Selective capillary electrophoresis separation of mono and divalent cations within a high-surface area-to-volume ratio multi-lumen capillary
Graphical abstract
Introduction
Since first being demonstrated as an analytical technique for separation and determination of inorganic ionic species in 1990 [1], capillary electrophoresis (CE) has maintained its popularity, and research on theory, separation modes, instrumentation, and applications continues to be reported [2]. Ion chromatography remains the gold standard approach for separation of inorganic ions in general, although CE represents a complimentary technique, which can offer orthogonal selectivity and matrix tolerance. In terms of detection, the on-capillary ultra violet (UV) absorption detector remains the most commonly applied detection approach in CE, even though the majority of common inorganic ions do not have sufficient absorptivity to be detectable at low concentration. In 1998, the capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detector (C4D) was introduced as an alternative detector for CE [3,4], providing universal on-capillary detection for small organic and inorganic ions, without having to resort to sample derivatisation or indirect methods [5]. As a result, over the past twenty years there has been a significant number of CE-C4D based methods reported, determining inorganic and organic ion species in foodstuffs, beverages, fine chemicals and pharmaceuticals, industrial brines and solvents, natural waters and wastewaters, and other environmental samples, a recent review of which has been prepared by Kubáň and Hauser [6].
The type of capillary used in CE has not varied a great deal over the years, with the standard single channel open tubular-fused silica capillary (OT-FSC) of i.d. between 25 and 150 μm, with a polyimide coating, are typically used being the accepted physical format. Exceptions include specialty capillaries, modified to provide specific advantages, typically related to detection, such as those with expanded zones or bubble cells for extended path length detection, or those with UV-transparent coatings etc [[7], [8], [9]].
To approach optimal separation efficiency using CE, zone broadening arising/resulting from various factors, such as Joule heating, longitudinal diffusion, injection plug length, laminar flow, solute wall adsorption, electrodispersion, and detector cell size, should be controlled [9,10]. Taking longitudinal diffusion as the major cause of band broadening, then separation efficiency, expressed as plate height (H), is of course directly related to field strength (E).H = 2D/μtotE
Where D is the solute diffusion coefficient, μtot is the total ionic mobility [11]. However, higher electric field strength will results in the generation of Ohmic heat, more commonly referred to as Joule heating, which can result in loss of radial temperature homogeneity, leading to band broadening [10]. To circumvent this possibility and maintain high separation efficiency, Joule heat must be effectively dissipated, and to do so ideally capillaries with low i.d., and associated high inner surface-area-to-volume (S/V) ratios, should be used. However, sensitivity for on-capillary optical detection is reduced significantly as the optical pathlength is reduced with smaller i.d. capillaries. Where this limitation becomes critical, researchers have the option to select the above mentioned C4D, with examples including determination of glycosides [12], saccharides [13,14], amino acids [15], artificial sweeteners [16], and inorganic and organic ions [[17], [18], [19]]. In most of these examples, the best resolution and efficiency (and thus detection limits) were obtained using capillary of 10 μm i.d. or less, with relatively high concentration of background electrolyte (BGE) [13,19].
Practical disadvantages of moving towards smaller i.d. capillaries include sample loading capacity and increased capillary backpressure (particularly for sub 25 μm i.d. capillaries), which can also affect reproducible sample loading volumes. This latter issue also becomes problematic when attempting to flush the capillaries between runs with fresh BGE. Finally, there is the possibility that small i.d. capillaries offering large S/V ratio can result in unexpected (although not necessarily unwanted) interactions between the solutes and the inner surface of capillary, which may affect both efficiency and selectivity.
An interesting alternative approach to try and overcome the above conflicting issues related to small capillary i.d., high backpressure and sample loading capacity, associated with conventional OT-FSC, is the use of multiple parallel channels of small (<10 μm) i.d. within a single capillary. Such capillary formats are now widely available in numerous designs and dimensions as so-called fused-silica photonic crystal fibers (PCFs), also known as micro-structured fibers (MSFs) or multi-lumen capillaries (MLCs). The potential advantage of these fibers and capillaries, relates to the large number of precisely spaced, homogenous and parallel micro-channels, which collectively provide a significant capillary volume for sample loading (high S/V), with associated reduced flow resistance and thus compatibility with higher operational flow rates, when taken in comparison with sub-25 μm i.d. OT-FSCs.
To date, there has been very limited work reported using such MLCs in separation science, and their potential advantages and applications are still being explored [20]. However, recent investigations include wall modified MLCs for the in-capillary extraction of polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) [21] with subsequent separation using GC-MS [22], the OT-LC separation of 2–3 fluorinated species on fluorosilane wall-modified MLCs [23], as an open tubular enzyme reactor [24], as an on-line solid phase extraction device [25], and as a combined concentrator, separation column and electrospray emitter in capillary-LC-MS [26]. With regard to CE based applications, in 2011, Rogers et al. [27] first reported the application of MLCs with 30–168 channels of 3.8–5.6 μm i.d. to the CE separation of labelled peptides. They observed that compared to single channel capillaries, with equivalent cross-sectional area under the same analytical conditions, Joule heating was suppressed due to the improved heat-dissipation within the MLCs, remarkably resulting in up to 82% improvement in separation efficiency. In a similar study, MLCs with 84 channels of 4.3 μm i.d. were used as the separation capillary in a commercial CE system, showing acceptable reproducibility and asymmetry of test solute peaks (fluorescein), with the MLC demonstrating an improvement in signal strength compared to the conventional single channel capillaries with similar total cross-sectional area [28]. MLCs with 6 channels of 28 μm i.d. have similarly been applied to the separation and detection of the in-house prepared explosive ‘nitro starch’ [29], also applying fluorescence detection. In the only study published to-date combining MLCs with on-capillary C4D, a seven-channel capillary, each of 28 μm i.d., was applied to the separation of neurotransmitters and inorganic cations, and compared for sensitivity to conventional single channel capillaries of 25–75 μm i.d. [30]. In this report, similar sensitivity was reported, however the performance and details for the migration of inorganic cations were neither shown nor discussed.
Herein, we investigated the performance of MLCs in the selective CE based separation of inorganic mono- and divalent cations, using on-capillary C4D detection. The key unknowns in this study were the impact of the MLC on peak selectivity and efficiency, with the additional question on the impact of the MLC on on-capillary C4D sensitivity. Two differing MLCs were investigated, each consisting of 126 parallel channels, one with channels of 8 μm i.d. and the other format with 4 μm parallel channels. With the inherent S/V ratio of these capillary formats, a further question addressed herein, is that of wall interactions and any resultant changes to selectivity, particularly for divalent cations. To determine this selectivity was compared under similar conditions to standard single channel OT-FSCs. Results presented in the following sections show significant wall interactions were observed, effectively presenting as electrochromatographic retention of divalent cations, and delivering unique selectivity for the mono- and divalent cation mixture. To demonstrate application of the developed approach, the MLC based separations were applied to the determination of monovalent cations in several water samples of drinking water, tap water and soil extracts.
Section snippets
Chemicals
All chemicals used were of analytical reagent grade. For the preparation of all solutions and their subsequent dilution, ultrapure water (>18.2 MΩ cm) obtained from a Milli-Q® Element (Millipore, USA) was used. Stock solutions of inorganic cations were separately prepared at 50 mmol L−1 using LiCl, NaCl, KCl, NH4Cl, MgCl2, CaCl2·2H2O, SrCl2·6H2O (Sigma-Aldrich, New South Wales, Australia) and BaCl2·2H2O (AJAX Finechem Pty Ltd, New South Wales, Australia). For preparation of the background
Separation and detection of monovalent cations
To compare selectivity, efficiency and detector response, the separation of a standard mixture solution of common inorganic cations (NH4+, Na+, Ca2+ and Mg2+) at 100 μmol L−1 was carried out on both format MLCs and the standard 50 μm i.d. OT-FSC. For the two MLCs Li+ was also added to the standard mixture. A BGE solution of 20 mmol L−1 MES/His at pH 6.1 was used for separations. The resultant electropherograms are shown in Fig. 2. Electrophoretic conditions and injection volumes were kept
Conclusion
It has been shown that MLCs in CE-C4D can produce novel separation selectivity for mono- and divalent cations, based upon substantial wall interactions with the divalent ions. This selectivity results in the divalent cations migrating well removed from the monovalent ions, presenting a potential useful selectivity for samples where either class maybe present in high excess. In addition, the use of the MLC has not significantly reduced detection sensitivity or separation efficiency for the
Acknowledgement
N. Nakatani would like to thank Rakuno Gakuen University for a supporting a long-term foreign residency research.
References (42)
- et al.
New methods for chromatographic separations of anions
Am. Lab.
(1990) - et al.
Capillary electrophoresis
Anal. Chem.
(2016) - et al.
Contactless conductivity detection for capillary electrophoresis
Anal. Chem.
(1998) - et al.
An oscillometric detector for capillary electrophoresis
Anal. Chem.
(1998) - et al.
A review of the recent achievements in capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detection
Anal. Chim. Acta
(2008) - et al.
Contactless conductivity detection for analytical techniques -Developments from 2014 to 2016
Electrophoresis
(2017) - et al.
Continuous separations by electrophoresis in rectangular channels
- et al.
Characterization of band broadening in capillary electrophoresis due to nonuniform capillary geometrics
Anal. Chem.
(1994) - et al.
High Performance Capillary Electrophoresis, a Prime
(2014) Zone broadening in electrophoresis with special reference to high-performance electrophoresis in capillaries: an interplay between theory and practice
Electrophoresis
(1990)
Peak broadening in capillary zone electrophoresis
Electrophoresis
The use of capillary electrophoresis with contactless conductivity detection for sensitive determination of stevioside and rebaudioside A in foods and beverages
Food Chem.
Rapid monitoring of mono- and disaccharides in drinks, foodstuffs and foodstuff additives by capillary electrophoresis with contactless conductivity detection
Anal. Chim. Acta
Rapid determinations of saccharides in high-energy drinks by short-capillary electrophoresis with contactless conductivity detection
Anal. Bioanal. Chem.
Frequency-tuned contactless conductivity detector for the electrophoretic separation of clinical samples in capillaries with very small internal dimensions
J. Separ. Sci.
Determination of artificial sweeteners by capillary electrophoresis with contactless conductivity detection optimized by hydrodynamic pumping
Anal. Chim. Acta
Capillary electrophoresis and contactless conductivity detection of ions in narrow inner diameter capillaries
Anal. Chem.
Contactless conductivity detection in capillary electrophoresis employing capillaries with very low inner diameters
Electroanalysis
Study on the interrelated effects of capillary diameter, background electrolyte concentration, and flow rate in pressure assisted capillary electrophoresis with contactless conductivity detection
Electrophoresis
Multi-channel capillaries and photonic crystal fibres for separation sciences
Trends Anal. Chem.
Wall modified photonic crystal fibre capillaries as porous layer open tubular columns for in-capillary micro-extraction and capillary chromatography
Anal. Chim. Acta
Cited by (5)
Capillary and microchip electrophoresis with contactless conductivity detection for analysis of foodstuffs and beverages
2022, Food ChemistryCitation Excerpt :CE separation has also been performed in a multi-channel fused silica capillary with 126 channels, each with either 4 or 8 µm ID, that is characterized by a large ratio of circumference to cross section of the separation channel. Divalent Ca2+ and Mg2+ ions interact strongly with the walls of the channel, contributing to slowing their movement through the multichannel capillary compared to univalent ions (NH4+, K+, Na+, Li+), thus improving the selectivity of the separation (Nakatani, Cabot, Lam, Rodriguez, & Paull, 2019). Hydrodynamic pressure generated by a syringe pump parallel with the high-voltage electric field has been employed to increase or decrease the separation times of inorganic as well as organic cations.
Development of a background electrolyte for the determination of inorganic cations in high ionic strength samples by capillary electrophoresis with indirect UV-absorption detection
2021, Journal of Chromatography ACitation Excerpt :Therefore, for attaining good performance in these electrophoretic methods (i.e. resolution, separation efficiency, sensitivity and limit of detection), sample ionic strength should be less or similar to the BGE ionic strength. In this context, most of the published literature tends to minimize the BGE concentration and ionic strength, aiming to improve the limits of detection (LOD) [2,7,20–24]. For instance, several applications have been reported for inorganic ions in low ionic strength samples such as active pharmaceutical ingredients [25], clean water sources [13,22,26] or very diluted high ionic strength samples [27].
Capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detection for analytical techniques – Developments from 2018 to 2020
2020, Journal of Chromatography ACitation Excerpt :A dummy cell (consisting of a capacitor) was placed in the feedback loop of a second operational amplifier, whose output was subtracted from the output of the first operational amplifier with an instrumentation amplifier. Paull and coworkers [29] demonstrated that C4D may also be used on a multilumen capillary (MLC). Such capillaries may contain 126 channels of 4 or 8 µm ID in a single fused silica (FS) tube with a standard OD of 363 µm, as illustrated in Fig. 2(I).
Conjugate local thermal non-equilibrium heat transfer in a porous medium-filled cavity with a rotating cylinder: Analysis and insights
2023, Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B: Fundamentals