From dietary restraint to binge eating: Some theoretical considerations
Abstract
A correlation between dietary restraint and the occurrence of binge eating has been convincingly shown in several investigations. However, the mediating mechanisms have not yet been elaborated in detail nor linked to empirical evidence. This theoretical gap is addressed in the following. After a short review of behavioral and metabolic correlates of dietary restraint, potential effects of restrained eating on the psychophysiological regulation of food intake are described. These effects may lead to the disruption of intake regulation and therefore can be regarded as direct causes of binge eating.
References (2)
- R.J. Tuschl et al.
Energy expenditure and everyday eating behavior in healthy young women
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
(1990)
Cited by (146)
Intuitive eating and its influence on self-reported weight and eating behaviors
2024, Eating BehaviorsIntuitive eating (IE) is an adaptive eating behavior that involves paying attention to the body's physiological signals, including eating when hungry and stopping when feeling full. A growing body of literature has examined the effect of IE on the development of maladaptive eating behaviors and body weight, even though IE is not centered around the latter. However, longitudinal observation studies among the general population are still rare. Therefore, this study aimed to longitudinally examine the links between IE and changes in body weight, maladaptive eating behaviors (reward, external, restrained eating), and overeating frequency over time. For this purpose, we used data from the first (2017) and the fourth waves (2020) of the Swiss Food Panel 2.0 survey, which included 1821 randomly selected Swiss participants. The same participants completed a self-administered questionnaire annually, measuring their self-reported eating behaviors and weight status. IE was measured with the Intuitive Eating Scale-2. Results showed that women with high IE scores were more likely to maintain their body weights (within ±2 kg) and less likely to gain weight (>2 kg) than women with low IE scores. No such effects were found for men. Furthermore, IE was linked to a reduction in maladaptive eating behaviors and overeating frequency over time in both genders. Results suggest that IE may counteract maladaptive eating behaviors, which can promote weight stability over time. Therefore, the encouragement of IE patterns seems to be a promising strategy to address problematic eating behaviors and the challenges associated with controlling food intake and prevention of overeating.
Associations of somatic depressive symptoms with food attentional bias and eating behaviors
2021, AppetiteRecent evidence suggests that atypical major depressive disorder (MDD) – whose key features include the reversed somatic symptoms of hyperphagia (increased appetite) and hypersomnia (increased sleep) – is a stronger predictor of future obesity than other MDD subtypes. The mechanisms underlying this relationship are unclear. The present study sought to elucidate whether the individual symptoms of hyperphagia, hypersomnia, poor appetite, and disturbed sleep have differential relationships with food attentional bias, emotional eating, external eating, and restrained eating. This cross-sectional laboratory study involved 103 young adults without obesity (mean age = 20 years, 79% female, 26% non-White, mean BMI = 23.4 kg/m2). We measured total depressive symptom severity and individual symptoms of hyperphagia, poor appetite, and disturbed sleep using the Hopkins Symptom Checklist-20 (SCL-20) and added an item to assess hypersomnia; food attentional bias using a Food Stroop task; and self-reported eating behaviors using the Dutch Eating Behavior Questionnaire. Hyperphagia was positively associated with emotional eating but negatively associated with food attentional bias. Hypersomnia was negatively associated with emotional eating. Poor appetite was negatively associated with emotional eating. Disturbed sleep was positively associated with food attentional bias and emotional eating. An aggregate of the remaining 15 depressive symptoms (SCL-15) was positively associated with emotional and restrained eating. Our findings highlight the importance of examining the direction of somatic depressive symptoms, and they set the stage for future research to identify subgroups of people with depression at greatest risk for obesity (e.g., those with hyperphagia and/or disturbed sleep) and the mechanisms responsible for this elevated risk (e.g., emotional eating).
Inflammation in obese children and adolescents: Association with psychosocial stress variables and effects of a lifestyle intervention
2021, Brain, Behavior, and ImmunityCitation Excerpt :Eating in response to food-related stimuli is characteristic for external eating (Schachter et al., 1968). Restrained eating can be defined as the intention to restrict food intake in order to lose weight or prevent weight gain (Tuschl, 1990). Items ranged from 1 (=never) to 5 (=very often).
Obesity in childhood and adolescence is a complex health issue that has detrimental effects on the physical and psychological health of the youngster, both in the short and long term. A characteristic of obesity is the associated chronic low-grade inflammation which can result in insulin resistance. Previous research suggested that biomarkers referring to such increased inflammation may help in understanding resistance to weight loss. Whether and how psychosocial factors are related with inflammation remains to be proven. The current study consisted of 594 children and adolescents (7–19 years), of whom 480 had follow-up data, who enrolled for a ten-month inpatient multidisciplinary obesity treatment consisting of healthy food routines, physical activities and psychological treatment. The purpose of the study was to explore (1) the relationship between inflammation and psychosocial stress variables (i.e., depressive symptoms, eating behavior, concerns about eating/shape/weight, insecure parent-child attachment) (correlational and multiple regression analysis), (2) whether a lifestyle intervention for obese youngsters results in decreased C-reactive protein (CRP) values (paired t-test) and (3) which psychosocial variables influence this CRP change as indication of treatment success (multiple regression analysis with change in BMI as control variable). Results showed that the psychosocial stress variables emotional eating, external eating and attachment anxiety are related to higher CRP values. Our data further suggested that a lifestyle intervention decreases the CRP values. This significant reduction in blood inflammatory marker was besides being influenced by weight loss also dependent on psychosocial variables, more specific on self-reported attachment avoidance, as this latter was related to less CRP decrease.
The aim of this study was first, to explore whether distinct combinations of key psychological and eating-related characteristics, could be identified and, second, whether these styles were related to measures of dieting success such as weight status and the number of previous weight loss attempts. Participants were any person 18 years or older with access to the internet and were recruited through Facebook to complete a 30-min, online survey. The survey included 23 different measures of factors related to personality, eating behaviours and current weight management. 1047 (68.3% of starters) completed the full survey. These people were 82.4% female with a mean age of 42.54 years (SD = 14.07). Factor analysis using Maximum Likelihood Extraction method with Promax rotation resulted in the extraction of 5 novel factors: Temptation (including experiencing cravings and difficulty controlling eating); Foodie (higher engagement and involvement with food); Overthinking (neuroticism, behavioural inhibition and perfectionistic tendencies); Social (extroversion and agreeableness); Impulsivity (impulsivity, lower conscientiousness, higher fun-seeking). Each of the factors associated bivariately, and in the expected direction, with behaviours such as vegetable consumption, frequency of diet attempts, and self-rated health. Each possible diet style is described further and interpreted in the context of existing literature with a focus on how understanding these could help personalise future interventions. Future work will validate this structure in different samples.
Socio-economic, psychological and environmental factors of obesity: Towards a better understanding to open new perspectives for action
2021, Cahiers de Nutrition et de DietetiqueAujourd’hui considérée comme une « épidémie » mondiale par l’Organisation Mondiale de la Santé (OMS), l’obésité est placée à l’extrême du continuum de la malnutrition et touche presque toutes les populations. La cause la plus évoquée pour l’expliquer est celle d’un dérèglement de la balance énergétique qui résulte d’apports énergétiques trop importants couplés à des dépenses énergétiques trop faibles (i.e. une balance énergétique positive). Les raisons de ce dérèglement sont multiples et variées, ce qui fait de l’obésité une pathologie aux origines multifactorielles, constituant un challenge pour les politiques de santé publique et les praticiens. Les nouvelles connaissances sur les facteurs socio-économiques, psychologiques et environnementaux de l’obésité passés en revue dans cet article constituent la base de nouvelles pistes pour prévenir et diminuer la prévalence élevée de l’obésité.
Now considered as a global “epidemic” by the World Health Organization (WHO), obesity is placed at the extreme end of the malnutrition continuum and affects almost all populations. The most frequently cited cause of obesity is a disturbance in the energy balance resulting from too much energy intake coupled with insufficient energy expenditure (i.e. a positive energy balance). The reasons for this imbalance are many and varied, which makes obesity a pathology with multifactorial origins, constituting a challenge for public health policies and for practitioners. The new knowledge on the socio-economic, psychological and environmental factors of obesity reviewed in this article provides the basis for new approaches to prevent and reduce the high prevalence of obesity.
Affect or restraint: Clinical correlates of the context surrounding binge eating episodes
2021, Journal of Behavioral and Cognitive TherapyAlthough binge eating is common, limited research has investigated the context surrounding binge episodes. This study seeks to understand clinical correlates of binge characteristics to guide treatment selection and clinical targets in adolescents and young adults. Participants were 42 females (15–35 years old; M ± SD: 21.17 ± 6.39 y; BMI: 26.97 ± 7.96 kg/m2) who reported at least one binge episode in the past month. Participants completed a qualitative interview detailing the context surrounding two unique binge episodes. Participants also completed the Eating Disorder Examination (EDE), Beck Depression Inventory (BDI-I), Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI), Dutch Eating Behavior Questionnaire (DEBQ), and Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale (DERS). Pre-binge negative mood was associated with DERS Impulse and Strategies subscale scores (r's = .379–.396). Positive mood was negatively correlated with DERS Goals, Impulse, Strategies, Nonacceptance, and Total scores (r's = −.342 to − 476). Stress surrounding the binge episode was correlated with DEBQ Emotional Eating scores (r = .495). Cue-driven binge eating variables showed small effect sizes with related clinical measures. Affective measures, including emotion regulation and emotional eating, were more strongly correlated than hunger or cue-driven measures with qualitative binge episode features in this study. Obtaining detailed information about the affective components of binge eating episodes may provide additional clinical targets for intervention.