Abstract
The contribution of farmers to the creation and maintenance of genetic diversity is beginning to receive more recognition in developed countries. Although the use of landraces and historic varieties has largely disappeared in countries with industrialized agricultural systems and formal seed markets, certain varieties with particular cultural significance have been continuously cultivated by farmers and other varieties have been preserved ex situ in genebanks. Recently, associations of organic farmers have become involved in the conservation and use of landraces and historic varieties (called farmer varieties in this article) because these varieties possess agronomic and quality traits that they have not found in modern varieties. In this study, eight farmer varieties of bread wheat from Europe selected by participating farmers were evaluated in on-farm trials during 3 years of cultivation. Each variety was grown on each farm, and phenotypic changes in each variety were measured the third year in a replicated split-plot trial on each farm comparing the version of each variety the farmer had multiplied to a sample of each variety from the region of origin. All varieties, including the two modern pureline varieties used as checks, showed statistically significant phenotypic changes over 3 years of multiplication. However, the magnitude of these changes was moderate and did not call into question varietal identity or distinctness. In addition, some traits of putative agronomic and adaptive importance, such as grain weight per spike and thousand kernel weight, did not respond positively to natural selection (environmental conditions and management practices) which suggests the necessity of farmer selection to maintain and improve varietal performance.
Abbreviations
- EU:
-
European Union
- FSO:
-
Farm seed opportunities
- DUS:
-
Distinctness, uniformity and stability
- VCU:
-
Value for cultivation and use
- RSP:
-
Réseau Semences Paysannes
- UPOV:
-
Union International pour la protection des obtentions végétales, International union for the protection of new varieties of plants
- NIRS:
-
Near-infrared spectrometry
- ANOVA:
-
Analysis of variance
- PH:
-
Plant height
- SL:
-
Spike length
- LLSD:
-
Last-leaf-to-spike-distance
- SpTot:
-
Total number of spikelets per spike
- SW:
-
Spike weight
- GW/spike:
-
Grain weight per spike
- KN/spike:
-
Kernel number per spike
- TKW:
-
Thousand kernel weight
References
Almekinders CJM, Elings A (2001) Collaboration of farmers and breeders: participatory crop improvement in perspective. Euphytica 122:425–438
Berthaud J, Clément JC, Empearire L, Louette D, Pinton F, Sanou J et al (2001) The role of local level gene flow in enhancing and maintaining genetic diversity. In: Cooper HD, Spillane C, Hodgkin T (eds) Broadening the genetic base of crop production. IPGRI/FAO, Rome, pp 81–103
Chable V (2009) La sélection participative pour les agricultures biologiques et paysannes: une coévolution des hommes et des plantes. In: Béguin P, Cerf M (eds) Dynamique des savoirs, dynamique des changements. Editions Octares, Toulouse, pp 73–92
Chable V, Berthellot JF (2006) La sélection participative en France: présentation des expériences en cours pour les agricultures biologiques et paysannes. Le courrier de l’environnement de l’INRA 30:129–138
Cross RJ, Wallace AR (1994) Loss of genetic diversity from heterogeneous self-pollinating genebank accessions. Theor Appl Genet 88(6):885–890
Danquah EY, Barrett JA (2002) Grain yield in composite cross five of barley: effects of natural selection. J Agric Sci 138:171–176
Dawson JC, Goldringer I (2012) Breeding for genetically diverse populations: variety mixtures and evolutionary populations. In: Lammerts van Bueren ET, Myers JR (eds) Organic crop breeding. Wiley, Hoboken
Dawson JC, Murphy KM, Huggins DR, Jones S (2011) Evaluation of winter wheat breeding lines for traits related to nitrogen use under organic management. Org Agric 1:65–80
Dawson JC, Serpolay E, Giuliano S, Schermann N, Galic N, Chable V, Goldringer I (2012) Multi-trait evolution of farmer varieties of bread wheat after cultivation in contrasting organic farming systems in Europe. Genetica. doi:10.1007/s10709-012-9646-9
Demeulenaere E, Bonneuil C, Balfourier F, Basson A, Berthellot JF, Chesneau V, Ferté H, Galic N, Kastler G, Koenig J, Mercier F, Payement J, Pommart A, Ronot B, Rouselle Y, Supiot N, Zaharia H, Goldringer I (2008) Étude des complémentarités entre gestion dynamique à la ferme et gestion statique en collections. Les Actes du Bureau de Resources Génetique 7:117–138
Eagles HA, Lothrop JE (1994) Highland maize from central Mexico: its origin, characteristics, and use in breeding programs. Crop Sci 34:11–19
Elias M, McKey D, Panaud O, Anstett MC, Robert T (2001) Traditional management of cassava morphological and genetic diversity by the Makushi Amerindians (Guyana, South America): perspectives for on-farm conservation of crop genetic resources. Euphytica 120:143–157
European Commission (2008) Commission Directive 2008/62/EC of 20 June 2008 providing for certain derogations for acceptance of agricultural landraces and varieties which are naturally adapted to the local and regional conditions and threatened by genetic erosion and for marketing of seed and seed potatoes of those landraces and varieties (Text with EEA relevance). Available online http://eur-lex.europa.eu verified 21.04.2011
European Council (1966) Council Directive 66/402/EEC of 14 June 1966 on the marketing of cereal seed (last modification in 2009). OJ 125, 11.7.1966, pp 2309–2319. Available online http://eur-lex.europa.eu verified 21.04.2011
Ghaouti L, Vogt-Kaute W, Link W (2008) Development of locally-adapted faba bean cultivars for organic conditions in Germany through a participatory breeding approach. Euphytica 162:257–268
Horneburg B, Becker HC (2008) Crop adaptation in on-farm management by natural and conscious selection: a case study with lentil. Crop Sci 48:203–212
Louette D, Smale M (2000) Farmers’ seed selection practices and traditional maize varieties in Cuzalapa, Mexico. Euphytica 113:25–41
Mercer KL, Perales HR (2010) Evolutionary response of landraces to climate change in centers of crop diversity. Evol Appl 3:480–493
Murphy KM, Campbell KG, Lyon SR, Jones SS (2007) Evidence of varietal adaptation to organic farming systems. Field Crops Research 102:172–177
Newton AC, Akar T, Baresel JP, Bebeli PJ, Bettencourt E, Bladenopoulos KV, Czembor JH, Fasoula DA, Katsiotis A, Koutis K, Koutsika-Sotiriou M, Kovacs G, Larsson H, Pinheiro de Carvalho MAA, Rubiales D, Russell J, Santos TMD, Vaz Patto MC (2010) Cereal landraces for sustainable agriculture: a review. Agron Sustain Dev 30:237–269. doi:10.1051/agro/2009032
Parzies HK, Spoor W, Ennos RA (2000) Genetic diversity of barley landrace accessions (Hordeum vulgare ssp. vulgare) conserved for different lengths of time in ex situ gene banks. Heredity 84:476–486
Serpolay E, Dawson JC, Chable V, Lammerts Van Bueren E, Osman A, Pino S, Silveri D, Goldringer I (2011) Diversity of different farmer and modern wheat varieties cultivated in contrasting organic farming conditions in Western Europe and implications for European seed and variety legislation. Organic Agric 1:127–145
Smith ME, Castillo GF, Gomez F (2001) Participatory plant breeding with maize in Mexico and Honduras. Euphytica 122(3):551–565
Soliman KM, Allard RW (1991) Grain yield of composite cross populations of barley: effects of natural selection. Crop Sci 31:705–708
Suneson CA (1956) An evolutionary plant breeding method. Agron J 48:188–191
Thomas M, Dawson JC, Goldringer I, Bonneuil C (2011) Seed exchanges, a key to analyze crop diversity dynamics in farmer-led on-farm conservation. Genet Resour Crop Evol 58:321–338
Thomas M, Demeulenaere E, Khan AR, Galic N, Pin S, Remoue C, Bonneuil C, Goldringer I (2012) On-farm crop metapopulation: how do human practices shape a bread wheat population-variety in industrialized agricultural systems? Evol Appl, accepted
Tin HQ, Berg T, Bjornstad A (2001) Diversity and adaptation in rice varieties under static (ex situ) and dynamic (in situ) management. Euphytica 122(3):491–502
UPOV (1996) Guidelines for the conduct of tests for distinctness, homogeneity and stability: wheat (Triticum aestivum L. emend. Fiori et Paol.). International Union for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants, tg/3/11 + corr. wheat/bl/weizen, 94-11-04 edn, tG/3/11 + Corr. Original: English/anglais/englisch Date: 1994-11-04 + 1996-10-18
Vom Brocke K, Christinck A, Weltzien RE, Presterl T, Geiger HH (2003) Farmers’ seed systems and management practices determine pearl millet genetic diversity patterns in semiarid regions of India. Crop Sci 43:1680–1689
Acknowledgments
This work was funded by a Specific Targeted Research Project of the European Commission 6th Framework Program Priority 8.1 SSP: Opportunities for farm seed conservation, breeding and production Proposal/Contract no.: SSP-CT-2006-044345. JD was supported by an INRA postdoctoral fellowship. We would especially like to thank the Italian and Dutch farmers who have participated in the project: Giandomenico Cortiana, Tonino Del Santis, Piet van IJzendoorn and Piet van Zanten. Thanks also to the technical staff at the INRA station of le Rheu and le Moulon and to collaborators Veronique Chable, Edith Lammerts van Bueren, and Mathieu Thomas.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dawson, J.C., Serpolay, E., Giuliano, S. et al. Phenotypic diversity and evolution of farmer varieties of bread wheat on organic farms in Europe. Genet Resour Crop Evol 60, 145–163 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10722-012-9822-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10722-012-9822-x