Introduction

Toxoplasma gondii (T. gondii), an apicomplaxan protozoan parasite that causes toxoplasmosis, is an opportunistic pathogen invading broad host range, including humans and nearly all warm-blooded animals worldwide [1]. Toxoplasmosis is a life-threatening and significant infectious disease which also results to economic losses in animal production, especially in pigs, sheep, and goats [2]. Moreover, T. gondii-infected meat products are a major source of human infection [3]. T. gondii, as an opportunistic infection factor, can be fatal for patients with suppressed immune systems, especially for those with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) [4], undergoing organ transplantation [5], and patients with malignant tumors receiving cancer therapy [6]. In these patients, rapid multiplication of cytolytic tachyzoites destroys the nervous tissues and causes the pathological changes associated with toxoplasmic encephalitis (TE) [7]. In addition, toxoplasmosis is a significant biological agent influencing human prenatal and postnatal care because T. gondii infection during pregnancy can lead to maternal-fetal vertical transmission causing miscarriage, premature birth, severe cognitive impairment, or ocular complications (blindness) in the fetus [8]. Despite increasing studies concerning the biology of the parasite, there is a lack of chemotherapeutic agents to limit its proliferation during the rapid replication stages (tachyzoite), and there are no available therapeutic agents to eliminate the cyst stages from the infected host [9]. On the other hand, development of a vaccine against T. gondii would be particularly valuable for controlling human and animal toxoplasmosis. According to studies, excretory-secretory antigens (ESAs) of T. gondii have been observed as important component during the process of invasion and replication of tachyzoites within host cells and are considered to be one of the important targets of host immune responses [10].

In recent years, several trials on DNA-based and protein-based vaccines have focused on T. gondii antigens belonging to several major protein families, such as the glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored proteins named SAG (surface antigens), SRS (SAG1-related sequences), and SUSA (SAG-unrelated surface antigens), rhoptry antigens (ROPs), dense granule antigens (GRAs), and micronemal proteins (MICs) [11,12,13,14].

Among these, micronemal proteins (MICs) are small apical organelles, including several adhesion proteins, that are secreted during early contact of the parasite’s apical end with the host plasma membrane. The protozoa enters the host cell using its own actin–myosin system [15, 16]. The parasite is able to enter wide range of host cell types due to being homologous in modular structures from most MICs to ligand domains or adhesion domains from eukaryotic proteins, such as chitin binding-like (CBL), epidermal growth factor-like (EGF), thrombospondin type-1 repeat (TSR), and microneme adhesive repeat (MAR) domains. MICs are not only essential for attachment to the host cell’s entry but are also crucial for parasite gliding motion, as their cytoplasmic domains can bind to aldolase that is connected to parasite actin–myosin motor, the basis for active invasion [17]. Recently, the MIC complex was shown to play a predominant and important role in virulence and pathogenicity [18]. Currently, at least 19 types of MICs were known, including MIC1-MIC12, AMA1, M2AP, PLP1, ROM1, SPATR, SUB1, and TLN4 [19]. An increasing number of studies on MICs have showed them as potent antigen targets and vaccine candidates to induce powerful immune responses against toxoplasmosis. The current review aims to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the T. gondii MICs (TgMICs), adjuvants, animal models (species/strain), T. gondii strains for challenge infection, and routes of vaccine used to prevent and control T. gondii infection through a systematic search on complete interventions aimed at reducing toxoplasmosis.

Methods

This review was planned and prepared according to the specified process in the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) statement [20]. All of our methods are publicly available in the CAMARADES website (Collaborative Approach to Meta-Analysis and Review of Animal Data from Experimental Studies; http: //www.camarades.info/index_files/chickenyolkSRt.pdf).

Search process

A comprehensive literature search about effect of immunization with TgMICs on animal models was performed in PubMed, Web of Science, Proquest, Scopus, Science Direct, and Embase in April 18, 2018, by 2 independent authors (SD and ShS). The search was initiated from the first described vaccination with MICs in 2003 using a combination of keywords as follows: toxoplasmosis, Toxoplasma, vaccine, vaccination, immunization, protection, MIC, microneme, and micronemal. This was complemented by using further searches from bibliographies in related primary and review articles.

Inclusion criteria

A paper was included if it fulfilled the following criteria: (1) the study used every form of DNA-vaccine or protein-vaccine or both based on MIC against T. gondii; (2) the research evaluated vaccination on animal models challenged with tachyzoites or cysts of T. gondii; (3) literature was published in English language and accessible in full text; (4) the article had appropriate control groups; and (5) the research has high score.

Exclusion criteria

After reviewing articles, studies with the following criteria were excluded: (1) the study did not report any survival time and parasite burden; (2) the research did not have enough information; (3) literature had no control group; and (4) the article did not achieve the minimum score, 6, for its quality.

Study choice

Two authors (SD and ASP) independently assessed the titles and abstracts of the articles. Full texts of relevant studies were reviewed independently to ensure their eligibility for inclusion into the systematic review. Each disagreement was resolved with discussion or upon review by another researcher (AD).

Data extraction

Data on gene used, adjuvant, route of vaccine, inoculated vaccine dose, animal model, number and strain of injected parasites, challenge route, immunology, survival, and parasite burden were independently summarized by two reviewers using a standardized data collection form. In addition, we extracted bibliographic data, such as authors and year of publication.

Assessment of quality

The quality of all the included studies was assessed using the Systematic Review Center for Laboratory Animal Experimentation (SYRCLE), a tool based on the Cochrane Collaboration Risk of Bias tool [21]. The SYRCLE statement contains 10 items, and one of them concerning random housing of animals was removed. Therefore, nine items remained for selection, performance, detection, attrition, and reporting biases. The maximum score is 9. Higher SYRCLE scores show better quality article.

Results

Number of included studies

In total, 28 articles (DNA vaccine 23; protein vaccine 4; DNA and protein vaccine 1), published from 2003 to 2017 [13, 22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48], were included in this review. In total, the SYRCLE scores of the included studies ranged from 6 to 9, with a low of 7.9. This emphasizes a low risk of bias (Tables 1, 2). Among them, approximately 57.03% of the studies focused on MIC3 and its epitopes. Figure 1 briefly demonstrates the search process for this systematic review.

Table 1 DNA vaccine studies and their results in mice
Table 2 Protein vaccine studies and their results in mice
Fig. 1
figure 1

Flowchart describing the study design process

DNA vaccine

Out of the 23 studies conducted on DNA vaccine, 12 (54.5%) focused on MIC3 and its epitopes (epidermal growth factor-like (EGF) domains and the Lectin-like domain), and multiple other molecules, such as MIC1, MIC2, perforin-like protein (PLP1), MIC4, MIC6, MIC8, α-chain of MIC11, MIC13, M2AP, and AMA, were also surveyed, either alone or in combination (11 studies single, 2 cocktail, and 9 both single and cocktail), for their vaccine potential at different efficacy levels. Moreover, SAG1 was further used in cocktail vaccines compared to other antigens, including ROP18, GRAs, and other MICs (Table 1).

Protein vaccine

There were 5 protein vaccines in the included studies, and 3 of these 5 studies focused on MIC3 (60%). In addition, there was no study on cocktail vaccine regarding the combination of microneme protein with ROPs and GRAs.

Adjuvants

Various adjuvants have been used to improve vaccine potency, including bacteria-derived adjuvants (LPS, CpG motifs, cholera toxin A2/B), cytokines (GM-CSF, IL-18, IL-12), emulsions (Freund’s complete and incomplete), and particles (gold particles). Among these, GM-CSF (2/11 studies) and Freund’s complete (2/11 studies) were employed more than the other mentioned adjuvants.

Route of vaccine delivery

The most used route for vaccine delivery to animal models was intramuscular (22 from 28 studies), and other ways of vaccination used include the subcutaneous, oral, gene gun into the abdomen, footpad, and intranasal routes. Recently, intranasal immunization with MIC8 demonstrated 100% protection, whereas intramuscular vaccination resulted in only 60% survival [47].

Animal models

The recommended vaccines were based on animal models (mice). The three most utilized mouse models for vaccination were BALB/c, Kunming, and C57BL/6. However, a few studies also used CBA/J, ICR, and Swiss mice as animal models. Among these, BALB/c mice have been employed as a proper model for lethal challenge tests with highly virulent (RH strain) T. gondii. In contrast, C57BL/6 mice exhibit a low rate of survival with even a low dose of a non-virulent strain of T. gondii. According to Dautu et al., 20% of the BALB/c mice immunized with M2AP survived for 30 days, whereas none of the C57BL/6 mice survived for the same period [24]. In addition, detected IFN-γ in mice immunized with MIC2 and AMA1 in BALB/c (55.89 ± 8.5 and 126.0 ± 33) was more compared to C57BL/6 (35.00 ± 5.0 and 126.0 ± 33) [24].

Challenge

For surveying efficiency of vaccines, around 2–4 weeks after immunization, the mice were challenged with T. gondii infection. To study the survival rates, the mice were infected intraperitoneally (16 studies) or orally (6 studies) or intragastrically (2 studies) with 102–104 tachyzoites or 10–80 cysts (rarely) from different parasite strains. Virulent T. gondii (RH) was utilized more than the other strains (ME49, Beverley, Trousseau, and PRU). Subsequently, mortality was checked daily and survival time was recorded. To examine protective immunity, avirulent or less virulent strains, such as SSI119, 76K, PRU, and ME49, were administered orally (7 studies) or intraperitoneally (2 studies) or intragastrically (1 study) with 20–70 cysts per mouse. However, in the study of Gong et al., the mice were challenged with 1 × 102 tachyzoites of T. gondii RH strain intraperitoneally [34]. Reduction in brain cyst burden of the chronic model was then recorded.

Immune response

All sera were analyzed by ELISA to evaluate the levels of anti-T. gondii antibodies. Significantly high levels of total IgG and its subclasses were detected in the sera of mice vaccinated with plasmid-MICs, especially after the third vaccination (Tables 1, 2).

With regard to the findings, mice immunized with cocktail vaccines, such as SAG1-MIC3 (nearly IgG = 0.8 compared to 0.2 with OD 630 nm) [45], MIC6-PLP1 (nearly IgG = 1.8 compared to 1.3 with OD 450 nm) [38], and MIC1-4-6 (nearly IgG = 0.6 compared to 0.3 with OD 490 nm) [13], presented higher levels of specific antibodies than those immunized with single vaccines (P < 0.05).

Additionally, to assess the cellular immune responses in the vaccinated mice, lymphocyte proliferation and cytokine production in splenocyte suspensions were measured. The lymphocyte proliferation response was considerably higher in all immunized mice than the control groups (P < 0.05). Significantly higher levels of IL-2, IL-10, IL-12, and IFN-γ were produced in splenocyte cultures from vaccinated mice compared with the control groups. However, there were no considerable differences in the production of IL-4 between the immunized and the non-immunized groups (Tables 1, 2). Results of multiple studies demonstrate that the cellular immune responses induced by the multi-antigenic vaccines were better than those induced by single genes.

For example, spleen cells from mice immunized with MIC1-4-6 [13] produced twice as much IL-12 than the cells from mice vaccinated with single-component MIC proteins. In addition, significant production of IFN-γ (1136 ± 152) and IL-12 (845 ± 37) was observed from spleen cells in mice immunized with pMIC4-SAG1 compared to mice immunized with single-gene SAG1 (658 ± 117 and 432 ± 42) or MIC4 (632 ± 96 and 415 ± 23) [35]. Qu and collaborators also observed higher levels of IFN-γ from spleen cell cultures in mice immunized with MIC3-ROP18 (849 ± 86) compared with single-gene ROP18 (427 ± 40) or MIC3 (346 ± 31) [32]. Further, the mice immunized with the vaccine cocktail MIC3-SAG1 produced a stronger splenocyte proliferative response than the mice immunized with MIC3 or SAG1 with mean SI (stimulation index) of 15 and 10, respectively [31].

Protective effect in immunized mice

Mice immunized with 2–50 μg/μl MIC1, MIC2, MIC4, MIC6, AMA1, and M2AP (single or cocktail) showed extension of their survival time by a rough maximum of thirty days. Though many studies utilized 100 μg/μl antigen, it is important to mention that the survival time of Kunming mice challenged with 80 T. gondii cysts of the PRU strain survived for up to 54 days following the injection of 100 μg/μl MIC6 [38]. Among several single antigens employed for vaccination under similar conditions (animal model, route and dose of vaccine, and inoculation parasite for challenge), MIC3, MIC4 (22 days) [27, 36], and MIC13 (21 days) [44] improved the survival time significantly compared to the others (approximately 10 days). Additionally, combination vaccines, such as SAG1-MIC3 [30], ROP18–MIC3 [32], MIC3 + GRA1 [34], SAG1-MIC4 [35], SAG1-MIC8 [41], and MIC1-4-6 [13], demonstrated increased survival compared to single antigens.

Some studies also assayed the reduction in brain cyst burden following vaccination. Parasite burdens in the brain reduced from 0% (mice vaccinated with 10 μg/μl MIC3) to 93.5% (mice vaccinated with 100 μg/μl EC3 (GRA3 + GRA7 + M2AP)) [25, 29]. According to the study by Pinzan and collaborators, LAC+, native complex (MIC1 + MIC4) isolated from STAg (Soluble Toxoplasma Antigen), reduced the parasite burden to 73.4% compared to individual component, namely, MIC1 (52%) [13].

Discussion

The aim of the present systematic review was to survey DNA-based and protein-based vaccines encoding T. gondii MICs to demonstrate their capacity for inducing immune responses (humoral and cellular), survival times, and protection in animal models after challenge with T. gondii strains. Despite substantial advances in the research on immune responses that occur after infection with T. gondii, there is currently only one commercially available vaccine, “Toxovax,” which has been used to decrease the abortion incidence in sheep for veterinary uses, but it did not prevent the formation of tissue cysts [49]. However, it has several disadvantages and cannot be utilized for humans because such vaccines may regain virulence and even provoke iatrogenic infection [50]. Thus, the development of a safe and effective vaccine would be globally valuable to prevent both recrudescent and fetal infections in immune-compromised patients and pregnant women [51]. In other words, ideal vaccines against T. gondii should be able to eliminate the parasite and subsequently prevent cyst formation and maternal-fetal transmission. Since there is no ideal vaccine for complete elimination of the parasite, studies should focus on appropriate antigens to increase survival time and decrease cyst number in animal models as primary endpoints.

Therefore, the findings of the present systematic review encourage and support better studies in the future to produce the next-generation vaccines against T. gondii. Both recombinant proteins and DNA vaccines have been shown to protect hosts against intracellular parasites.

According to this systematic review, among the MIC-based vaccine candidates, MIC3 was the most frequently applied as an important vaccine and elicits strong, long-lasting humoral and cellular immunities [26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34]. This protein has a potent affinity to host cells, and its receptor-binding site is closely associated with the N-terminal chitin binding-like (CBL) domain [52]. Moreover, MIC3 was found to be expressed during 3 parasite life stages, including tachyzoite, bradyzoite, and sporozoite [19], although microneme proteins usually are not highly expressed during the sporozoite stage. Humans are usually infected by ingesting oocysts released from cat feces or by eating meat from infected animals containing long-lived tissue cysts [53]. Thus, immunization with MIC3 would generate a specific immune response that could avoid the release of tachyzoites from cysts (bradyzoites) and mature oocysts (sporozoites). Bioinformatics analysis demonstrated that MIC3 has a great immunogenicity and antigenicity index [26]. Therefore, it is considered as a potential candidate for vaccine development.

Previous studies have displayed that single-gene vaccines have been encouraged but are only able to induce partial immune responses against T. gondii [26]. Recently, increasing investigations have focused on multi-antigenic or cocktail vaccines. Multiple studies indicate that either DNA vaccine or recombinant vaccine in cocktail form, such as MIC3-SAG1, MIC3-GRA1, MIC3-ROP18, MIC4-SAG1, MIC6-PLP1, MIC8-SAG1, and MIC1-4-6, induces a stronger immunogenicity against T. gondii challenge compared to single-gene vaccines [13, 30, 32,33,34, 38, 41]. Given its complex life cycle involving numerous hosts with various forms of proteins to express and diversity of invasion pathways, T. gondii represents a very vast degree of antigenic variability. Further, accumulating evidences display that immunization with stage-specific antigens elicits stage-limited protection against toxoplasmosis. Therefore, it is important to develop multi-antigen vaccines in connection with multi-stage in order to conquer the deficiency of utilizing single antigens as vaccine candidates.

Epitope-based vaccine design is a novel method that primarily recognizes sequential epitopes [54]. The efficacy of epitope-based vaccines is extremely dependent on the exact identification of conformational B cell and T cell epitopes. Yin et al. surveyed epitopes of several antigens derived from tachyzoite, bradyzoite, and sporozoite of T. gondii, including SAG3 (101–144), ROP18 (347–396), MIC6 (288–347), GRA7 (182–224), MAG (158–125), BAG1 (156–211), and SPA (142–200), by priming with DNA vaccine and boosting with adenovirus-vectored vaccine, and this immunization proved a potential protect in mice challenged with T. gondii [39]. Compared with common vaccines, epitope-based vaccines have many advantages. Given that they do not contain inactivated pathogens, such vaccines are safer, thereby entirely eliminating any possible threat of infection [55].

We found that vaccination efficacy is particularly dependent on the utilized adjuvant, route of administration, strain and life cycle stage of the parasite employed, and the challenge infection. Moreover, the animal model (species/strain) used is also crucial for developing vaccines for humans.

Usually, vaccines do not have sufficient immunological potency and need to be combined with proper adjuvants to increase their effectiveness. Various adjuvants have been used as part of the vaccine formulation, including Freund’s complete adjuvant (FCA), Freund’s incomplete adjuvant (FIA), gold particles, GM-CSF, LPS, GERBU, cholera toxin, CpG, IL-12, and IL-18. Interestingly, immunization with Th1-inducing gold particles (as an adjuvant) incorporating a few (2 μg) MIC2 or M2AP or AMA could increase the survival of C57BL/6 and BALB/c mice challenged with the strain Beverley [24].

In addition to the use of adjuvants in vaccines, efficiency may also be increased by changing the vaccination route as intradermal inoculation is shown to be more effective than the intramuscular or intraperitoneal routes [56]. However, few recent studies employing the intranasal route have demonstrated the potential of particularly targeting mucosal immunity [35]. The reason why large number of studies employ intramuscular vaccination might be that the musculature is full of cells which leads to rapid and abundant expression of the related protein. Interestingly, DNA vaccines were administrated by different routes, such as intramuscular injection or a DNA particle delivery system, Gene Gun. Unlike intramuscular injection, which requires micrograms (μg) of plasmid DNA and several doses, Gene Gun route requires lesser levels of plasmid DNA for inducing the same immune response [24].

The level of protection afforded by specific vaccines is also shown to be dependent on the murine model utilized. For instance, though M2AP protected BALB/c mice with regard to survival time, it could not protect C57BL/6 mice [24]. Similarly, GRA6 provided partial protection against T. gondii in BALB/c mice but not in Kunming mice [57]. As formerly infected female BALB/c mice are capable of inhibiting congenital transmission completely even if re-infected during pregnancy, this model represents a gold standard for designing appropriate vaccine strategies.

Thus, firstly immunization should be carried out on inbred mouse strains, especially BALB/c and C57BL/6 or C3H/HeN; in addition, the vaccine efficacy should also be examined in outbred mice, since these are more similar to animal and human population [58]. Although in a study, Hiszczyńska-Sawicka and collaborators examined immune responses including IgG1 and IgG2 antibodies and production of IFN-γ using MIC3 DNA vaccine on sheep, it would be better for future studies to evaluate survival time and parasite burden in such animal models [59].

Susceptibility to toxoplasmosis varies with the diverse routes of challenge used for the strain variety of T. gondii [60]. According to the findings, in approximately 77% of the studies, the mice were challenged orally for examination of parasite burden in brain cysts. Challenge protocols of the studies depend on the aim of vaccination. For prevention of acquired toxoplasmosis (using food consumption), oral challenge route is better than other routes, whereas in transplacental form, non-oral routes, such as intraperitoneal or subcutaneous, seem to be more suitable.

In addition, different T. gondii strains are applied for challenge in vivo. Approximately 81.7% of the studies utilized virulent T. gondii RH to generate an acute model in mice. It is presently proven that T. gondii strains vary in virulence in mammals [61]. Particularly, Brazilian Toxoplasma strains are more virulent compared to strains of the European types I/II/III, and a number of other Toxoplasma strains are appearing through congenital toxoplasmosis in human and animal reservoirs globally [58]. In a study of Carneiro and collaborators, a total of 27 T. gondii strains were isolated from newborns with congenital toxoplasmosis in the state of Minas Gerais, Brazil, tested by PCR-RFLP approach. Among them, 14 isolates (54%) were identified as intermediate virulence, 10 isolates (38%) as virulent, and only 2 isolates (8%) as nonvirulent [62]. In addition, 20 Toxoplasma gondii strains isolated from animals and humans in Brazil by Ferreira and collaborators [63] were analyzed through two RAPD-PCR and SSR-PCR techniques. They showed that 85% of the studied strains had a certain degree of virulence, whereas only 15% of the strains were non-virulent. These results are in contrast with strains surveyed in the United States and Europe, where most strains are non-virulent [64]. Thus, it is important to utilize genotypes originating from different parts of the world in the immunization measures to ensure cross-virulence immunization against T. gondii [58].

It is a consensus opinion that cell-mediated immune responses, especially associated with CD8 T lymphocytes producing IFN-γ, are the main mediator of immunity against toxoplasmosis, making it a promising strategy for vaccination investigations. In addition, CD4 T cells play an important role in inducing immune responses and produce interleukin-2 (IL-2) for the development of CD8 T cells. Nevertheless, numerous vaccine studies have also indicated that a broad range of immune responses requiring elements of humoral immunity with antibodies provide the best protection against infection [65]. Consequently, numerous studies have surveyed whether immune responses to MICs and other candidate antigens, such as (GPI)-anchored protein (SAG, SRS, and SUSA), GRA, ROP, either singly or in a cocktail, induce protection against challenge by evaluating the survival time and brain cyst burden [66]. DNA and protein vaccines have been demonstrated as potent methods for the induction of particular cellular and humoral immune responses. Protein vaccines are demonstrated to induce primarily humoral immunity and, thus, are extremely efficient for controlling infections that could be antagonized with neutralizing antibodies. DNA vaccines, however, induce primarily potent cytotoxic T cell responses and have been showed to have limited ability in overall protection, especially when utilized in primates [58]. In a review, Foroutan and collaborators reported that a heterologous prime-boost strategy, especially a DNA vaccine as a priming and a protein-based vaccine for booster, induces more cellular and humoral immune responses than the homologous prime-boost [67].

Furthermore, studies on MICs have made much progress, and their compounds and functions are now becoming apparent. With regard to results, among MICs, MIC1-4, MIC6, and PLP1 prolonged the survival time in the mice by an average of 38 days and reduced the parasite burden by an average of 72% [13, 38].

Therefore, these evidence suggest that the MIC-based vaccines presented in this systematic review are promising and can be a worthy starting point to develop an effective and novel vaccine against T. gondii, for use in animals and humans. Recent advances in experimental and bioinformatics tools will aid in the selection of better vaccine candidates.

Another approach for toxoplasmosis control is the vaccines that directly target T. gondii transmission. Thus, it is important to design a vaccine providing potential contribution to decrease the infection rates, prevent parasite development, and reduce toxoplasmosis by inhibiting the transmission. T. gondii transmission-blocking vaccines (TBVs) are the tools to reduce infection in the family Felidae (domestic cats and their relatives) and toxoplasmosis transmission, by inducing the immunity that breaks the life cycle of the parasite between humans and cats.

Conclusion

Multi-epitope synthetic peptide vaccines delivering multistage MICs (MIC3, MIC4, and MIC13) can induce significantly higher immunogenicity. Also, the most successful vaccination procedure was the administration of the cocktail vaccines, since vaccinated animal models had the highest survival time and the lowest tissue cyst burden in the brain. According to the present systematic review, the strongest protection against toxoplasmosis was induced in mice by the mixture of surface antigens (SAG1) or other ESAs (ROP18 and GRA7) combined with MIC proteins. In addition, evaluation in other animal host species, containing those in which a vaccination may have veterinary usage, should aim in defining the role that this vaccination may play in controlling toxoplasmosis. Moreover, protection in animal models should be enhanced using gold particles (as an adjuvant). It is worth noting that bioinformatics and in silico approaches will facilitate production of novel potential vaccines against Toxoplasma gondii.