Abstract
Goals, Scope and Background
Eutrophication and hypoxia, which are already serious environmental issues in the Midwestern region of the United States and the Gulf of Mexico, could worsen with an increase emphasis on the use of corn and soybeans for biofuels. Eutrophication impacts from agriculture are difficult to integrate into an LCA due to annual variability in the nutrient loads as a factor of climatic conditions. This variability has not been included in many relevant energy or row crop LCAs. The objective of this research was to develop a relatively simple method to accurately quantify nutrient loadings from row crop production to surface water that reflects annual variations due to weather. A set of watersheds that comprise most of eastern Iowa was studied. Ample data describing corn-soybean agriculture in this region and nutrient loadings to the Mississippi River enabled the development, calibration and validation of the model for this particular region.
Methods
A framework for estimating lifecycle inventory data for variable nutrient loading from corn-soybean agriculture was developed. The approach uses 21 years of country-average data for agricultural and annual rainfall for 33 counties that approximate three major watersheds in eastern Iowa. A linear equation describes the relationship between the fraction of the applied nutrients that leach into the surface water and the annual rainfall. Model parameters were calibrated by minimizing the error in the difference between actual and modeled cumulative discharge to the Mississippi River over the period 1988–1998. Data from 1978–1987 were used to validate the method. Two separate approaches were then used to allocate the nutrient flows between the corn and soybeans.
Results and Discussion
The total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) leaching models provide good representation of the variability in measured nutrient loads discharged from eastern Iowa watersheds to the Mississippi River. The calibrated model estimates are within 1.1% of the actual 11-year cumulative TN load and 0.3% of the TP load. In contrast, a standard method used in other lifecycle assessments for estimating nutrient leaching based on a constant fraction of the nutrients leached provides a reasonable average, but does not capture the annual variability. Estimates of the TN load that can be allocated to corn range from 60 and 99% between two allocation methods considered. This difference stems from a poorly understood symbiosis of nitrogen flows within the corn-soybean rotation that is difficult to integrate into an LCA.
Conclusions
Lifecycle inventories can include improved estimates non-point source nutrient flows to surface waters by incorporating climatic variability. Nutrient discharges to surface water are estimated with emission factors as a linear function of the annual rainfall rate. Water quality data is required to calibrate this model for a given region. In comparison with a standard approach that uses an average emission factor, the model presented here is superior in terms of capturing the variability that is correlated to an increase in the size of the hypoxic zone in the Gulf of Mexico.
Recommendations and Perspectives
Lifecycle inventories quantifying nutrient discharges from corn-soybean production should include the variability in these flows that occur due to climatic conditions. Failure to do so will reduce the LCA’s capability of quantifying the very significant eutrophication and hypoxia impacts associated with wet years.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Goolsby DA, Battaglin WA, Lawrence GB, Artz RS, Aulenbach BT, Hooper RP, Keenley DR, Stensland GJ (1999): Flux and sources of nutrients in the Mississippi-Atchafalaya River Basin. Topic 3 Report for the Integrated Assessment on Hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico. NOAA, Washington DC, 〈 http://oceanservice.noaa.gov/products/pubs_hypox.html 〉
Goolsby DA, Battaglin WA (2000): Nitrogen in the Mississippi Basin-Estimating Sources and Predicting Flux to the Gulf of Mexico. USGS Fact Sheet 135-00, 〈 http://ks.water.usgs.gov/Kansas/pubs/fact-sheets/fs.135-00.pdf 〉
Lucey KJ, Goolsby DA (1993): Effects of climatic variation over 11 Years on nitrate-nitrogen concentrations in the Racoon River, Iowa. J Environ Qual 22, 38–46
Puckett LJ, Cowdery TK, Lorenz DL, Stoner JD (1999): Estimation of nitrate contamination of an agro-ecosystem outwash aquifer using a nitrogen mass balance approach. J Environ Qual, 28, 2015–2025
Weed DAJ, Kanwar RS (1996): Water quality — Nitrate and water present in and flowing from root-zone soil. J Environ Qual 25, 709–719
Jaynes DB, Hatfield JL, Meek DW (1999): Water quality in Walnut Creek watershed: Herbicides and nitrate in surface waters. J Environ Qual 28, 45–59
Bakhsh A, Kanwar RS, Bailey TB, et al. (2002): Cropping system effects on NO3-N loss with subsurface drainage water. T ASAE 45, 1789–1797
Turner RE, Rablais NN (1994): Coastal eutrophication near the Mississippi River Delta. Nature 368 619–621
Arnold JG, Srinivasan R, Muttiah RS, Williams JR (1998): Large area hydrologic modeling and assessment — Part 1: Model development. J Am Water Resource As 34, 73–89
Williams JR, Jones CA, Kinery JR, Spanel DA (1989): The EPIC crop growth model. T ASAE 32, 497–511
Vache KB, Eilers JM, Santelmann MV (2002): Water quality modeling of alternative agricultural scenarios in the US corn belt. J Am Water Resourc As 38, 773–787
Kirchner JW, Feng X, Neal C (2000): Fractal stream chemistry and its implications for contaminant transport in catchments. Nature 403, 524–527
Rinaldo A, Botter G, Bertuzzo, E, Uccelli A, Settin T, Marani M (2005) Transport at basin scales: 2. Applications. Hydrol Earth Sys Sci Discuss 2, 1641–1681
Scavia D, Rabalais NN, Turner RE, Justic D, Wiseman WJ, Jr (2003): Predicting the response of Gulf of Mexico hypoxia to variations in Mississippi River nitrogen load. Limnology Oceanography 48, 951–956
Wang MQ (1999): GREET 1.5 — Transportation Fuel-Cycle Model, Volume 2: Appendices of data and results. Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, IL, ANL/ESD-39
deVries W, Kros J, Oenema O, deKlein J (2003): Uncertainties in the fate of nitrogen. Nutrient Cycling in Agrosystems 66, 71–102
Miller SA, Landis AE, Theis TL (2006): Use of Monte Carlo analysis to characterize nitrogen fluxes in agroecosystems. Environ Sci Technol 40, 2324–2332
Howarth RW, Billen G, Swaney D, Townsend A, Jaworski N, Lajtha K, Downing JA, Elmgren R, Caraco N, Jordan T, Berendse F, Freney J, Kudeyarov V, Murdoch P, Zhu ZL (1996): Regional nitrogen budgets and riverine N&P fluxes for the drainages to the North Atlantic Ocean: Natural and human influences. Biogeochemistry 35, 75–139
IPCC (1996): IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories, Reference Manual (Vol. 3) 〈 http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.ip/public/gl/invs6.html 〉
Gast RG, Nelson WW, Randall GW (1978): Nitrate accumulation in soils and loss in tile drainage following nitrogen applications to continuous corn. J Environ Qual 7, 258–261
Hallberg GR (1987): Nitrates in Iowa Groundwater. In: D’Itri FM, Wolfson LG (eds), Rural Groundwater Contamination. Lewis Publishers Inc., Chelsea MI, Chapter 3, pp 23–68
Sheehan J, Camobreco V, Duffield J, Graboski M, Shapouri H (1998): Life Cycle Inventory of Biodiesel for use in an Urban Bus. Final Report prepared by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL/SR-580-24089)
Sheehan J, Aden A, Paustian K, Killian K, Brenner J, Walsh M, Nelson R (2003): Energy and Environmental Aspects of Using Corn Stover for Fuel Ethanol. J Industrial Ecol 7, 117–146
Becher KD, Schnoebelen DJ, Akers KKB (2000): Nutrients discharged to the Mississippi River from Eastern Iowa Watersheds, 1996–1997. J Am Water Resour As 36, 161–173
Becher KD, Kalkhoff SJ, Schnoebelen, DJ, Barnes KK, Miller VE (2001): Water-quality assessment of the Eastern Iowa Basins — Nitrogen, phosphorus, suspended sediment, and organic carbon in surface water, 1996–98. U.S. Geological Survey Water-Resources Investigations Report 01-4175
Brenner J, Paustien K, Bluhm G, Cipra J, Easter M, Elliott T, Kautza T, Killian K, Schuler J, Williams S (2001): Quantifying the change in greenhouse gas emissions due to the natural resource conservation practice application in Iowa. Final report prepared for the Iowa Conservation Partnership. Colorado State University Natural Resource Ecology Laboratory, Fort Collins CO
USGS Hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico: website 〈 http://co.water.usgs.gov/hypoxia/html/nutrients.html 〉, accessed December 2005
USDA Agricultural Census data. 〈 http://usda.mannlib.cornell.edu:8080/MannUsda/viewDocumentDirectory.do?documentID=109 〉, accessed June 2005
USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. Agricultural Waste Management Field Handbook. Chapter 4: Animal Waste Characteristics, 〈 ftp://ftp.wcc.nrcs.usda.gov/downloads/wastemgmt/AWMFH/awmfh-chap4.pdf 〉
Sharpley AN, McDowell RW, Weld JL, Kleinman PJA (2001): Assessing site vulnerability to phosphorus loss in an agricultural watershed. J Environ Qual 30, 2026–2036
Goolsby DA, Battaglin WA (2001): Long-term changes in concentration and flux of nitrogen in the Mississippi River Basin, USA. Hydrol Process 15, 1209–1226
McIsaac GF, David MB, Gertner GZ, Goolsby DA (2002): Relating net nitrogen input in the Mississippi River basin to nitrate flux in the lower Mississippi River: A comparison of approaches. J Environ Qual, 31 1610–1622
Tomer MD, Meek DW, Jaynes DB, Hatfield JL (2003): Evaluation of nitrate nitrogen fluxes from a tile-drained watershed in central Iowa. J Environ Qual 32, 642–653
USDA National Agricultural Statistical Services: data base, 〈 http://www.usda.gov/nass/pubs/histdata.htm 〉, accessed March 2004
USDA Census reports: 〈 http://agcensus.mannlib.cornell.edu/ 〉, accessed March 2004
Spatial Climate Analysis Service: 〈 http://www.ocs.orst.edu/prism/ 〉, accessed March 2004
Smith RA, Schwarz GE, Alexander RB (1997): Regional interpretation of water-quality monitoring data. Water Resour Res 33, 2781–2798
Van Zeijts H, Leneman H, Wegener-Sleeswijk A (1999): Fitting fertilization in LCA: Allocation to crops and cropping plan. J Cleaner Prod 7, 69–74
Gentry LE, Below FE, David MB, et al. (2001): Source of the soybean N credit in maize production. Plant Soil 236, 175–184
Baker JL, Timmons DR (1994): Effect of fertilizer management on leaching of labeled nitrogen for no-till corn in field lysimeters. J Environ Qual 23, 305–310
Bjorneberg DL, Kanwar RS, Melvin SW, (1996): Seasonal changes in flow and nitrate-N loss from subsurface drains. T ASAE 39, 961–967
Smil V (2000): Phosphorus in the environment: Natural flows and Human interferences. Annu Rev Energy Environ 25, 53–88
Klatta JG, Mallarino AP, Downing JA, Kopaskab JA, Wittrya DJ (2003): Soil phosphorus, management practices, and their relationship to phosphorus delivery in the Iowa Clear Lake agricultural watershed. J Environ Qual 32, 2140–2149
Hauschild MZ, Wenzel H (1998): Environmental Assessment of Products. Volume 2: Scientific Background. Chapman and Hall, London
Seppala J, Knuuttila, S, Silvo K (2004): Eutrophication of Aquatic Ecosystems: A new method fpr calculating the potential contributions of nitrogen and phosphorus. Int J LCA 9, 90–100
Klaff J (2003): Limnology. 2nd ed., Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Smith RA, Alexander RB, Schwarz GE (2003): Estimating the natural background concentrations of nutrients in streams and rivers of the conterminous United States. Environ Sci Technol 37, 3039–3047
USEPA (2000): Nutrient Criteria Technical Guidance Manual — Rivers and Streams. Office of Water, Washington DC (EPA-822-B-00-002), 〈 http://www.epa.gov/ost/criteria/nutrient/guidance/rivers/index.html 〉
USEPA (2000): Ambient Water Quality Criteria Recommendations — Rivers and Steams in Nutrient Ecoregion VI. Office of Water, Washington DC (EPA-822-B-00-017), 〈 http://www.epa.gov/waterscience/criteria/nutrient/ecoregions/rivers/rivers_6.pdf 〉
Brezonik PL, Bierman VJ, Alexander R, Anderson J, Barko J, Dortch M, Hatch L, Hitchcock GL, Kenney D, Mulla D, Smith V, Walker C, Whiteledge T, Wiseman WJ (1999): Effects of reducing nutrient loads to surface waters within the Mississippi River basin and Gulf of Mexico. Topic 4 Report for the Integrated Assessment on Hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico. NOAA, Washington DC, 〈 http://oceanservice.noaa.gov/products/pubs_hypox.html 〉
David MB, Gentry LE, Kovacic DA, et al. (1987): Nitrogen balance in and export from an agricultural watershed. J Environ Qual 26, 1038–1048
Vanni MJ, Renwick WH, Headworth JL, Auch JD, Schaus MH (2001): Dissolved and particulate nutrient flux from three adjacent agricultural watersheds: A five-year study. Biogeochemistry 54, 85–114
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Powers, S.E. Nutrient loads to surface water from row crop production. Int J Life Cycle Assess 12, 399–407 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1065/lca2007.02.307
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1065/lca2007.02.307