nonlinear elastic-plastic representation (initial E=572 MPa, v=0.45 (
Results
Bone strain increased with increasing load across all resection thicknesses. Highly strained bone volume at a 1% strain level (strained above the 1% strain threshold of the thinnest (9 mm) patella) was markedly higher in the 9 mm and 11 mm resection thickness models than the 13 mm and 14 mm resection thickness models in deep flexion (Fig. 3).
Calculating the peak (1%) strain threshold at each resection thickness (1% of bone volume is above this strain threshold), the thinnest patellae experienced the
Discussion
Understanding the mechanical consequences of patellar resection thickness is important for the clinician in determining how much bone can be safely resected without substantially increasing the risk of patellar bone fracture and anterior knee pain. This is particularly critical for patients with small patellar geometry which would leave thin bone stock remaining post-operatively in order to maintain pre-operative thickness. While there are a variety of potential sources of anterior knee pain
Conflict of interest statement
The authors have no conflict of interest related to this work.
References (38)
- et al.
Verification of predicted specimen-specific natural and implanted patellofemoral kinematics during simulated deep knee bend
Journal of Biomechanics
(2009) - et al.
Dynamic finite element knee simulation for evaluation of knee replacement mechanics
Journal of Biomechanics
(2012) - et al.
The role of patient, surgical, and implant design variation in total knee replacement performance
Journal of Biomechanics
(2012) - et al.
Influence of patellofemoral articular geometry and material on mechanics of the unresurfaced patella
Journal of Biomechanics
(2012) - et al.
Simulation of a knee joint replacement during a gait cycle using explicit finite element analysis
Journal of Biomechanics
(2002) - et al.
Influence of patellar thickness on patellar tracking and patellofemoral contact characteristics after total knee arthroplasty
Journal of Arthroplasty
(1996) Predicting the compressive mechanical behavior of bone
Journal of Biomechanics
(1994)- et al.
Influence of patellar thickness on results of total knee arthroplasty: does a residual bony patellar thickness of ≤12 mm lead to poorer clinical outcome and increased complication rates?
Journal of Arthroplasty
(2002) - et al.
Loading of the knee joint during activities of daily living measured in vivo in five subjects
Journal of Biomechanics
(2010) - et al.
The effect of an augmentation patella prosthesis versus patelloplasty on revision patellar kinematics and quadriceps tendon force: an ex vivo study
Journal of Arthroplasty
(2008)
Comparison of isotropic and orthotropic material property assignments on femoral finite element models under two loading conditions
Medical Engineering & Physics
Mechanics of bone/PMMA composite structures: an in vitro study of human vertebrae
Journal of Biomechanics
Effect of patella thickness on patella strain following total knee arthroplasty
Journal of Arthroplasty
The material mapping strategy influences the accuracy of CT-based finite element models of bones: an evaluation against experimental measurements
Medical Engineering & Physics
The effect of patella preparation for total knee arthroplasty on patellar strain: a comparison of resurfacing versus inset implants
Journal of Arthroplasty
Intraosseous innervation of the human patella: a histologic study
American Journal of Sports Medicine
The patellofemoral component of total knee arthroplasty
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research
Extensor mechanism problems following total knee replacement
Journal of Knee Surgery
Cited by (18)
Patellar bone strain after total knee arthroplasty is correlated with bone mineral density and body mass index
2019, Medical Engineering and PhysicsCitation Excerpt :While patellar fractures after resurfacing are considered as rare (0.5–5.2%), one of the most severe complications, anterior knee pain (AKP) is much more common (0–47%) and still poorly understood [1–4]. Previous studies have shown that TKA leads to increased strain in the patella, and thus hypothesized that this strain increase could be associated with postoperative complications [5–10]. Indeed, increased strain can lead to tissue damage and thus to fatigue fracture [7].
Influence of Component Geometry on Patellar Mechanics in Posterior-Stabilized Rotating Platform Total Knee Arthroplasty
2019, Journal of ArthroplastyCitation Excerpt :During weight-bearing, the anatomic patella displayed higher PF flexion relative to the dome geometry. The lower PF flexion of subjects with dome geometry may impact the extensor strength as the levering mechanism provided by the patella becomes less effective by moving the PF contact center of pressure more proximal on the patella [24–27]. Possibly for this reason, dome subjects exhibited lower average extensor strength compared with anatomic subjects.
Patellar component design influences size selection and coverage
2017, KneeCitation Excerpt :Patella fracture can occur due to excessive resection of the native patella [23,27]. With links to patellar fracture and potentially anterior knee pain, Fitzpatrick et al. have investigated the distribution of bone strain and the effects of varying resection thickness [24,25]. Using a series of subject-specific models, mechanical changes in the extensor moment arm, kinematics, and distribution of bone strain were evaluated with changes in resection depth [25].
Importance of trabecular anisotropy in finite element predictions of patellar strain after Total Knee Arthroplasty
2017, Medical Engineering and PhysicsRole of Patellofemoral Offset in Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Randomized Trial
2017, Orthopedic Clinics of North America