ReviewElectrical tomography for characterizing transport properties in cement-based materials: A review
Introduction
In the context of global climate change, cement production contributes approximately 5–8% of the total CO2 emissions [1]. It is therefore imperative that researchers and industry are invested in developing sustainable cement binder systems and alternative cementitious materials [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]. All the while, it is important to (i) extend the service life of concrete structures thereby reducing the long-term demand for traditional cementitious binders and (ii) continually improve our understanding of the durability and transport mechanisms in novel cementitious materials [7].
Central in the discussion of a concrete structure’s durability is moisture distribution and transport. This is because many degradation processes in concrete structures, such as reinforcement corrosion [8] and ASR [9], take place in the presence of moisture. Moreover, the transport of corrosion-promoting ions, such as chloride, is facilitated by moisture [10], [11]. Inasmuch, it is logical to use moisture transport properties, such as permeability or hydraulic conductivity, as metrics for concrete durability [12], [13], [14], [15].
Concrete is, however, a highly heterogeneous material, rarely fully saturated, and often has some level of distributed cracking when exposed to environmental conditions [16], [17], [18]. As such, endeavoring to quantify the durability characteristics of an unsaturated, heterogeneous, and possibly damaged cement-based material by interpreting data from point-based measurements – alone – often leads to results that are highly variable and/or painfully frustrating to decipher. Moreover, the use of such parameters can lead to significant errors in numerical models [19] and life-cycle estimations using such models [20].
These realizations have encouraged researchers to adopt measurement regimes acquiring data from more than two points. Broadly speaking, these methods include direct and inverse methods. In direct methods, the user directly interprets a suite of measurements to gain information on the transport phenomenon of interest. The advantages of these methods are their speed, broad usage, and well-documented behavior. Within this family, multi-point resistivity methods using, e.g. Wenner probes, have proven useful in characterizing water content, pore fluid resistivity, and properties related to the pore-space tortuosity of cement-based materials [21]. One challenge in using such a method is that calibration using numerical models and precise knowledge of the samples’ mix design and condition may be required to attain accurate quantitative results [22]. In the case of Wenner probes, an “apparent” resistivity (not the true concrete resistivity, but one affected by reinforcement, contact impedance, etc.) is calculated from the measurements using knowledge of the sample geometry, injected current, and assuming that the sample is homogeneous and semi-infinite [23], [24], [25], [26], [27]. A significant body of research has addressed challenges associated with the calibration of direct electrical methods used in characterizing durability properties of cement-based materials and structures. For example, the effects of geometry [24], reinforcement [25], air content [28], temperature [29], and curing [30] – among numerous other variables – has been considered. Meanwhile, other researchers have focused on the development of new measuring apparatuses, including, e.g. multi-ring devices [31], embedded sensors [32], [33], and near-surface electrode grids [34]. As a whole, this body of research has significantly improved the robustness of direct methods to the point that direct methods have become standard in field and laboratory characterization of cement-based materials [35].
Tomographic methods are an alternative to direct methods, wherein researchers aim to gain spatial and/or temporal information on transport properties by solving an inverse problem using distributed data. In general, tomographic methods use input data to reconstruct properties such as moisture distribution, flow rates, ingress, and conductivity [36], [37]. The use of tomography for characterizing transport properties and transport-related properties in cement-based material is extensive. Broadly speaking, these methods have included radiation-based modalities such as X-ray [38], [39], [40] and -ray [41] tomography, neutron imaging [42], [43], [44], magnetic resonance imaging [45], [46], and electrical tomography (ET) [47].
Of the tomographic modalities, each have their respective strengths and weaknesses for characterizing transport properties and transport-related properties of cement-based materials. For example, X-ray tomography is often considered the modality of choice for characterizing the solid pore space of cement-based materials, while neutron tomography is arguably better suited for characterizing unsaturated flow [48]. It is important to recognize that the imaging capabilities of X-ray and neutron tomography are driven by the underlying physics of each modality. As it pertains to this work, the physical differences lie in the X-ray and neutron cross sections of hydrogen [49]. Since hydrogen has a large neutron cross section, neutron tomography is well-suite for characterizing water ingress. On the other hand, hydrogen has a small X-ray cross section, therefore X-ray tomography is not ideal for imaging water ingress. In contrast, while X-ray and neutron tomography are based on measurements from beams passing through a sample more-or-less linearly, electrical-based modalities rely on diffusive electric fields flowing through the cementitious medium [50]. As such, ET may be categorized as “diffusive” [50].
We may then conclude that the use of ET for characterizing transport properties in cement-based materials results in fundamentally different imaging characteristics compared to the aforementioned radiation-based modalities. The primary differences between ET and radiation-based modalities derive from (i) the diffusive nature on electrical fields in porous media and (ii) the contrasting behaviors of electrical and radiation-based inverse problems [51]. In principle, (i) and (ii) are relatively straightforward to conceptualize; in practice these differences result in fundamentally different abilities of electrical- and radiation-based modalities for characterizing transport in cement-based materials. To summarize, rather qualitatively, the tomographic features of popular modalities used for characterizing transport in cement-based materials are provided in Table 1.
The summary shown in Table 1 generally indicates that electromagnetic radiation-based modalities are powerful tools for characterizing transport properties at high resolution when the sample is small. The small-medium sample size range required for high-resolution imaging1 using electromagnetic radiation-based tomography results from the high attenuation of concrete [58], which has been shown experimentally in e.g. [59]. In other words, the distinguishability of electromagnetic radiation-based measurements decrease significantly as sample size increases, which is of course proportional to the loss in resolution. On the other hand, electrical-based modalities are shown to be effective for imaging large specimens at the cost of resolution, which is fundamentally linked to the diffusive nature of electrical tomography. In either case, both electromagnetic radiation- and electric-based modalities both have implementation limitations that should be noted. For example, radiation-based tomography requires a radiation source, i.e. a reactor, synchrotron, etc. which usually requires a dedicated facility. Meanwhile, electrical-based tomography is relatively easy to implement, but quantitative interpretation of results can be difficult and prior knowledge of the electrical-transport properties of interest may be required. Nonetheless, the purpose of this article is not to contrast the performance of electrical- and electromagnetic radiation-based tomographic modalities. Indeed, each modality has its strengths and weaknesses – therefore the use of a given modality should be selected based on application-specific criteria.
In this paper, we provide a first review of ET applications used for characterizing transport properties in cement-based materials. Here, we distinguish between “transport” in the holistic sense and “transport properties,” where we refer to “transport properties” as physical phenomena directly or indirectly related to the spatial–temporal movement and evolution of water, ions, etc. in the pore space of cement-based materials. Additionally, we discuss some challenges and opportunities in using for ET for investigating transport-related processes in cement-based materials. We begin by providing a necessary technical background highlighting ET imaging regimes and their corresponding inverse problems. Following, we overview applications of two- and three-dimensional ET for investigating and characterizing transport properties in cement-based materials. Lastly, a discussion of the challenges and opportunities remaining in this field is provided.
Section snippets
Background
Broadly speaking, ET is a family of imaging modalities aiming to reconstruct one or more distributed electrical properties from electrical measurements. By electrical property, we generally refer to physical properties such and resistivity , conductivity , and permittivity . When cement-based materials are exposed to a time-harmonic field, these properties are related via the admittivity function [60] written aswhere electrical impedance is the inverse of ,
Early works inspiring the use of ET for characterizing transport properties
The technical and conceptual basis of transport in cement-based materials is largely rooted in work done by researchers in geophysics, soil science, physics, mathematics, and civil engineering in the 19th century. Transport, as we understand it today, dates back to the seminal works of the 1850s, including Fick’s law (1855) [93] and Darcy’s law (1856) [94]. The laws governing transport in unsaturated porous media, partial differential equations usually solved numerically, were later updated and
Some perspective
The use of electrical tomography for characterizing transport properties in cement-based materials is a new field. This is clear when contrasting ET to X-ray and neutron modalities, which have implemented tomography or radiography for characterizing cement-based materials since the 1970s [42]. Inasmuch, we are only beginning to realize the possibilities afforded by ET for characterizing fundamental transport properties in cement-based materials. On the flip side, ET is not as well technically
Summarizing remarks and paths forward
The use of electrical tomography for characterizing transport properties in cement-based materials has come a long way since its humble roots in 1993. Indeed, at that time, researchers were solving 2D ET inverse problems having only dozens of degrees of freedom, whereas today it is not uncommon to read an article reporting solutions to 3D problems with well over 10,000 degrees of freedom. Although the challenges in ET are not only computational, this fact among others provides an optimistic
Declaration of Competing Interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgments
The author would like to thank the Dept. of Civil and Structural Engineering at the University of Sheffield for the continued support. The author would also like to thank Mohammad Pour-Ghaz (NC State), Milad Hallaji (Thornton Tomasetti), Dong Liu (University of Science and Technology of China), and Aku Seppänen (UEF) for the useful discussions and support leading up to the writing of this article.
References (153)
- et al.
Roadmap across the mesoscale for durable and sustainable cement paste–a bioinspired approach
Constr. Build. Mater.
(2016) - et al.
Paper sludge, an environmentally sound alternative source of mk-based cementitious materials. a review
Constr. Build. Mater.
(2015) - et al.
A physico-chemical basis for novel cementitious binders
Cem. Concr. Res.
(2011) - et al.
Advances in alternative cementitious binders
Cem. Concr. Res.
(2011) - et al.
Mechanical and durability properties of high performance concretes containing supplementary cementitious materials
Constr. Build. Mater.
(2010) - et al.
Effect of moisture conditions and transfers on alkali silica reaction damaged structures
Cem. Concr. Res.
(2010) - et al.
Chloride threshold level for corrosion of steel in concrete
Corros. Sci.
(2007) - et al.
Effect of sample conditioning on the water absorption of concrete
Cem. Concr. Compos.
(2011) - et al.
A comparison of methods to evaluate mass transport in damaged mortar
Cem. Concr. Compos.
(2016) - et al.
Assessment of the unsaturated water transport properties of an old concrete: Determination of the pore-interaction factor
Cem. Concr. Res.
(2011)
Water absorption in internally cured mortar made with water-filled lightweight aggregate
Cem. Concr. Res.
Modeling the three-dimensional unsaturated water transport in concrete at the mesoscale
Comput. Struct.
Modeling water absorption in concrete and mortar with distributed damage
Constr. Build. Mater.
Quantitative electrical imaging of three-dimensional moisture flow in cement-based materials
Int. J. Heat Mass Transf.
Design and validation of a multi-electrode embedded sensor to monitor resistivity profiles over depth in concrete
Constr. Build. Mater.
A quantitative analysis of the geometric effects of reinforcement in concrete resistivity measurement above reinforcement
Constr. Build. Mater.
Numerical modeling of the effects of rebar presence and/or multilayered concrete resistivity on the apparent resistivity measured via the wenner method
Constr. Build. Mater.
Test methods for on site measurement of resistivity of concrete-a rilem tc-154 technical recommendation
Constr. Build. Mater.
Effect of curing regime on concrete resistivity and aging factor over time
Constr. Build. Mater.
Examples of reinforcement corrosion monitoring by embedded sensors in concrete structures
Cem. Concr. Compos.
Temperature and moisture monitoring in concrete structures using embedded nanotechnology/microelectromechanical systems (mems) sensors
Constr. Build. Mater.
Near–surface sensors for condition monitoring of cover-zone concrete
Constr. Build. Mater.
Quantitative electrical imaging of three-dimensional moisture flow in cement-based materials
Int. J. Heat Mass Transf.
The application of x-ray absorption to building moisture transport studies
Measurement
Application of neutron imaging to investigate fundamental aspects of durability of cement-based materials: a review
Cem. Concr. Res.
Electrical resistance tomography to monitor unsaturated moisture flow in cementitious materials
Cem. Concr. Res.
Release of internal curing water from lightweight aggregates in cement paste investigated by neutron and x-ray tomography
Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A
Magnetic resonance imaging and moisture content profiles of drying concrete
Cem. Concr. Res.
Fluid-flow measurements in low permeability media with high pressure gradients using neutron imaging: Application to concrete
Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A
Gammadensimetry: A method to determine drying and carbonation profiles in concrete
NDT & E Int.
Three-dimensional electrical capacitance tomography–a tool for characterizing moisture transport properties of cement-based materials
Mater. Des.
Water transport in cement-in-polymer dispersions at variable temperature studied by magnetic resonance imaging
Cem. Concr. Res.
Electrical capacitance tomography to monitor unsaturated moisture ingress in cement-based materials
Cem. Concr. Res.
The effect of water saturation degree on the electrical properties of cement-based porous material
Cem. Concr. Compos.
Capillary porosity depercolation in cement-based materials: Measurement techniques and factors which influence their interpretation
Cem. Concr. Res.
hp-finite element discretisation of the electrical impedance tomography problem
Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng.
Less is often more: applied inverse problems using hp-forward models
J. Comput. Phys.
Detection and reconstruction of complex structural cracking patterns with electrical imaging
NDT & E International
Recent update on the environmental impact of geopolymers
RILEM Tech. Lett.
Geopolymer technology: the current state of the art
J. Mater. Sci.
Oxygen transport and corrosion of steel in concrete under varying concrete cover, w/c, and moisture
ACI Mater. J.
Effect of cracking on chloride content in concrete bridge decks
Am. Concr. Inst.
Quantifying permeability, electrical conductivity, and diffusion coefficient of rough parallel plates simulating cracks in concrete
J. Mater. Civ. Eng.
Water transport in concrete damaged by tensile loading and freeze–thaw cycling
J. Mater. Civ. Eng.
Unsaturated diffusivity functions for concrete derived from nmr images
Mater. Struct.
Variability analysis of the bulk resistivity measured using concrete cylinders
Adv. Civil Eng. Mater.
Test methods for on site measurement of resistivity of concrete
Mater. Struct.
Electrical resistivity and formation factor of air-entrained concrete
ACI Mater. J.
Activation energy of conduction for use in temperature corrections on electrical measurements of concrete
Adv. Civil Eng. Mater.
The development and combination of electromagnetic non-destructive evaluation techniques for the assesment of cover concrete condition prior to corrosion
Cited by (32)
Beam-hardening correction method for quantifying moisture content in cement paste based on X-ray radiography
2024, Construction and Building MaterialsTomography-based investigation on the early-time capillary imbibition in stained foam concrete
2023, Journal of Building EngineeringImaging of unsaturated moisture flow inside cracked porous brick using electrical capacitance volume tomography
2023, Journal of Building Engineering