Evaluation of yield regulation options for primary forest in Tapajós National Forest, Brazil

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2006.05.047Get rights and content

Abstract

The sustainability of a range of forest management scenarios were evaluated for the Tapajós region of the Brazilian Amazon using the growth and yield simulation model, Simflora, a derivative of the model SYMFOR developed for application in Indonesia. A simulation of current management regulations based upon a maximum extracted volume of 35 m3 ha−1 and a 30-year cutting cycle was found to be unsustainable. A range of alternative specifications for the control (regulation) of harvested timber yield were compared, along with associated estimates of timber increment and description of the ecological composition of the stand. The alternative scenarios included cutting cycles ranging from 10 to 60 years and maximum yields from 10 to 40 m3 ha−1.

The maximum commercial volume increment predicted in this study was 0.33 m3 ha−1. It was observed that the highest rates of volume increment were associated with high logging intensities. The study produced a limited number of potentially sustainable options for the Tapajós forest. The best of these were the combinations of 10 m3 ha−1 yield and a cutting cycle of 30 years or 20 m3 ha−1 with a 60-year cutting cycle. The analysis suggested that the sustainability of both of these options was “marginal” and suggested adopting a precautionary approach of an additional limit for yield to be no more than 33% of standing commercial volume until more data are available.

Analysis of the ecological data from the simulations clearly demonstrated that the composition of the managed forest is likely to differ significantly from that observed in primary forest. The most significant likely change is a reduction in the proportion of trees in the emergent ecological group. This observation raises the issue that stakeholders should not expect tropical forests that are managed for production to ever be identical in structure or composition to primary forests. It also suggests that additional technical measures will be required to promote the regeneration and growth of current emergent species if these are to be maintained in managed forests in the Amazon.

The study concludes that there cannot be a single system of yield regulation or forest management that will fit all contexts (social, ecological, environmental and economic) or management objectives held by various stakeholders in the Amazon.

Introduction

The Amazonian rain forest is the world's largest contiguous area of tropical forest (Dubois, 1991, Asner et al., 2004), being recognised for its high biodiversity and importance to global climate (Malhi et al., 2002). Selective logging is one of the main land uses in the Amazon, being very important for the regional economy. From 1996 to 2003, logging occurred at a rate of 10–20 thousand km2 year−1, being responsible for an estimated annual round-wood production of 27–50 million m3, employing 350 thousand people and generating gross annual revenue of US$ 2.5 billion (Nepstad et al., 1999, Lentini et al., 2003, Asner et al., 2005).

Currently, with very few exceptions, logging activity is part of agricultural frontier expansion and follows the world-wide pattern of the boom-bust cycle (Vincent, 1992, Schneider et al., 2000). In order to avoid the loss of forest cover and its benefits (e.g. watershed, soil and nutrient conservation, and the preservation of biodiversity), sustainable forest management has been proposed as a solution (Schmidt, 1991, Whitmore, 1991, Pearce et al., 2003).

Definitions of SFM vary widely (Vanclay, 1996, Rice et al., 1998) generally agreeing that today's use of natural forest resources should not compromise its future use in line with the original definition of sustainable development produced by the United Nations Commission on Environment and Development (“The Brundtland Report”, UN Commission on Environment and Development, 1987). Most countries impose regulations to forested lands to ensure this (Vanclay, 1996).

Yield is regulated in Brazil during the approval process of the Sustainable Forest Management Plan and Annual Operating Plans. These documents must present the minimum logging diameter, maximum mean extracted volume and cutting cycle to be used. The minimum DBH of 45 cm is generally applied with a cutting cycle of 25–30 years (Barreto et al., 1998, Grogan et al., 2004). The rule of thumb for maximum mean extracted volume has been more flexible with plans commonly approving 60 m3 ha−1, however in recent years there has been more adherence to values of 40 and 30 m3 ha−1 so 35 is used for this study. Within a species, up to 90% of the trees above the minimum diameter limit may be harvested.

Growth and yield models are essential tools to evaluate forest characteristics over one or more cutting cycles. The precision of these estimates may, however, be constrained by data used to calibrate the model and assumptions used to develop the model (Vanclay, 1992, Soares et al., 1995). While many models have already been developed to simulate forest growth and ecology, only few models have been developed and applied to support forest policies (van Gardingen et al., 2002).

In the Amazon region, MYRLIN (Nicol et al., 2002) and GEMFORM (Alder, 2000, Marshall and Bird, 2002) were used in Guyana to estimate future yield. In French Guyana, an individual tree spatially explicit model was developed, called SELVA (Gourlet-Fleury and Houllier, 2000) and it was compared to a matrix model called StoMat, concluding that both modelling approaches generate similar predictions and that the current felling regime does not guarantee sustained yields (Gourlet-Fleury et al., 2005). In Bolivia, a simulation model based on diameter distribution, increment and natural mean mortality of commercial species was developed, revealing that complete volume recovery will not be possible under currently prescribed cutting cycles and minimum felling diameter (Dauber et al., 2005). The SYMFOR model originally designed for use in Indonesia (Phillips et al., 2003) was adapted for use in Guyana (Phillips et al., 2002a) and then the Brazilian Amazon (Phillips et al., 2004). This model for Brazil was further adapted for use in this study with the incorporation of new management options and translation into Portuguese to become the model SIMFLORA.

In the Brazilian Amazon, attempts to provide a technical basis for yield regulation were based on mean diameter increment and mortality of commercial species (Barreto and Uhl, 1993, Silva et al., 1995, Vidal, 2004). The initiatives related to forest dynamics modelling in the Brazilian Amazon known by the authors are (in chronological sequence):

  • (a)

    Standpro—stand class projections (Silva, 1989).

  • (b)

    Inform—diameter class and nutrient cycling hybrid model (Biot et al., 1997).

  • (c)

    Cafogrom—cohort model (Oliveira, 2000, Alder and Silva, 2000, Alder and Silva, 2001, Keller et al., 2004).

  • (d)

    Transition matrix used to predict commercial species diameter structure (Cunha et al., 2002).

  • (e)

    SYMFOR—individual tree spatially explicit model (Phillips et al., 2004).

Simflora is a framework which includes forest ecology and management models. The ecological model is individual-based and spatially explicit. Further details on its calibration and validation in Brazil and its limitations and assumptions are described elsewhere (Phillips et al., 2004).

This study aimed to evaluate options of yield regulation for primary forest in Tapajós National Forest, Brazil. The approach adopted in this study differed from previous modelling studies using data from the Tapajós region (Silva, 1989, Alder and Silva, 2000, Phillips et al., 2004, Keller et al., 2004) in that the application of ecologically-based Simflora model permitted the analysis of a wider range of logging scenarios and criteria of sustainability, moving beyond the consideration of sustained timber yield, towards the objective of sustainable management of the timber resource.

Specific objectives of the current study were to:

  • Evaluate the current Brazilian yield regulation system against objective criteria for Sustainable Forest Management.

  • Compare the current system with a range of possible alternatives derived through modifications of the length of cutting cycle and maximum harvested volume limit.

  • Analyse predicted changes in the ecological composition of forests under simulated management scenarios as a criterion of sustainability.

  • Analyse the way that the volume increment responds to management options and provide an estimate of the expected maximum commercial volume increment to be used to set limits for sustainable forest management.

  • To apply the yield and ecological analysis to define possible strategies to increase future sustainable yield from the Brazilian Amazon.

Section snippets

Data

The dataset comes from Tapajós National Forest, in Belterra municipality, Pará State (54°56′5″W and 3°18′46″S). The vegetation consists of typical terra-firme (dry-land) high forest, with basal area ranging from 30 to 35 m2 ha−1 (DBH  5 cm) and standing volume of 150–200 m3 ha−1 (DBH  45 cm). The regional climate is classified as Ami under Köppen system, with mean annual rainfall of 1900–2110 mm and temperature of 25 °C. Soils are classified as yellow latosols and topography is slightly rolling (Silva et

Timber yield

The predicted yield resulting from the current Brazilian yield regulation system with a maximum extraction of 35 m3 ha−1 and a cutting cycle of 30 years is shown as Fig. 1. This figure shows that whilst the desired harvest is achieved in primary forest (year 0), this is not sustained for any of the subsequent harvests. The observation that this system does not produce sustainable yield given the current commercial species list is supported by previous modelling studies in the Amazon region (Alder

Implications for forest management in the Amazon

Forest managers need to explore means to increase the productivity of the forests to meet their economic objectives, whilst also meeting demands from society to adapt to new social and environmental norms. In addition, the benefits associated with timber certification schemes provide incentives for change. Managers have a much wider range of options available than those explored in the current study. Previous work with the equivalent model for Indonesia (SYMFOR) (Phillips et al., 2003)

Conclusions

The simulation of growth and yield from the Tapajós region in this paper has suggested that the sustainable yield for current management practice may be as low as 0.33 m3 ha−1 year−1, or 10 m3 ha−1 over a 30-year cutting cycle. This is considerably lower than levels currently being discussed for legislation in Brazil. There is no doubt that such an approach to sustainable management will be unwelcome to some parts of the forest industry. The move towards forest certification provides an opportunity

Acknowledgements

We thank James Grogan, Mark Schulze and two anonymous reviewers for reviewing this article. The authors would like to acknowledge the staff of Embrapa Amazonia Oriental for the collection and provision of the data necessary for this work. The specific assistance of Dr. J.N.M. Silva is gratefully acknowledged for the provision of data and his helpful inputs into the design of the project and comments on this manuscript. This study was initially supported by the Dendrogene Project (a cooperation

References (62)

  • P. Soares et al.

    Evaluating a growth-model for forest management using continuous forest inventory data

    For. Ecol. Manage.

    (1995)
  • S.W. Stone

    Using a geographic information system for applied policy analysis: the case of logging in the Eastern Amazon

    Ecol. Econ.

    (1998)
  • P.R. van Gardingen et al.

    Financial and ecological analysis of management options for logged-over Dipterocarp forests in Indonesian Borneo

    For. Ecol. Manage.

    (2003)
  • J.K. Vanclay

    Assessing site productivity in tropical moist forests—a review

    For. Ecol. Manage.

    (1992)
  • A. Veríssimo et al.

    Extraction of a high-value natural resource in Amazonia: the case of mahogany

    For. Ecol. Manage.

    (1995)
  • D. Alder

    Development of Growth Models for Applications in Guyana

    (2000)
  • Alder, D., Silva, J.N.M., 2001. Sustentabilidade da Produção Volumétrica: um estudo de caso na Floresta Nacional do...
  • G.P. Asner et al.

    Canopy damage and recovery after selective logging in Amazonia: field and satellite studies

    Ecol. Appl.

    (2004)
  • G.P. Asner et al.

    Selective logging in the Brazilian Amazon

    Science

    (2005)
  • Barreto, P., Uhl, C., 1993. O potencial de produção sustentável de madeira em Paragominas–PA na Amazônia Oriental:...
  • Biot, Y., Brilhante, V., Veloso, J., Ferraz, J., Leal, N., Higuchi, N., Ferreira, S., Desjardins, T., 1997. Inform–o...
  • J.O.P. Carvalho et al.

    Growth rate of a terra firme rain forest in Brazilian Amazonia over an eight-year period in response to logging

    Acta Amazonica

    (2004)
  • U.S. Cunha et al.

    Predição da estrutura diamétrica de espécies comerciais de terra firme da Amazônia por meio de matriz de transição

    Ciência Florestal

    (2002)
  • N.R. de Graaf

    A Silvicultural System for Natural Regeneration of Tropical Rain Forest in Suriname

    (1986)
  • N.R. de Graaf

    Reduced impact logging as part of the domestication of neotropical rainforest

    Int. For. Rev.

    (2000)
  • J.C.L. Dubois

    The present status of research into management of the rain forests of Amazonian Brazil

  • FSC. Forest Stewardship Council: SLIMF....
  • S. Gourlet-Fleury et al.

    Using models to predict recovery and assess tree species vulnerability in logged tropical forests: a case study from French Guiana

    For. Ecol. Manage.

    (2005)
  • N.R. Graaf

    Reduced impact logging as part of the domestication of neotropical rainforest

    Int. Forestry Rev.

    (2000)
  • J. Grogan et al.

    Apoio científico para os padrões de manejo de madeira na floresta amazônica—a questão da sustentabilidade

    (2004)
  • J. Hendrison

    Damaged Controlled Logging in Managed Tropical Rain Forest in Suriname.

    (1990)
  • Cited by (72)

    • Sustainability of Brazilian forest concessions

      2021, Forest Ecology and Management
    • The continuous timber production over cutting cycles in the Brazilian Amazon depends on volumes of species not harvested in previous cuts

      2021, Forest Ecology and Management
      Citation Excerpt :

      The available stock for the second harvest was composed mainly by current commercial species, which were not marketable by the time of the first harvest. This new timber stock composition would be enough to ensure timber production in the next cutting cycle (see also van Gardingen et al., 2006; Keller et al., 2007; Alder et al., 2012; Avila et al., 2017). Manilkara elata, Carapa guianensis and Goupia glabra Aubl., harvested in the first cutting cycle, comprised 34% of the available timber stock for the second harvest.

    • How long does the Amazon rainforest take to grow commercially sized trees? An estimation methodology for Manilkara elata (Allemão ex Miq.) Monach

      2020, Forest Ecology and Management
      Citation Excerpt :

      Reis et al. (2014), when studying the dynamics of the diameter distribution of some Sapotaceae species 13 years after logging in the municipality of Moju, Pará State in Brazil, observed that 96% of the M. elata were below 60 cm in diameter and that individuals from the 75 cm and 85 cm size classes were recovered and concentrated on in harvesting (71% of harvested trees), but there is still a deficit in the 15 cm (32%), 45 cm (43%) and 85 cm (66.7%) classes when compared to the situation prior to the logging. In simulations performed with different logging intensities (10, 20 and 30 m3 ha−1) and cutting cycles (10, 30 and 60 years) with the Symfor model and National Forest do Tapajós data, species that have emergent trees did not recover their volume during the simulated periods and consequently presented a growth rate below that considered sustainable in international management plans (van Gardingen et al., 2006) and recommended by Brazilian law (Brasil, 2009, 2006). This result may lead to the reduction of emergent and climax species such as Manilkara elata, which may be replaced by faster-growing pioneer species, reducing the market value of the forest asset.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text