A comprehensive economic evaluation of integrated desalination systems using fossil fuelled and nuclear energies and including their environmental costs
Abstract
Seawater desalination is now widely accepted as an attractive alternative source of freshwater for domestic and industrial uses. Despite the considerable progress made in the relevant technologies desalination, however, remains an energy intensive process in which the energy cost is the paramount factor. This study is a first of a kind in that we have integrated the environmental costs into the power and desalination costs. The study has focused on the seawater desalination cost evaluation of the following systems. It is supposed that they will be operating in the co-generation mode (simultaneous production of electrical power and desalted water) in 2015: Fossil fuelled based systems such as the coal and oil fired plants and the gas turbine combined cycle plant, coupled to MED, and RO; Pressurised water reactors such as the PWR-900 and the AP-600, coupled to MED, and RO; High temperature reactors such as the GT-MHR, the PBMR, coupled to MED, with the utilisation of virtually free waste-heat provided by these reactors. The study is made in real site-specific conditions of a site in Southern Europe. Sensitivity studies for different parameters such as the fossil fuel prices, interest and discount rates, power costs etc., have also been undertaken. The results obtained are then used to evaluate the financial interest of selected integrated desalination systems in terms of a detailed cash flow analysis, providing the net present values, pay back periods and the internal rate of returns. Analysis of the results shows that among the fossil fuelled systems the power and desalination costs by circulating fluidized bed coal fired plant would be the lowest with current coal prices. Those by oil fired plants would be highest. In all cases, integrated nuclear energy systems would lead to considerably lower power and water costs than the corresponding coal based systems. When external costs for different energies are internalised in power and water costs, the relative cost differences are considerably increased in favour of the nuclear systems. Financial analysis further confirms these conclusions.
References (8)
- S. Dardour et al.
Utilisation of waste heat from the GT-MHR and the PBMR type of reactors for nuclear desalination
Desalination
(2007) - N. Bouzguenda et al.
Financing of integrated nuclear desalination system in developing countries
Desalination
(2007) - J. Margat, Water for the people of the Mediterranean: situation and perspectives, MAP Technical Report Series N° 158,...
- IAEA Tecdoc 1542,...
Cited by (60)
Innovative strategies to manage polluted aquatic ecosystem and agri-food waste for circular economy
2024, Environmental Nanotechnology, Monitoring and ManagementWater, vital for life, faces contamination threats from both natural and human-induced sources, endangering aquatic life and our well-being. As global demands increase, waste generation rises, posing environmental risks while holding untapped potential in valuable biomolecules. This paper aims to examine the profound impact of water pollution on ecosystems and human health while exploring innovative strategies for effective wastewater treatment. Conventional treatment methods, while limited, set the stage for discussion on newer techniques like Metal-organic frameworks, Alkali-activated materials, Molecular biology, and phytoremediation. These pioneering approaches promise cost-effective, eco-friendly wastewater treatment, coupled with valuable compound extraction. Integrating these solutions fosters a circular bio-economy, optimizing resource use and curbing environmental impacts. This review thus explores a path toward sustainable water pollution mitigation and resource maximization in a rapidly evolving world.
Thermal energy recovery from a Brayton cycle nuclear power plant for efficiency improvement via compressor inlet cooling: Thermoeconomic optimization
2023, Case Studies in Thermal EngineeringDue to the well-known limitations of renewable energy resources, nuclear power is considered as another alternative for carbon-free electricity generation. A great deal of interest has been paid to developing gas-cooled reactors due to their efficient and cost effective electricity generation ability. Among these systems, the GT-MHR is a promising one which employs the Brayton closed cycle for power generation with an energy efficiency of around 47% and a waste heat of around 300 MWth. The present work aims at utilizing this waste heat to produce additional power (via an ORC) and inlet gas cooling of compressor via employing absorption chiller. In this respect a combined GT-MHR/ORC/ARC structure is designed and assessed thermodynamically and economically and is compared with the standalone GT-MHR performance. A sensitivity analysis is implemented to inspect the influences of design variables, and then optimizations are conducted based on cost and exergy. Results revealed better performance for combined system in comparison to the GT-MHR. Under the optimal working conditions obtained for cost optimal design case, the combined cycle yields 12.4% higher efficiency and 9.7% lower LCOE compered to GT-MHR power plant. Another interesting outcome is obtained, as under the optimal operation, the total levelized investment cost for the novel combined cycle (9065 $/h) is less than the GT-MHR system (9285 $/h). This is due to the larger optimal pressure ratio for compressor in combined cycle which causes less helium flow rate, as a result of which the components sizes and costs are decreased.
Transport phenomena and dynamics of an evaporating water meniscus at low heat fluxes
2023, International Journal of Heat and Mass TransferIt is known that evaporation efficiency of novel solar thermal vapor generation/desalination systems can potentially increase by incorporating interfacial heat localization techniques utilizing porous wicks. The ensuing efficiency is a strong function of the geometric and thermal properties of the wicks and the ambient operating parameters. We investigate the role of these critical process parameters on the evaporation dynamics of pure and saline water from a single-layered wire mesh operating at low heat fluxes (1 kW/m2, 5 kW/m2and 10 kW/m2), which are typical for devices working on solar energy. Evaporation rates of water from stainless steel and nylon meshes are determined using non-invasive infra-red thermography and digital microscopy. A finite element based computational model is developed to understand local transient evaporation phenomenon at the microscale. Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian (ALE) formulation is used to solve the coupled transport equations on a deforming computational grid, incorporating the Fick's law of diffusion at the evaporating water-air interface. With increasing heat fluxes, there is a deviation from purely diffusion-based transport. Higher evaporation rates are observed in meshes with smaller wire diameter and higher thermal diffusivity. In addition, the decisive role of local thin capillary films is exemplified. Simulations also indicate the diminutive role of thermocapillary convection during evaporation at such low input heat fluxes. Finally, we also investigate the effect of mesh size on the nature of salt crystallization. The evolution of salt concentration gradient at the microscale is computed that complements the experimental observations. Optimal exploitation of heat localization technique for enhanced evaporation necessitates understanding of microscale mesh level local transport effects.
How green desalination via SMRs is? A techno-environmental assessment of conceptual designs for MED-TVC and RO hybrid desalination
2023, Progress in Nuclear EnergyDesalination raises concerns about the highly saline brine left after the process and usually disposed of in the sea and oceans. Further, desalination is an energy intensive process and since most of the operational units are powered using conventional fossil fuel, they are continually affecting the environment. The concerns of ecosystem degradation have always restricted the growth of the desalination industry. Due to the strong features of small modular reactors, the SMR-based desalination plants could offer significant improvements in the area of desalination environmental impacts. In this regard, this study investigates the techno-environmental aspects of three state-of-art conceptual MED-RO hybrid desalination systems coupled with a single NuScale SMR power unit to reduce the adverse discharge brine impacts. Hybridization of desalination systems could achieve the comparative advantages of both thermal distillation and membrane desalination aiming to address the socio-economic impacts originating from desalination. For this purpose, several new introduced parameters, including exergetic efficiency, Power-to-Water ratio, specific discharge salinity, intake-seawater-to-brine ratio, discharge stream enthalpy, and net greenhouse gas emissions precluded by using NuScale for different hybrid desalination schemes are assessed. The analysis was completed with the aid of the MATLAB software and THERMOFLEX module using an Excel interface. The main finding of this study is that marine impacts are better justified in hybrid desalination schemes and that further use clean reactor energy source would decrease the environmental burdens. The results show that in case of fully integrated hybrid system 244,000 tons of CO2, 1012 tons of SO2 and 910 tons of NOx could be precluded annually from releasing into the atmosphere. However, hybrid systems generally have more significant marine effects which demonstrates the necessitated further studies and corrective actions.
Performance enhancement of tubular solar still using nano-enhanced energy storage material integrated with v-corrugated aluminum basin, wick, and nanofluid
2021, Journal of Energy StorageHerein, five alternative combinations were applied on and under the still basin to enhance tubular solar still performance. Firstly, using a v-corrugated aluminum basin. Secondly, adding wick material to the v-corrugated aluminum basin. Thirdly, adding carbon black (CB) nanofluid on wick material located on the v-corrugated aluminum basin (heat localization). Fourthly, using phase change materials (pure paraffin wax) under the v-corrugated aluminum basin integrated with wicks and carbon black nanofluid (1.5 wt.%). Finally, the best case consists of the v-corrugated basin combined with wick, 1.5 wt.% CB nanofluid and CB nanoparticles with 3 wt.% were added to paraffin wax under the basin. The results showed that the productivity was enhanced by 21.4, 42.77, 58.48, 73.56, and 88.84% for the cases with the previous order. For the best case (fifth case), the thermal energy and exergy efficiencies were enhanced by 82.16 and 221.8%, respectively, whereas the cost could be saved by 22.47 %, compared to the conventional tubular solar still. Accordingly, the proposed materials and their combinations led to acceptable and feasible enhancement in the tubular solar still performance due to the improved heat transfer characteristics, and hence the increased evaporation rate.
Performance improvement of double slope solar still via combinations of low cost materials integrated with glass cooling
2021, DesalinationSolar-driven desalination methods, particularly solar stills (SS), and their improvements have been widely paid attention. Along with that, the current work aimed to evaluate the augmented evaporation/condensation performance of a modified double slope solar still (MDSSS) compared to conventional solar still (CSS). For evaporation enhancement, three alternative combinations were applied in the still basin, which consisted of nanoparticles/fluid (carbon black/water), heat localization (wick), and sensible storage (gravel) materials. In other meaning, three cases were experimented; namely: MDSSS-I with gravel immersed in carbon black (CB) nanofluid, MDSSS-II with gravel atop thermal insulation and covered with black wick, and MDSSS-III with dispersed CB nanoparticles on the top of the second case combination. These modifications were suggested to enlarge the wet area subjected to solar radiation, increase thermal conductivity, and localize the heat on the water surface. On the other hand, for condensation improvement, passive water-based glass cooling technique was integrated with all cases to degrade the glass cover temperature. Besides the experimental investigation, thermo-economic assessment analysis of the system was performed via estimating energy and exergy efficiencies, and production cost. The results proved the aimed enhancements for all cases and the best performance was achieved from the MDSSS-III. In this case, the yield, average energy efficiency, and average exergy efficiency were improved by 68, 50.6, and 146.3%, respectively, compared to CSS. In addition, MDSSS-III attained highest cost saving by 30.7% compared to CSS as the cost per liter of freshwater productivity was 0.0147 $/L, and 0.0212 $/L, respectively. Hence, integrating such locally-available materials with DSSS may open a new sight for further enhancement and increase the opportunities for establishing large-scale practical plants.
- ⁎⁎
Work performed in partial fulfillment of the PhD thesis.