The identification, implementation, and evaluation of critical user interface design features of computer-assisted instruction programs in mathematics for students with learning disabilities
Introduction
With the advanced technology of the past decade, researchers in the field of special education have made efforts to incorporate technology into the instructional curriculum for students with a wide range of disabilities in order to enhance their learning outcomes in an effective and efficient way (Ferretti and Okolo, 1996, Torgesen and Barker, 1995, Woodward and Carnine, 1993). Such efforts have made it possible for students with learning disabilities (LD) to gain access to technology which assists their learning in various subject areas such as reading, mathematics, social studies, and science (Woodward & Carnine, 1993).
In mathematics, such technology has been advocated as a potential tool for students with LD to foster their successful learning (Lin et al., 1994, Okolo, 1992a, Robinson et al., 1989). Because of the comprehensive and abstract natures of mathematics, students with LD require a sufficient number of fast-paced practices, modeling with representative examples, and immediate feedback to learn and understand mathematics (Fuchs et al., 2008, Swanson et al., 1999). Such vital instructional components can be effectively delivered by technology (Anderson-Inman, Knox-Quinn, & Horney, 1996). Also, with technology, mathematics instruction can be individualized and adapted for students with LD to meet their special learning characteristics (National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM), 2000). Given these assets, a new trend of emphasizing technology as one of the critical mathematics instructional features for students with LD has been created in the field of special education (Hasselbring et al., 1988, Swanson et al., 1999, Symington and Stranger, 2000).
As a result of this trend, a large body of research involving computer-assisted instruction (CAI), defined as the use of a computer to provide instructional content, in mathematics for students with LD has emerged and proved CAI’s effectiveness in teaching mathematics to these students (Adydin, 2005, Gleason et al., 1990, Lewis, 1998). For example, several group-design CAI studies (Moore, 1988, Trifiletti et al., 1984, Watkins and Webb, 1981) focusing on CAI versus teacher-directed instruction (TDI) found that the students in the CAI group outperformed their counterparts in the TDI group. Similarly, two single-subject design CAI studies (Howell et al., 1987, Wilson et al., 1996) focusing CAI versus TDI reported that the student(s) with LD showed achievement gains during the CAI intervention period only. These CAI studies successfully demonstrated that CAI was an effective method of improving the mathematical skills of students with LD. These studies, however, did not fully describe the CAI programs’ design features, which were the key to facilitating students’ mathematical learning (Seo & Bryant, 2009). The importance of the design features of CAI programs has been emphasized in a review of media research by Clark (1983) who claimed that the instructional principles and features embedded in CAI programs, rather than a CAI program itself, are the critical factors most closely related to students’ positive academic outcomes. In response to Clark’s argument, several researchers conducted CAI studies focusing on the effects of the instructional features (e.g., cognitive strategy or mnemonic strategy) embedded in CAI programs on the mathematical performance of students with LD and argued that these instructional features helped create successful mathematical learning outcomes for these students (Irish, 2002, Okolo, 1992b, Shiah et al., 1994).
In line with these CAI studies in mathematics for students with LD, the critical instructional features of CAI programs for students with LD have been emphasized, but the orthogonal technical issue regarding how to effectively deliver such instructional features has not been fully addressed. In other words, a good user interface scheme for delivering such instructional features effectively via the interaction between CAI programs and students with LD has not been explored. In general, a well-designed user interface plays a crucial role in delivering the content, maintaining users’ attention and interest in the content, and increasing users’ interaction with CAI programs (Cho et al., 2009, Hinostroza and Mellar, 2001). Such interaction with CAI programs can cause users to actively participate in the learning process, comprehend instruction, and, finally, improve their learning outcomes (Cho et al., 2009, Chou, 2003, Crowther et al., 2004, Hinostroza and Mellar, 2001). Particularly, in the case of mathematics CAI programs, instruction regarding abstract mathematical concepts and relationships can be effectively delivered by using various user interface features (e.g., interactive graphics and virtual simulation), thereby increasing students’ mathematical learning and understanding (Akpinar and Hartley, 1996, Kong, 2008, Pierce et al., 2007, Reimer and Moyer, 2005, Steffe and Olive, 1996). For example, interactive two- and three-dimensional graphics embedded in mathematics CAI programs allow students to visually explore the properties of geometric shapes and help them understand geometric relationships (Ittigson and Zewe, 2003, Steen et al., 2006). Given the importance of the user interface design of CAI programs for students’ mathematical learning, many studies in the field of educational technology have analyzed the critical user interface design features of mathematics CAI programs (Baki and Güveli, 2008, Jonassen et al., 2003, Kong, 2008, Pierce et al., 2007). Because the previous studies targeted normally achieving students who do not have LD or learning difficulties, rather than students with LD, a systematic analysis of the critical user interface design features of mathematics CAI programs for students with LD has been limited. In fact, there is a dearth of studies focusing on the user interface design features of mathematics CAI programs for students with LD based on an in-depth analysis of their mathematical performance and biological characteristics. Therefore, little is known about how the user interface of such CAI programs must be designed for students with LD in order to effectively deliver mathematics instructions and, consequently, improve their mathematical learning.
Given the absence of this information, this study was conducted to (1) identify the critical user interface design features of mathematics CAI programs for students with LD, (2) design and develop a multimedia CAI program, ‘Math Explorer,’ to demonstrate how the identified user interface design features could be practically embedded in mathematics CAI programs for students with LD and (3) conduct usability testing to assess whether Math Explorer was usefully designed in terms of its interface for students with LD.
Section snippets
Identification of critical user interface design features of CAI programs in mathematics for students with LD
To identify the critical user interface design features of mathematics CAI programs for students with LD, this study analyzed the relationship between the mathematical performance and biological characteristics of students with LD, and the critical mathematics instructional features for these students through a review of related studies in the field of special education (Bryant et al., 2008, Carnine, 1997, Geary, 1990, Geary, 1993, Geary, 2004, Geary et al., 1991, Geary et al., 2000, Geary et
Implementation of critical user interface design features of CAI programs in mathematics for students with LD: Math Explorer development
A multimedia CAI program, ‘Math Explorer,’ was designed and developed to demonstrate how the identified user interface design features and guidelines could be practically embedded in mathematics CAI programs for students with LD. Math Explorer was created by the researcher using Macromedia Flash Professional 8 (Macromedia, 2006) through consultations with the professors and graduate students in the department of instructional technology and the graduate students in the department of computer
Evaluation of critical user interface design features of CAI Program in mathematics for students with LD: Math Explorer usability testing
Upon completion of Math Explorer’s development, the first usability testing was conducted to assess whether Math Explorer was usefully designed in terms of the interface for students with LD and obtain participants’ feedback for revising the program. After revising Math Explorer based on the results of the first usability testing, the second usability testing was conducted to assess whether the program’s interface features were improved and well-designed for students with LD. All procedures and
Results
The scores for each usability task question for tasks 1 and 2 were collected, summed and averaged. Table 4 shows that the teachers’ average rating scores for tasks 1 and 2 in the first usability testing were 4.78 and 4.82, respectively. Given the fact that 5.0 was a maximum average score, the results for tasks 1 and 2 indicated that the teachers were satisfied with the overall interface design features of Math Explorer and able to execute the instructional activities successfully. Table 4 also
Conclusions
In the field of special education, the instructional features of mathematics CAI programs have been emphasized and considered as critical factors to improve the mathematical performance of students with LD (Seo & Bryant, 2009). Beyond the instructional features, the user interface design features of mathematics CAI programs are also critical because the instructional features can be effectively delivered depending on how the interface of mathematics CAI programs is designed. However, there is a
References (85)
- et al.
Evaluation of a web based mathematics teaching material on the subject of functions
Computers & Education
(2008) - et al.
The role of perceived user-interface design in continued usage intention of self-paced e-learning tools
Computers & Education
(2009) Reconsidering research on learning from media
Review of Educational Research
(1983)A componential analysis of an early learning deficit in mathematics
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
(1990)- et al.
Numerical and arithmetical cognition: A longitudinal study of process and concept deficits in children with learning disability
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
(2000) - et al.
Pedagogy embedded in educational software design: Report of a case study
Computers & Education
(2001) The development of a cognitive tool for teaching and learning fractions in the mathematics classroom: A design-based study
Computers & Education
(2008)- et al.
An activity – theoretical approach to investigate learners’ factors toward e-learning systems
Computers in Human Behavior
(2007) - et al.
A scale for monitoring students’ attitudes to learning mathematics with technology
Computers & Education
(2007) - et al.
Analysis of studies of the effects of computer-assisted instruction on the mathematics performance of students with learning disabilities
Computers & Education
(2009)
The use of computers in mathematics education: A paradigm shift from “computer assisted instruction” towards “students programming”
The Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology
Designing interactive learning environments
Journal of Computer Assisted Learning
Computer based study strategies for students with learning disabilities: Individual differences associated with adoption level
Journal of Learning Disabilities
Using hypermedia to improve the mathematics problem-solving skills of students with learning disabilities
Journal of Learning Disabilities
The Internet: A new frontier for pupils with severe learning difficulties
British Journal of Special Education
Equity in school computer use: National data and neglected considerations
Journal of Educational Computing Research
Teaching mathematics to students with learning disabilities
Preventing mathematics difficulties in the primary grades: The critical features of instruction in textbooks as part of equation
Learning Disability Quarterly
Instructional design in mathematics for students with learning disabilities
Journal of Learning Disabilities
Effective strategies for teaching mathematics
Interactivity and interactive functions in web-based learning systems: A technical framework for designers
British Journal of Educational Technology
Improving the quality and effectiveness of computer-mediated instruction through usability evaluations
British Journal of Educational Technology
The role of colour in visual displays
International Reviews of Ergonomics
Principles and guidelines for screen display interface
The Videodisc Monitor
Designing a visual factors-based screen display interface. The new role of the graphic technologist
Educational Technology
Authenticity in learning: Multimedia design projects in the social studies for students with disabilities
Journal of Learning Disabilities
Intensive intervention for students with mathematics disabilities: Seven principles of effective practice
Learning Disability Quarterly
Handbook of screen format design
20 Rules for arranging text on a screen
CBT Directions
Mathematical disabilities: Cognitive, neuropsychological, and genetic components
Psychological Bulletin
Mathematics and learning disabilities
Journal of Learning Disabilities
Cognitive addition: A short longitudinal study of strategy choice and speed-of-processing differences in normal and mathematically disabled children
Developmental Psychology
Numerical and arithmetical cognition: Patterns of functions and deficits in children at risk for a mathematical disability
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
Improving CAI effectiveness with attention to instructional design in teaching story problems to mildly handicapped students
Journal of Special Education Technology
Developing math automaticity in learning handicapped children: The role of computerized drill and practice
Focus on Exceptional Children
Evaluating educational software for special education
Intervention in School and Clinic
The effects of computer use on the acquisition of multiplication facts by a student with learning disabilities
Journal of Learning Disabilities
Designing and implementing mathematics instruction for students with diverse learning needs
Using peg- and keyword mnemonics and computer-assisted instruction to enhance basic multiplication performance in elementary students with learning and cognitive disabilities
Journal of Special Education Technology
Technology in the mathematics classroom
Cited by (55)
Effectiveness of digital-based interventions for children with mathematical learning difficulties: A meta-analysis
2020, Computers and EducationCitation Excerpt :Design features recommendations also include reducing the amount of instructions, using visually attractive animations and graphics as well as graphic characters to increase the learning motivation. It is also recommended to locate the mechanics in a playful environment, to avoid using too many –potentially distracting– graphics unrelated to the instructional purposes, and to present simple and consistent interfaces acting as a background for the game activities (e.g. Cezarotto; Battaiola, 2016; Seo & Woo, 2010). Highly innovative intervention programs as well as adaptive computer videogames based on neuroscience research have been recently developed for the remediation of dyscalculia (e.g. Butterworth et al., 2011; Kucian et al., 2011; Räsänen, Salminen, Wilson, Aunio, & Dehaene, 2009; Wilson et al., 2006).
Benefits, Challenges and Opportunities of Using Computer-Assisted Instruction in Mathematics Education
2024, EAI/Springer Innovations in Communication and ComputingDesign principles of an interactive tangible mobile application for students with specific learning disabilities
2023, Closing the Educational Achievement Gap for Students With Learning DisabilitiesComputer-Based Intervention Closes Learning Gap in Maths Accumulated in Remote Learning
2022, Journal of IntelligenceInfluence of Website-Based E-Learning in the Pandemic Era: Improving Students’ Creative Thinking Skills through Educational Management
2022, International Journal on E-Learning: Corporate, Government, Healthcare, and Higher Education