Abstract
Covariance between preference and performance was quantified for Papilio glaucus strains derived from a locally monophagous Florida population and a locally polyphagous Ohio population. I used two-choice assays to assess relative host preferences of mothers for plant species that represent reciprocal normal and novel hosts for each population (i.e., Liriodendron tulipifera and Magnolia virginiana) and a split-brood design to quantify relative performance of their progeny on each host. Covariance between preference and proxies of performance was detected independently within each population, which is a level of genetic structure at which such covariance has rarely been documented. These results support the hypothesis that preference-performance covariance can exist in populations that have no obvious internal host-associated structure. In the Ohio strain, all proxies of performance (larval duration, pupal mass, relative growth rate, and survival) were significantly correlated with relative preference for the normal host, L. tulipifera. In the Florida strain, however, only pupal mass was correlated with maternal preference, and this correlation was not in the direction expected. Progeny that attained the heaviest mass were derived from mothers that preferred L. tulipifera, the locally rare host. The nature of the preference-performance links was not in the manner predicted by conventional optimal oviposition theory, whereby host-associated tradeoffs have been considered an implicit element. Relative performance was congruent across hosts, regardless of whether mothers preferred L. tulipifera, M. virginiana, or neither host. After considering possible genetic and nongenetic explanations that could account for preference-performance covariance in P. glaucus, I conclude that this covariance has a genetic basis. Likely, multiple genetic control mechanisms (e.g., pleiotropy and co-adaptation) integrate at the level of different trait combinations and/or a particular trait combination to generate observed patterns.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andrewartha HG, Birch LC (1954) The distribution and abundance of animals. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Ballabeni P, Wlodarczyk M, Rahier M (2001) Does enemy-free space for eggs contribute to a leaf beetle's oviposition preference for a nutritionally inferior host plant? Funct Ecol 15:318–324
Barbosa P, Martinat P, Bennett R (1986) Consequences of maternal age and host deprivation on the production and development of Brachymeria intermedia (Nees) and the mortality of its gypsy moth (Lymantria dispar) host. J Appl Entomol 3:215–223
Barton Browne L (1993) Physiologically induced changes in resource-oriented behaviour. Annu Rev Entomol 35:447–467
Berenbaum M (1981) Note on an oviposition "mistake" by Papilio glaucus (Papilioniade). J Lep Soc 35:75
Berenbaum M (1991) Comparative processing of allelochemicals in the Papilionidae (Lepidoptera). Arch Insect Biochem Physiol 17:213–221
Bernays EA (1991) Plasticity and the problem of choice in food selection. Ann Entomol Soc Am 92:944–951
Bernays EA (1996) Selective attention and host-plant specialization. Entomol Exp Appl 80:125–131
Bossart JL (1998) Genetic architecture of host use in a widely distributed, polyphagous butterfly (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae): adaptive inferences based on comparison of spatio-temporal populations. Biol J Linn Soc 165:279–300
Bossart JL, Scriber JM (1995a) Genetic variation in oviposition preference in tiger swallowtail butterflies: interspecific, interpopulation and interindividual comparisons. In: Scriber JM, Tsubaki Y, Lederhouse RC (eds) Swallowtail butterflies: their ecology and evolutionary biology. Scientific Publ, Gainesville, Fla, pp 183–193
Bossart JL, Scriber JM (1995b) Maintenance of ecologically significant genetic variation in the tiger swallowtail butterfly through differential selection and gene flow. Evolution 49:1163–1171
Bossart JL, Scriber JM (1999) Preference variation in the polyphagous tiger swallowtail butterfly (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae). Environ Entomol 28:628–637
Bush GL (1975) Modes of animal speciation. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 6:339–364
Bush GL (1994) Sympatric speciation in animals: New wine in old bottles. Trends Ecol Evol 9:285–288
Cheverud JM, Moore AJ (1994) Quantitative genetics and the role of the environment provided by relatives in behavioral evolution. In: Boake CRB (ed) Quantitative genetic studies of behavioral evolution. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 67–100
Chew FS, Robbins RK (1984) Egg-laying in butterflies. In: Vane-Wright RI, Ackery PR (eds) The biology of butterflies. Academic, New York, pp 66–79
Courtney SP, Kibota TT (1990) Mother doesn't know best: selection of hosts by ovipositing insects. In: Bernays EA (ed) Focus on insect-plant interactions, vol 2. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Fla, pp 161–181
Courtney SP, Chen GK, Gardner A (1989) A general model for individual host selection. Oikos 55:55–65
Craig TP, Itami JK, Price PW (1989) A strong relationship between oviposition preference and larval performance in a shoot-galling sawfly. Ecology 70:1691–1699
Craig TP, Abrahamson WG, Itami JK, Horner JD (1999) Oviposition preference and offspring performance of Eurosta solidaginis on genotypes of Solidago altissima. Oikos 86:119–128
Cronin JT, Abrahamson WG (1999) Host-plant genotype and other herbivores influence goldenrod stem galler preference and performance. Oecologia 121:392–404
Denno RF, McLure MS (1983) Variable plants and herbivores in natural and managed systems. Academic, New York
Feeny P (1991) Chemical constraints on the evolution of swallowtail butterflies. In: Price P, Lewinsohn TM, Fernandes GW, Benson WW (eds) Plant-animal interactions: evolutionary ecology in tropical and temperate regions. Wiley, New Jersey, pp 315–340
Feeny P (1992) The evolution of chemical ecology: contributions from the study of herbivorous insects. In: Rosenthal GA, Berenbaum MR (eds) Herbivores: their interactions with secondary plant metabolites, vol II. Academic, New York
Feeny P, Rosenberry L, Carter M (1983) Chemical aspects of oviposition behavior in butterflies. In: Ahmad S (ed) Herbivorous insects: host-seeking behavior and mechanisms. Academic, New York, pp 27–76
Fox CW (1993) A quantitative genetic analysis of oviposition preference and larval performance on two hosts in the bruchid beetle, Callosobruchus maculatus. Evolution 47:166–175
Fox CW, Lalonde RG (1993) Host confusion and the evolution of insect diet breadths. Oikos 67:577–581
Futuyma DJ, Moreno G (1988) The evolution of ecological specialization. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 19:207–233
Futuyma DJ, Peterson SC (1985) Genetic variation in the use of resources by insects. Annu Rev Entomol 30:217–38
Golmulkiewicz R, Kirkpatrick M (1992) Quantitative genetics and the evolution of reaction norms. Evolution 46:390–411
Gotthard K, Nylin S (1995) Adaptive plasticity and plasticity as an adaptation: a selective review of plasticity in animal morphology and life history. Oikos 74:3–17
Harbison JL, Legaspi JC, Fabritius SL, Saldana RR, Legaspi BC, Enkegaard A (2001) Effects of age and host number on reproductive biology of Allorhogas phyralophagus (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) attacking the Mexican rice borer (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae). Environ Entomol 30:129–135
Haukioja E, Neuvonen S (1985) Induced long-term resistance of birch foliage against defoliators: defensive or incidental? Ecology 66:1303–1308
Hawthorne DJ, Via S (2001) Genetic linkage of ecological specialization and reproductive isolation in pea aphids. Nature 412:904–907
Hercus MJ, Hoffmann AA (2000) Maternal and grandmaternal age influence offspring fitness in Drosophila. Proc R Soc Lond Ser B Biol Sci 267:2105–2110
Jann P, Ward PI (1999) Maternal effects and their consequences for offspring fitness in the yellow dung fly. Funct Ecol 13: 51–58
Jaenike J (1978) On optimal oviposition behavior in phytophagous insects. Theor Popul Biol 14:350–356
Jaenike J (1990) Host specialization in phytophagous insects. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 21:243–273
Jaenike J, Holt RD (1991) Genetic variation for habitat preference: evidence and explanations. Am Nat 137:567–590
Jaenike J, Papaj DR (1992) Behavioral plasticity and patterns of host use by insects. In: Roitberg BD, Isman MB (eds) Insect chemical ecology: an evolutionary approach. Chapman and Hall, New York, pp 245–264
Karban R, Courtney S (1987) Intraspecific host plant choice: Lack of consequences for Streptanthus tortuosus (Cruciferae) and Euchloe hyantis (Lepidoptera: Pieridae). Oikos 48:243–248
Larsson S, Ekbom B (1995) Oviposition mistakes in herbivorous insects: confusion or a step towards a new host plant? Oikos 72:155–160
Lederhouse RC, Ayres MP, Nitao JK, Scriber JM (1992) Differential use of lauraceous hosts by swallowtail butterflies, Papilio troilus and P. palamedes (Papilionidae). Oikos 63:244–252
Li SY, Sirois G, Lee DL, Maurice C, Henderson DE (1993) Effects of female mating status and age on fecundity, longevity and sex ratio in Trichogramma minutum (Hymenoptera: Trichogrammatidae). J Entomol Soc BC 90:61–66
Lynch M, Walsh B (1998) Genetics and analysis of quantitative traits. Sinauer, Sunderland, Mass
Mangel M (1989) An evolutionary interpretation of the "motivation to oviposit". J Evol Biol 2:157–172
Mayhew PJ (1997) Adaptive patterns of host-plant selection by phytophagous insects. Oikos 79:417–428
Mayhew PJ (2001) Herbivore host choice and optimal bad motherhood. Trends Ecol Evol 16:165–167
Miller JR, Strickler KL (1984) Finding and accepting host plants. In: Bell WJ, Cardé RT (eds) Chemical ecology of insects. Sinauer, Sunderland, Mass., pp 127–157
Minkenberg OPJM, Tatar M, Rosenheim JA (1992) Egg load as a major source of variability in insect foraging and oviposition behavior. Oikos 65:134–142
Mitter C, Farrell B, Futuyma DJ (1991) Phylogenetic studies of insect-plant interactions: insights into the genesis of diversity. Trends Evol Ecol 6: 290–293
Mohaghegh J, DeClercq P, Tirry L (1998) Effects of maternal age and egg weight on developmental time and body weight of offspring of Podisus maculiventris (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae). Ann Entomol Soc Am 91:315–322
Moreteau B, R'Kha S, David JR (1994) Genetics of a nonoptimal behavior: oviposition preference of Drosophila mauritiana for a toxic resource. Behav Gen 24:433–441
Ng D (1988) A novel level of interactions in plant-insect systems. Nature 334:611–612
Nitao JK, Ayres MP, Lederhouse RC, Scriber JM (1991) Larval adaptation to lauraceous hosts: geographic divergence in the spicebush swallowtail butterfly. Ecology 72:1428–1435
Nylin S, Janz N, Wedell N (1996) Oviposition plant preference and offspring performance in the comma butterfly: correlations and conflicts. Entomol Exp Appl 80:141–144
Odendaal FJ, Rausher MD (1990) Egg load influences search intensity, host selectivity, and clutch size in Battus philenor butterflies. J Insect Behav 3:183–193
Prokopy RJ, Roitberg BD, Vargas RI (1994) Effects of egg load on finding and acceptance of host fruit in Ceratitis capitata flies. Physiol Entomol 19:124–132
Rabinowitz D (1981) Seven forms of rarity. In: Synge H (ed) The biological aspects of rare plant conservation. Wiley, New York, pp 205–217
Rausher MD (1983) Variability for host preference in insect populations. Mechanistic and evolutionary models. J Insect Physiol 31:873–889
Resetarits WJ Jr (1996) Oviposition site choice and life history evolution. Am Zool 36:205–215
Sadeghi H, Gilbert F (1999) Individual variation in oviposition preference, and its interaction with larval performance in an insect predator. Oecologia 118:405–411
SAS (1990) SAS/STAT user's guide, version 6, 4th edn. SAS Institute, Cary, NC
Scheirs J, De Bruyn L, Verhagen R (2000) Optimization of adult performance determines host choice in a grass miner. Proc R Soc Lond Ser B Biol Sci 267:2065–2068
Scriber JM (1986) Origins of the regional feeding abilities in the tiger swallowtail butterfly: ecological monophagy and the Papilio glaucus australis subspecies in Florida. Oecologia 71:94–103
Scrivastava M, Singh R (1995) Influence of age of parents Lysiphlebus delhiensis (Subba Rao and Sharma) (Hym. Aphidiidae) during copulation on progeny production and offspring sex ratio. J Appl Entomol 119:73–77
Singer MC, Ng D, Thomas CD (1988) Heritability of oviposition preference and its relationship to offspring performance within a single insect population. Evolution 42:977–985
Thompson JN (1988) Evolutionary ecology of the relationship between oviposition preference and performance of offspring in phytophagous insects. Entomol Exp Appl 47:3–14
Thompson JN (1996) Evolutionary ecology and the conservation of biodiversity. Trends Evol Ecol 11:300–303
Thompson JN, Pellmyr O (1991) Evolution of oviposition behavior and host preference in lepidoptera. Annu Rev Entomol 36:65–89
Thompson JN, Wehling W, Podolsky R (1990) Evolutionary genetics of host use in swallowtail butterflies. Nature 344:148–150
Valladeres G, Lawton JH (1991) Host-plant selection in the holly leaf-miner: does mother know best? J Anim Ecol 60:227–240
Van Tienderen PH (1997) Generalists, specialists, and the evolution of phenotypic plasticity in sympatric populations of distinct species. Evolution 51:1372–1380
Via S (1986) Genetic covariance between oviposition preference and larval performance in an insect herbivore. Evolution 40:778–785
Via S (1993) Adaptive phenotypic plasticity: target or by-product of selection in a variable environment? Am Nat 142:352–365
Warren MS, Hill JK, Thomas JA, Asher J, Fox R, Huntley B, Roy DB, Telfer MG, Jeffcoate S, Harding P, Jeffcoate G, Willis SG, Greatorex-Davies JN, Moss D, Thomas CD (2001) Rapid responses of British butterflies to opposing forces of climate and habitat change. Nature 414:65–69
Wasserman SS, Futuyma DJ (1981) Evolution of host plant utilization in laboratory populations of the southern cowpea weevil, Callosobruchus maculatus Fabricius (Coleoptera:Bruchidae). Evolution 35:605–617
Wolf JB, Brodie ED III (1998) The coadaptation of parental and offspring characters. Evolution 52:299–308
Acknowledgements
Discussions with Matt Ayres (Dartmouth College) helped clarify my thinking on statistical analyses and data interpretation. The critical reviews of Mike Singer and Carol Boggs are gratefully acknowledged for forcing me to eliminate verbose text.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bossart, J.L. Covariance of preference and performance on normal and novel hosts in a locally monophagous and locally polyphagous butterfly population. Oecologia 135, 477–486 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-003-1211-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-003-1211-x