Considering the complexity of microbial community dynamics in food safety risk assessment☆
Introduction
Predictive microbiology has made significant contributions to food safety risk assessment and risk management (McMeekin et al., 1997). Like the results of other experimental studies, however, nagging concerns remain about the external validity of predictive microbiology models for drawing inferences about real world exposures to microbial pathogens in food. Typically, such models have been developed on the basis of monospecific cultures grown in an artificial matrix under static abiotic environmental conditions. Predictive microbiological models typically have failed to account for non-steady-state environmental conditions and diversity in the physiologic status of microorganisms and pretreatment storage conditions (McMeekin et al., 1997). Furthermore, pathogen growth rates and maximum densities are thought to be a function of the total microbial community composition and density in the food due to competition for nutrients, the production of inhibitory substances, and overall density. Thus, the potential for spoilage and other normal food microflora to competitively inhibit the growth of pathogens also raises questions about the validity of monospecific culture experimental results with respect to growth rates, maximum population density (MPD), and other aspects of pathogen population dynamics in naturally contaminated food products. Competitive inhibition of foodborne pathogens has been demonstrated for Salmonella, where the suppression of growth of all microorganisms occurred when the total microbial population density achieved the upper limit characteristic of the growth matrix (Jameson, 1962). This effect has also been reported for Staphylococcus aureus, Listeria monocytogenes, Yersinia enterocolitica, Bacillius cereus, Salmonella infantis, and Carnobacterium spp. Buchanan and Bagi, 1997, Duffes et al., 1999, Grau and Vanderlinde, 1992, Mattila-Sandholm and Skytta, 1991, Nilsson et al., 1999, Ross and McMeekin, 1991. The observed dynamics of mixed microbial populations can be highly complex, however. Buchanan and Bagi (1999) demonstrated, for example, that L. monocytogenes grown in co-culture with Pseudomonas fluorescens can attain maximum population densities that are lower, higher, or the same compared to levels of the pathogen monoculture, depending on the temperature, acidity, and availability of water in the surrounding environment. Such results indicate that fully considering the complexity of microbial community dynamics would require detailed knowledge of the food, its microbial composition and inoculum levels, the factors affecting competitive interactions, and how the food is handled during transportation, storage, distribution, and use.
Undoubtedly, predictive microbiological models based on multi-species trials would present a more realistic picture of microbial community dynamics in food products. As a practical matter, however, an experimental program that evaluates all possible combinations of abiotic and biotic environmental conditions would be prohibitively costly and time-consuming. There are also practical limits on the successful identification and enumeration of target organisms and their competitors given currently available microbiological selective culture methods. Therefore, great care in experimental design will be needed to ensure that the value of information provided by community-level studies warrants the time and resources allocated to them. From an experimental perspective, judicious use of theoretical ecology models has the potential to inform efficient community-level study design by helping to identify important regions in the experimental design space (e.g., the growth/no-growth interface). Furthermore, theoretical modeling can help to construct general explanations for specific observed results. This application of theoretical modeling can be particularly useful when results are unexpected. Therefore—as a practical matter—the insights gained from theoretical ecology may help to avert potentially unproductive disagreements arising from seemingly contradictory empirical results.
One apparent contradiction arises from the intuitive notion that ubiquitous natural spoilage flora (e.g., Pseudomonas species) will inevitably outcompete and eventually exclude comparatively rare pathogens in food products. Responses observed under experimental conditions vary considerably, however (e.g., Buchanan and Bagi, 1999). Further, theoretical ecology indicates that the course of competitive interactions between microorganisms may be substantially altered or even reversed due to variation among strains or environmental conditions or as a consequence of chance events, such as differences in initial concentrations between pathogens and other microflora within the food substrate. This paper first illustrates the consistency of seemingly incongruous results from predictive microbiological experiments with a simple model of interspecific competition, using Escherichia coli O157:H7 in ground beef as an illustrative example. We then explore how community-level microbial dynamics could be incorporated into the food safety risk assessment process.
Predictive microbiology models have been developed for E. coli O157:H7 under a variety of environmental conditions. These models predict the growth and decline of E. coli O157:H7 given environmental parameters including time, temperature, pH, and salinity. One set of equations was developed by Buchanan and Bagi (1994) based on studies of monospecific cultures grown in brain heart infusion broth. This set of equations was later incorporated into the Pathogen Modeling Program (PMP) available from the US Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service (ARS). Based on the ARS data, Marks et al. (1998) calculated the maximum population density (e.g., the observed maximum number of E. coli O157:H7 colony-forming units per gram (cfu/g)) as a function of the theoretical maximum density (TMD) and temperature. Marks et al. (1998) estimated the TMD of E. coli O157:H7 at refrigeration temperatures to be about 10 log (1010 cfu/g).
Walls and Scott (1996) compared predictions from the PMP with observations of E. coli O157:H7 growth in ground beef with natural flora and concluded that the PMP “offers reasonably good predictions of growth in raw ground beef”. In particular, Walls and Scott (1996) demonstrated growth in ground beef up to approximately 10 log. (Note that the figures in Walls and Scott (1996) present the average levels for the experimental replicates.) How is it possible that the MPD of E. coli O157:H7 co-cultured with the natural ground beef flora could approach the theoretical maximum? Initially, the experimental results for E. coli O157:H7 cultured in raw ground beef appear to contradict those reported for Salmonella, Listeria, and other pathogens co-cultured with natural foodborne microflora. These seemingly paradoxical experimental results are consistent, however, with the complex range of outcomes predicted by a simple model of interspecific competition.
Section snippets
Lotka–Volterra competition model
The Lotka–Volterra competition model provides a basic model for the population growth of two interacting species (Brown and Rothery, 1993). The approach is an extension of the logistic model for population growth of a single species limited by a maximum carrying capacity characteristic of a particular habitat. The monospecific logistic growth model describes a limited population growth rate that decreases linearly with population density due intraspecific competition. This basic approach is
Competition scenario simulation
The dynamics of simulation Scenarios 1–3 are presented in Fig. 1, Fig. 2, Fig. 3, respectively. The results illustrate how the competitive interaction simulation depends on the initial concentrations of the microorganisms. Note that Scenarios 1 and 2 Fig. 1, Fig. 2 reach the same competitive outcome—eventual exclusion of the pathogen by the spoilage organism—but they differ in the path taken. In Scenario 1 (Fig. 1), the maximum pathogen density achieved is reduced an order of magnitude below
Discussion
This paper presents a highly simplified model of complex microbial community dynamics. In order to gain additional insights into competitive interactions for experimental design or other purposes, the basic Lotka–Volterra competition model can be augmented in various ways for greater realism and generalizability. For example, one could also explore the influence of allowing the Lotka–Volterra model parameters and initial densities to vary jointly and stochastically as a function of
References (23)
- et al.
A dynamic approach in predicting bacterial growth in food
Int. J. Food Microbiol.
(1994) - et al.
Expansion of response surface models for the growth of E. coli O157:H7 to include sodium nitrite as a variable
Int. J. Food Microbiol.
(1994) - et al.
Microbial competition: effect of culture conditions on the suppression of Listeria monocytogenes Scott A by Carnobacterium piscicola
J. Food Prot.
(1997) - et al.
Microbial competition: effect of Pseudomonas fluorescens on the growth of Listeria monocytogenes
Food Microbiol.
(1999) - et al.
A prototype model structure for mixed microbial populations in homogeneous food products
J. Theor. Biol.
(1999) - et al.
Inhibition of Listeria monocytogenes by Carnobacterium spp. strains in a simulated cold smoked fish system stored at 4°C
Int. J. Food Microbiol.
(1999) - et al.
Occurrence, numbers, and growth of Listeria monocytogenes on some vacuum-packaged processed meats
J. Food Prot.
(1992) - et al.
Growth control of Listeria monocytogenes on coldsmoked salmon using a competitive lactic acid bacteria flora
J. Food Prot.
(1999) - et al.
Validation of predictive mathematical models describing the growth of Escherichia coli O157:H7 in raw ground beef
J. Food Prot.
(1996) Influence of activity sequences on competition models
Math. Model. Sci. Comput.
(1993)
Ecological Risk Estimation
Cited by (44)
Studying the metabolic factors that may impact the growth of co-cultured Listeria monocytogenes strains at low temperature
2023, Food Research InternationalA mathematical model to predict the antilisteria bioprotective effect of Latilactobacillus sakei CTC494 in vacuum packaged cooked ham
2022, International Journal of Food MicrobiologyDecline of Listeria monocytogenes on fresh apples during long-term, low-temperature simulated international sea-freight transport
2021, International Journal of Food MicrobiologyCitation Excerpt :To assess whether any food product supports the growth of L. monocytogenes, it is important to know whether the background microbial population inhibits, allows or enhances the growth of L. monocytogenes (Zilelidou and Skandamis, 2018), e.g. the absence of natural microbial load in hot-smoked fish products leads to the rapid growth of L. monocytogenes (Zilelidou and Skandamis, 2018). Growth of L. monocytogenes cannot be considered only as a result of food's physicochemical parameters but also the combination of various microbial communities (Powell et al., 2004). The initial decline in L. monocytogenes counts in the first 2 weeks of cold storage could be linked to competition between L. monocytogenes and other microorganisms that limit its survival and proliferation.
- ☆
Disclaimers: The opinions expressed herein are the views of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the US Department of Agriculture. Reference herein to any specific commercial products, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government.