Abstract
In homicide cases a clear anatomical or toxicological cause of death is normally evident. In the following a case is described where, without clear anatomical or toxicological cause of death, the husband of the deceased—a trained anaesthesiologist—was charged with murder. Suspicion was raised since the autopsy findings did not correspond to a fatal fall downstairs but instead could be definitely ruled out as cause of death, since intracranial bleedings and cerebral contusions, the leading causes of death in fatal falls downstairs, were missing. Further suspicion was raised since electrocardiograms (ECGs), previously stated by the accused to have been recorded personally from his wife during cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), were obviously faked. Additionally, an ampule of succinylcholine was missing from his emergency case. In a trial lasting more than three quarters of a year with several witnesses and experts heard by the court, the cause of death remained unclear. However, a natural cause of death and a fatal fall downstairs were ruled out. Subsequently the husband admitted during the trial to have killed his wife without elaborating on the circumstances for legal reasons. He was sentenced to prolonged imprisonment. Of special importance was that, based on the knowledge of typical autopsy findings in fatal falls downstairs, a lethal fall downstairs could be ruled out. Therefore even negative autopsy findings are of great forensic importance.
References
Balkon J, Donnelly B, Rejent TA. Determination of succinylcholine in tissues by TLC, GC/NPD, and GC/MS. J Anal Toxicol 1983;7:237–40.
Ballard KD, Vickery WE, Citrino RD, Diamond FX, Rieders F. Analysis of quaternary ammonium neuromuscular blocking agents in a forensic setting using LC-MS/MS with internal standardization on a Q-TOF. 49th ASMS conference on mass spectrometry and allied topic, Chicago (USA) 2001;27–31.05.2001.
Ballard KD, Vickery WE, Nguyen LT, Diamond FX, Rieders F. An analytical strategy for quarternary ammonium neuromuscular blocking agents in a forensic setting using LC-MS/MS on a tandem quadrupole/time-of-flight instrument. J Am Soc Mass Spectrom 2006;17:1456–68.
Brockmeyer J, Wollersen H, Musshoff F, Madea B. Zur Analytik von Succinylcholin. Rechtsmed 2004;14:353.
Dickman CA, Zabramski JM, Hadley MN, Rekate HL, Sonntag VK. Pediatric spinal cord injury without radiographic abnormalities: report of 26 cases and review of the literature. J Spinal Disord 1991;4(3):296–305.
Driever F, Dettmeyer R, Madea B. Zur Lokalisation von Verletzungen bei Treppenstürzen. Arch Kriminol 2001;208:105–13.
Duprez T, De Merlier Y, Clapuyt P, Clément de Cléty St, Cosnard G, Gadisseux J-F. Early cord degeneration in bifocal SCIWORA: a case report, Pediatr Radiol 1998;28:186–8.
Forney RBJ, Carroll FT, Nordgren IK, Pettersson BM, Holmstedt B. Extraction, identification and quantitation of succinylcholine in embalmed tissue. J Anal Toxicol 1982;6:115–9.
Geserick G, Prokop O. Zur Lokalisation von Orbita- und Felsenbeinzeichen im Vergleich zum Ort der Gewalteinwirkung auf den Schädel. Kriminal Forens Wiss 1988;71/72:41–3.
Gibb DB. Suxamethonium–a review. I. Physico-chemical properties and fate in the body. Anaesth Intensive Care 1972;1:109–18.
Gupta SK, Rajeev K, Khosla VK, Sharma BS, Paramjit, Mathuriya SN, Pathak A, Tewari MK, Kumar A. Spinal cord injury without radiographic abnormality in adults. Spinal Cord 1999;37:726–9.
Hartshorne NJ, Harruff RC, Alvord EC. Fatal head injuries in ground-level falls. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 1997;18:258–64.
Hein PM, Schulz E. Die sturzbedingte Schädelhirnverletzung. Beitr Ger Med 1989;47:447–50.
Hein PM, Schulz E. Contrecoup fractures of the anterior cranial fossae as a consequence of blunt force caused by a fall. Acta Neurochir 1990;105:24–9.
Hoshi K, Hashimoto Y, Matsukawa S. Pharmacokinetics of succinylcholine in man. Tohoku J Exp Med 1993;170:245–50.
Kato M, Shiratori T, Yamamuro M, Haga S, Hoshi K, Matsukawa S, Jalal IM, Hashimoto Y. Comparison between in vivo and in vitro pharmacokinetics of succinylcholine in humans. J Anesth 1999;13:189–92.
Kerskes CH, Lusthof KJ, Zweipfenning PG, Franke JP. The detection and identification of quaternary nitrogen muscle relaxants in biological fluids and tissues by ion-trap LC-ESI-MS. J Anal Toxicol 2002;26:29–34.
Kothari P, Freeman B, Grevitt M, Kerslake R. Injury to the spinal cord without radiological abnormality (SCIWORA) in adults. J Bone Joint Surg 2000;82-B(7):1034–7.
Kuepper U, Musshoff F, Madea B. Synthesis and characterization of succinylcholine-d18 and succinylmonocholine-d3 designed for simultaneous use as internal standards in mass spectrometric analyses. J Mass Spectrom 2007;42:929–39.
Lagerwerf AJ, Vanlinthout LE, Vree TB. Rapid determination of succinylcholine in human plasma by high-performance liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection. J Chromatogr 1991;570:390–5.
LeBeau M, Quenzer C. Succinylmonocholine identified in negative control tissues. J Anal Toxicol 2003;27:600–1.
Lignitz E, Geserick G, Patzelt D. Experimentelle Befunde zum Orbitazeichen beim Contrecoup. Kriminal Forens Wiss 1984;55/56:20–2.
Maeda H, Fujita MQ, Zhu BL, Ishidam K, Oritani S, Tsuchihashi H, Nishikawa M, Izumi M, Matsumoto F. A case of serial homicide by injection of succinylcholine. Med Sci Law 2000;40:169–74.
Maltby JR. Criminal poisoning with anaesthetic drugs: murder, manslaughter, or not guilty. Forensic Sci 1975;6:91–108.
Maxeiner H, Ehrlich E. Über die Lokalisation, Anzahl und Länge von Wunden der Kopfhaut bei Sturz und Schlag – ein Beitrag zur Anwendbarkeit der sogenannten Hutkrempenregel. Arch Kriminol 2000;205:82–91.
Meyer E, Lambert WE, De Leenheer A. Succinic acid is not a suitable indicator of suxamethonium exposure in forensic blood samples [letter]. J Anal Toxicol 1997;21:170–1.
Nordgren IK, Forney RB Jr, Carroll FT, Holmstedt BR, Jaderholm-Ek I, Pettersson BM. Analysis of succinylcholine in tissues and body fluids by ion-pair extraction and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. Arch Toxicol Suppl 1983;6:339–50.
Pang D, Pollack IF. Spinal cord injury without radiographic abnormality in children – the SCIWORA syndrome. J Trauma 1989;29(5):654–64.
Peters J. Recording electrocardiograms can be dangerous. Anesthesiology 2003;99:1225–7.
Pramar YV, Moniz D, Hobbs D. Chemical stability and adsorption of succinylcholine chloride injections in disposable plastic syringes. J Clin Pharm Ther 1994;19:195–8.
Preuß J, Padosch SA, Dettmeyer R, Driever F, Lignitz E, Madea B. Injuries in fatal cases of falls downstairs. Forensic Sci Int 2004;141:121–6.
Roy JJ, Boismenu D, Gao H, Mamer OA, Varin F. Measurement of succinylcholine concentration in human plasma by electrospray tandem mass spectrometry. Anal Biochem 2001;290:238–44.
Somogyi G, Varga M, Prokai L, Dinya Z, Buris L. Drug identification problems in two suicides with neuromuscular blocking agents. Forensic Sci Int 1989;43:257–66.
Tammelleo AD. Nurse murders pediatric patient. Regan Rep Nurs Law 1986;27:1.
Torda TA, Graham GG, Warwick NR, Donohue P. Pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of suxamethonium. Anaesth Intensive Care 1997;25:272–8.
Tsutsumi H, Nishikawa M, Katagi M, Tsuchihashi H. Adsorption and stability of suxamethonium and its major hydrolysis product succinylmonocholine using liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. J Health Sci 2003;49:285–91.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Presented in part at the 16th Nordic Conference on Forensic Medicine, 15–17.06.2006 in Turku, Finland.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Madea, B., Dettmeyer, R. & Musshoff, F. Fall downstairs: accident, homicide or natural death?. Forensic Sci Med Pathol 4, 122–128 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12024-007-9012-x
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12024-007-9012-x