doi:10.1016/j.ijpharm.2004.09.024
Copyright © 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Vitamins C and E reverse effect of herbicide-induced toxicity on human epidermal cells HaCaT: a biochemometric approach
Audrey Gehin, Yves Claude Guillaume, Joëlle Millet, Catherine Guyon and Laurence Nicod
, 
Equipe des Sciences Séparatives et Biopharmaceutiques (EA 482), UFR Médecine — Pharmacie, Place Saint Jacques, F-25030 Besançon Cedex, France
Received 15 April 2004;
revised 22 September 2004;
accepted 25 September 2004.
Available online 8 December 2004.
References and further reading may be available for this article. To view references and further reading you must
purchase this article.
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to investigate and compare the cytotoxicity of glyphosate alone or included in Roundup 3 plus® modulated by the cytoprotective effects of additional antioxidants such as Vitamin C and Vitamin E on the human keratinocytes cell line HaCaT. An experimental design which allows to minimize the number of experiments was carried out to determine the optimal conditions for cytoprotection against herbicide-induced toxicity. It was shown that HaCaT cell line provides a useful model to study components with toxicity or antioxidant activity. Our results indicated that (i) glyphosate-based formulations can be responsible for oxidative damage to human epidermal cells, (ii) antioxidant compounds should be associated to herbicide formulations to decrease their deleterious effects on human skin. The use of an experimental design connected with the simplex method can be consider to be a fast technique to classify, with a limited number of experiments, the respective role of five parameters in the in vitro cytoprotection by antioxidants of herbicide-induced toxicity.
Keywords: Keratinocytes HaCaT; Experimental design; Cytotoxicity; Herbicide; Antioxidant activity
Fig. 1. The structure of glyphosate (a), Vitamin C (b) and Vitamin E (c).
Fig. 2. Cytotoxicity profiles of glyphosate (●) and Roundup 3 plus® (■) in cultured HaCat cells after 24 h of treatment. The results expressed as percentage of controls, are given as means ± standard deviation of at least three independent experiments, each being performed in triplicate.
Fig. 3. Effects of the parameters on the IC50 (inhibition concentration 50%) values where x1 represents the herbicide formulation (level 1: glyphosate; level 2: Roundup 3 plus®), and x2 the antioxidant substance (level 1: Vitamin C; level 2: Vitamin E; level 3: Vitamin C + Vitamin E), x3 the antioxidant concentration (μM) (level 1: 0; level 2: 100; level 3: 200), x4 the incubation period of antioxidant (h) (level 1: 0; level 2: 24; level 3: 48), x5 the cell density (level 1: 4 × 104; level 2: 5 × 104; level 3: 6 × 104).
Fig. 4. Effects of the parameters on the slope values, where x1 represents the herbicide formulation (level 1: glyphosate; level 2: Roundup 3 plus®), x2 the antioxidant substance (level 1: Vitamin C; level 2: Vitamin E; level 3: Vitamin C + Vitamin E), x3 the antioxidant concentration (μM) (level 1: 0; level 2: 100; level 3: 200), x4 the incubation period of antioxidant (h) (level 1: 0; level 2: 24; level 3: 48), and x5 the cell density (level 1: 4 × 104; level 2: 5 × 104; level 3: 6 × 104).
Table 1.
The five parameters (from x1 to x5) and the three levels (from 1 to 3) for each parameter

Table 2.
Second-order experimental design for five parameters (from x1 to x5), where each level was coded from 1 to 3: 18 experiments

x1: herbicide formulation, x2: antioxidant substance, x3: antioxidant concentration (μM), x4: incubation period of antioxidant (h), x5: cell density.
Table 3.
Measured Ym and calculated Yc IC50 (inhibition concentration 50%) in 18 assayed conditions of the experimental design

x1: herbicide formulation, x2: antioxidant substance, x3: antioxidant concentration (μM), x4: incubation period of antioxidant (h), x5: cell density.
Table 4.
Measured Ym and calculated Yc slope in 18 assayed conditions of the experimental design

x1: herbicide formulation, x2: antioxidant substance, x3: antioxidant concentration (μM), x4: incubation period of antioxidant (h), x5: cell density.