Abstract
Despite evidence of mentoring’s importance in training researchers, studies to date have not yet determined which mentoring relationships have the most impact and what specific factors in those mentoring relationships contribute to key outcomes, such as the commitment to and persistence in research career paths for emerging researchers from diverse populations. Efforts to broaden participation and persistence in biomedical research careers require an understanding of why and how mentoring relationships work and their impact, not only to research training but also to promoting career advancement. This paper proposes core attributes of effective mentoring relationships, as supported by the literature and suggested by theoretical models of academic persistence. In addition, both existing and developing metrics for measuring the effectiveness of these attributes within mentoring relationships across diverse groups are presented, as well as preliminary data on these metrics from the authors’ work.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bland C, Taylor A, Shollen S. Faculty success through mentoring: a guide for mentors, mentees, and leaders. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.; 2009.
Cho C, Ramanan R, Feldman M. Defining the ideal qualities of mentorship: a qualitative analysis of the characteristics of outstanding mentors. Am J Med. 2011;124(5):453–8.
Feldman MD, Arean PA, Marshall SJ, Lovett M, O’Sullivan P. Does mentoring matter: results from a survey of faculty mentees at a large health sciences university. Med Educ Online. 2010;23:15.
Garman K, Wingard D, Reznik V. Development of Junior Faculty’s self-efficacy: outcomes of a National Center of Leadership in Academic Medicine. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2001;76(10):S74–6.
Palepu A, Friedman R, Barnett R. Junior faculty members’ mentoring relationships and their professional development in US medical schools. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 1998;73(3):318–23.
Ragins B, Kram K. The handbook of mentoring at work: theory, research, and practice. Thousand Oaks: Thousand Oaks Press; 2007.
Ramanan R, Phillips R, Davis R. Mentoring in medicine: keys to satisfaction. Am J Med. 2002;112(4):336–41.
Sambunjak D, Straus SE, Marušić A. Mentoring in academic medicine. JAMA. 2006;296(9):1103–15.
Shea JA, Stern DT, Klotman PE, Clayton CP, O’Hara JL, Feldman MD, et al. Career development of physician scientists: a survey of leaders in academic medicine. Am J Med. 2011;124(8):779–87.
Steiner J, Curtis P, Lanphear B. Assessing the role of influential mentors in the research development of primary care fellows. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2004;79(9):865–72.
Fleming M, Burnham E, Huskins W. Mentoring translational science investigators. J Am Med Assoc. 2012;308(19):1981–2.
McGee R, Keller JL. Identifying future scientists: predicting persistence into research training. CBE Life Sci Educ. 2007;6(4):316–31.
Laursen S, Hunter A-B, Seymour E, Thiry H, Melton G. Undergraduate Research in the Sciences: Engaging Students in Real Science. New York: Wiley; 2010.
Gloria AM, Robinson Kurpius SE. Influences of self-beliefs, social support, and comfort in the university environment on the academic nonpersistence decisions of American Indian undergraduates. Cult Divers Ethn Minor Psychol. 2001;7(1):88–102.
Solorzano D. The road to the doctorate for california’s chicanas and chicanos: a Study of Ford Foundation Minority Fellows. Berkeley: California Policy Seminar; 1993.
Long-distance relationships. Nat Neurosci. Nature Publishing Group; 2007, 10(10):1223.
Steiner J, Lanphear B. Indicators of early research productivity among primary care fellows. J Gen Intern Med. 2002;17(11):845–51.
Wingard D, Garman K, Reznik V. Facilitating faculty success: outcomes and cost benefit of the UCSD National Center of Leadership in Academic Medicine. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2004;70(10):S9–11.
Palepu A, Friedman R, Barnett R, Carr P. Medical faculty with mentors are more satisfied. J Gen Intern Med. 1996;11(4):107.
Schapira MM, Kalet A, Schwartz MD, Gerrity MS. Mentorship in General Internal Medicine: investment in our Future. J Gen Intern Med. 1992;7(2):248–51.
Beech BM, Calles-Escandon J, Hairston KG, Langdon SE, Latham-Sadler BA, Bell RA. Mentoring Programs for Underrepresented Minority Faculty in Academic Medical Centers. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2013;88(4):541–9.
Dolan E, Johnson D. Toward a holistic view of undergraduate research experiences: an exploratory study of impact on Graduate/Postdoctoral mentors. J Sci Educ Technol. 2009;18(6):487–500.
Hathaway RS, Nagda BA, Gregerman SR. The Relationship of Undergraduate Research Participation to Graduate and Professional Education Pursuit: an Empirical Study. J Coll Stud Dev. 2002;43(5):614–31.
Gregerman SR, Lerner JS, von Hippel W, Jonides J, Nagda BA. Undergraduate student-faculty research partnerships affect student retention. Rev High Educ. 1998;22(1):55–72.
Byars-Winston A, Branchaw J, Pfund C, Leverett P, Newton J. Culturally diverse undergraduate researchers’ academic outcomes and perceptions of their research mentoring relationships. Int J Sci Educ. 2015;37(15):2533–54.
Bland C, Seaquist E, Pacala J, Center B, Finstad D. One school’s strategy to assess and improve the vitality of its faculty. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2002;77(5):368–76.
Ries A, Wingard D, Morgan C, Farrell E, Letter S, Reznik V. Retention of junior faculty in academic medicine at the University of California, San Diego. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2009;84(1):37–41.
Daley S, Wingard D, Reznik V. Improving the retention of underrepresented minority faculty in academic medicine. J Natl Med Assoc. 2006;98(9):1435–40.
Thomas D. The truth about mentoring minorities: race matters. Harv Bus Rev. 2001;74(5):98.
Helm E, Prieto D, Parker J, Russell M. Minority medical school faculty. J Natl Med Assoc. 2000;92(8):411–4.
Morzinski J, Fisher J. A nationwide study of the influence of faculty development programs on colleague relationships. Acad Med J Assoc Am Med Coll. 2002;77(5):402–6.
Ginther DK, Schaffer WT, Schnell J, Masimore B, Liu F, Haak LL, et al. Race, ethnicity, and NIH research awards. Science. 2011;333(6045):1015–9.
Csikszentmihalyi M. Forward. In: Nakamura J, Shernoff D, Hooker C, editors. Good mentoring: fostering excellent practice in higher education. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 2009.
Pfund C, House S, Asquith P, Fleming MF, Buhr KA, et al. Training mentors of clinical and translational research scholars: a randomized controlled trial. Acad Med. 2014;89:774–82.
Lee JM, Anzai Y, Langlotz CP. Mentoring the Mentors: aligning Mentor and Mentee Expectations. Acad Radiol. 2006;13(5):556–61.
Sciences NI of GM. Investing in the Future: Strategic Plan for Biomedical and Behavioral Research Training. 2011.
Byars-Winston A, Leverett P, Owen A, Pfund C, Branchaw J, Benbow R. Mentee and mentor experiences of race/ethnicity and gender in biology research mentoring relationships. Unpublished submitted manuscript.
Eby LT, Rhodes JE, Allen TD. Definition and evolution of mentoring. In: Allen TD, Eby LT, editors. The Blackwell handbook of mentoring: a multiple perspectives approach. Malden: Blackwell Publishing Inc.; 2007.
Muller CB, Blake-Beard S, Barsion S, Wotipka CM. Learning from the experiences of women of color in MentorNet’s one-on-one program. J Women Minor Sci Eng. 2012;18(4):317–38.
Prunuske AJ, Wilson J, Walls M, Clarke B. Experiences of mentors training underrepresented undergraduates in the research laboratory. CBE Life Sci Educ. 2013;12(3):403–9.
Chang M, Eagan M, Lin MH, Hurtado S. Considering the impact of racial stigmas and science identity: persistence among biomedical and behavioral science aspirants. J High Eudc. 2011;82(5):564–96.
Hurtado S, Cabrera N, Lin M, Arellano L, Espinosa L. Diversifying science: underrepresented student experiences in structured research programs. Res High Educ. 2009;50(2):189–214.
Carlone H, Johnson A. Understanding the science experiences of successful women of color: science identity as an analytic lens. J Res Sci Teach. 2007;44(8):1187–218.
Johnson A, Brown J, Carlone H, Cuevas AK. Authoring identity amidst the treacherous terrain of science: a multiracial feminist examination of the journeys of three women of color in science. J Res Sci Teach. 2011;48(4):339–66.
Sullivan P, Simmons M, Meloncon MK, Potts L. Intentionally recursive: a participatory model for mentoring. In: Proceedings of the 33rd annual international conference on the design of communication (p. 0), ACM (2015).
Eby LT, Allen TD, Evans SC, Ng T, DuBois D. Does mentoring matter? A multidisciplinary meta-analysis comparing mentored and non-mentored individuals. J Vocat Behav. 2008;72(2):254–67.
Byars-Winston A, Gutierrez B, Topp S, Carnes M. Integrating theory and practice to increase scientific workforce diversity: a framework for career development in graduate research training. CBE Life Sci Educ. 2011;10(4):357–67.
Bearman S, Blake-Beard S, Hunt L, Crosby FJ. New directions in mentoring. The blackwell handbook of mentoring. A multiple perspectives approach. Malden: Blackwell Publishing; 2007.
Nora A, Crisp G. Mentoring Students: conceptualizing and validating the multi-dimensions of a support system. J Coll Stud Retent. 2007;9(3):337–56.
Tinto V. Leaving college: rethinking the causes and cures of student attrition. 2nd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1993.
Manson SM. Personal journeys, professional paths: persistence in navigating the crossroads of a research career. Am J Public Health. 2009;99(1):S20–5.
Seymour E, Hunter A, Laursen S, DeAntoni T. Establishing the benefits of undergraduate researchers into a scientific community of practice. J Sci Educ Technol. 2011;20(6):771–84.
Chemers M, Zurbriggen E, Syed M, Goza B, Bearman S. The role of efficacy and identity in science career commitment among underrepresented minority students. J Soc Issues. 2011;67(3):469–91.
Yosso T. Whose culture has capital? A critical race theory discussion of community cultural wealth. Race Ethn Educ. 2005;8(1):69–91.
Lent R, Brown S, Hackett G. Toward a unifying social cognitive theory of career and academic interest, choice, and performance. J Vocat Behav Behav. 1994;45:79–122.
Bakken L, Byars-Winston A, Gundermann D, Ward E, Slattery A, King A, et al. Effects of an Educational Intervention on Female Biomedical Scientists’ Research Self-Efficacy. Adv Heal Sci Educ. 2010;15(2):167–83.
Byars-Winston A, Estrada Y, Howard C, Davis D, Zalapa J. Influence of social cognitive and ethnic variables on academic goals of underrepresented students in science and engineering: a multiple-groups analysis. J Couns Psychol. 2010;57(2):205–18.
Lent RW, Brown SD, Sheu H-B, Schmidt J, Brenner BR, Gloster CS, et al. Social cognitive predictors of academic interests and goals in engineering: utility for women and students at historically black Universities. J Counsel Psychol. 2005;52(1):84–92.
Gainor KA, Lent RW. Social cognitive expectations and racial identity attitudes in predicting the math choice intentions of Black college students. J Couns Psychol. 1998;45(4):403–13.
Williams MM, George-Jackson CE. Using and doing science: gender self-efficacy, and science identity of undergraduate students in STEM. J Women Minor Sci Eng. 2014;20(2):99–126.
Fiske A, Kitayama S, Markus H, Nisbett R. The cultural matrix of social psychology. In: Gilbert G, Fiske S, Lindzey G, editors. The handbook of social psychology. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw Hill; 1998. p. 915–81.
Hunter A, Laursen S, Seymour E. Becoming a scientist: the role of undergraduate research in students’ cognitive, personal, and professional development. Sci Educ. 2007;91(1):36–74.
Estrada M, Woodcock A, Hernandez P, Schultz P. Toward a model of social influence that explains minority student integration into the scientific community. J Educ Psychol. 2011;130:206–22.
Tran M. How can students be scientists and still be themselves: Understanding the intersectionality of science identity and multiple social identities through graduate. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of California at Los Angeles; 2011.
Bourdieu P. The Forms of Capital. In: Richardson J, editor. Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. New York: Greenwood Press; 1986.
Bourdieu P, Passeron J. Reproduction in education, culture and society. London: Sage Publications; 1977.
Becher T, Trowler P. Academic tribes and territories: intellectual enquiry and the culture of disciplines. New York: McGraw-Hill Education; 2001.
Zambrana R, Ray R, Espino M, Castro C, Cohen B, Eliason J. “Don’t Leave Us Behind” the importance of mentoring for underrepresented minority faculty. Am Educ Res J. 2015;52(1):40–72.
Bokeno RM, Gantt VW. Dialogic mentoring core relationships for organizational learning. Manag Commun Q. 2000;14(2):237–70.
Griffin K. Black professors managing mentorship: implications of applying social exchange frameworks to analyses of student interactions and their influence on scholarly. Teach Coll Rec. 2012;114(5):1–37.
Beasley MA. Opting out: losing the potential of america’s young black elite. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 2012.
Abedin Z, Biskup E, Silet K, Garbutt JM, Kroenke K, Feldman MD, et al. Deriving Competencies for Mentors of Clinical and Translational Scholars. Clin Transl Sci. 2012;5(3):273–80.
Pfund C, Maidl Pribbenow C, Branchaw J, Miller Laufer S, Handelsman J. Professional skills: the merits of training mentors. Science. 2006;311:473–4.
Meagher E, Taylor L, Probsfield J, Fleming M. Evaluating research mentors working in the area of clinical translational science: a review of the literature. Cli Transl Sci. 2011;4(5):353–8.
Fleming M, House S, Shewakramani V, Yu L, Garbutt J, McGee R, et al. The mentoring competency assessment: validation of a new instrument to evaluate skills of research mentors. Acad Med. 2013;88(7):1002–8.
Weston T, Laursen S. The undergraduate research student self-assessment (URSSA): validation for use in program evaluation. CBE Life Sci Educ. 2015;14(3):ar33.
Lopatto D. Survey of undergraduate research experiences (SURE): first findings. Cell Biol Educ. 2004;3(4):270–7.
Eagan M, Hurtado S, Chang M, Garcia G, Herrera F, Garibay J. Making a difference in science education the impact of undergraduate research programs. Am Educ Res J. 2013;50(4):683–713.
Chang MJ, Sharkness J, Hurtado S, Newman CB. What matters in college for retaining aspiring scientists and engineers from underrepresented racial groups. J Res Sci Teach. 2014;51(5):555–80.
Bieschke KJ, Bishop RM, Garcia VL. The utility of the research self-efficacy scale. J Career Assess. 1996;4(1):59–75.
LaFromboise TD, Coleman HL, Hernandez A. Development and factor structure of the cross-cultural counseling inventory—revised. Prof Psychol. 1991;22(5):380–8.
Boulder University of Colorado. URSSA, undergraduate student self-assessment, ethnography & evaluation research. 2009. www.salgsite.org.
Handelsman J, Handelsman H. Entering mentoring: a seminar to train a new generation of scientists. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press; 2005.
Rose GL. Enhancement of mentor selection using the ideal mentor scale. Res High Educ. 2003;44(4):473–94.
Bieschke K. Research self-efficacy beliefs and research outcome expectations: implications for developing scientifically minded psychologists. J Career Assess. 2006;14:77–91.
Allen T, Shockley K, Poteat L. Protégé anxiety attachment and feedback in mentoring relationships. J Vocat Behav. 2010;77(1):73–80.
Day R, Allen TD. The relationship between career motivation and self-efficacy with protégé career success. J Vocat Behav. 2004;64(1):72–91.
Hurtado S, Han JC, Sáenz VB, Espinosa LL, Cabrera NL, Cerna OS. Predicting transition and adjustment to college: biomedical and behavioral science aspirants’ and minority students’ first year of college. Res High Educ. 2007;48(7):841–87.
Greenwald AG, McGhee DE, Schwartz JLK. Measuring individual differences in implicit cognition: the implicit association test. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1998;74(6):1464–80.
Roberson L, Deitch EA, Brief AP, Block CJ. Stereotype threat and feedback seeking in the workplace. J Vocat Behav. 2003;62(1):176–88.
Steele C, Aronson J. Stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of African Americans. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1995;69:797–811.
Picho K, Brown S. Can stereotype threat be measured? A validation of the social identities and attitudes scale (SIAS). J Adv Acad. 2011;74(6):1464–80.
Acknowledgments
We thank other members of the National Research Mentoring Network (NRMN) Mentor Training Core (Stephanie House, Richard McGee, Sandra Quinn, Jenna Rodgers, Christine Sorkness, Kimberly Spencer, Stephen Thomas, Anne-Marie Weber-Main) for contributions that led to conceptualization of this article in preparation of NRMN grant proposal and their previous work. Specifically, we thank, AMWM and RM for work on definition of mentoring as well as RM and SQ for work on the conceptual frameworks. We thank SH, KS and JR for their feedback and Matt Holtz for work on the references. This works was supported CP, ABW, JB through the National Research Mentoring Network (NRMN) NIH U54MD009479/NIGMS, U54GM119023, and NIGMS R01GM094573 and SH and KE through the Coordinating and Evaluation Center NIH U54MD009508/NIGMS, U54GM119024, and R01GM071968. Research reported in this manuscript was supported in part by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Common Fund, through the Office of Strategic Coordination/Office of the NIH Director; all of the NIH Institutes and Centers; and the Office of Research Infrastructure Programs/Office of the NIH Director under award numbers U54GM119023, and U54GM119024. Research was also supported by R01GM094573, and R01GM071968. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pfund, C., Byars-Winston, A., Branchaw, J. et al. Defining Attributes and Metrics of Effective Research Mentoring Relationships. AIDS Behav 20 (Suppl 2), 238–248 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10461-016-1384-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10461-016-1384-z