Abstract
Background
A one-stop diagnostic service has been available for women with symptomatic breast disease at St Bartholomew’s Hospital for 5 years and was originally audited in May 1993. In re-auditing the one-stop service our aim was to see if our practice had improved following the original audit and to look at the impact which these changes in practice had made to the service offered to the patient.
Methods
A prospective audit of 4 consecutive clinics was undertaken in November 1997. A total of 300 patients (59 new and 241 follow up) were seen in clinic in this time. The primary outcome measure concerned the completeness of triple assessment in the 40 patients who required one stop investigations, including mammography, ultrasonography and fine-needle aspiration cytology. In addition, mean time to initial consultation and level of awareness of the one-stop facility and its attendant time delay were measured.
Results
Of the 300 clinic attendees 40 (38 new, 2 follow-up) had one-stop investigations. As a result of the one-stop service being in practice, 36 patients (90%) had a definitive management decision made at their first outpatient visit. Of these 2 were symptomatic cancers, forming 5% of the workload. A total of 86% of the workload was benign. Four patients (10%) had equivocal results. The mean waiting time from designated appointment until surgical consultation was 36.7 minutes and was disappointingly unchanged from that of the previous audit. However this does not take into account the significant reduction in staffing levels which has occurred between the two periods of assessment.
Conclusions
The initial audit identified a significant problem with time constraints, necessitating that a large number of patients with carcinomas return at a later date for further investigations. Booking only new patients at the beginning of clinic has provided a solution. Disappointingly, our figures do not show a significant improvement in mean waiting time compared with the previous audit, despite allowing GPs greater access of referral. Encouragingly, we have been able to maintain a similar standard of provision of care despite lower staffing levels and to implement the changes suggested by the original audit (thereby closing the audit loop).
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- FNAC:
-
Fine needle aspiration cytology
- GP:
-
General Pracitioner
- SHO:
-
Senior House Officer
- US:
-
ultrasound
References
Sandison AJP, King DH, Padayachee TS,et al: A one-stop vascular clinic; A practical proposition with non-invasive assessment.Ann R Coll Surg Engl 79:447–450, 1997.
Hasan ST, German K, Deny CD: Same day diagnostic service for new cases of haematuria; A district general hospital experience.Br J Urol 73:152–4, 1994.
Gui GPH, Allum WH, Perry NM,et al: One-stop diagnosis for symptomatic breast disease.Ann R Coll Surg Engl 77:24–27, 1995.
Gui GPH, Allum WH, Perry NM,et al: Clinical audit of a specialist symptomatic breast clinic.J R Soc Med 88:330–333, 1995.
Williams O: What is clinical audit?Ann R Coll Surg Engl 78:406–411, 1996.
Clinical Audit in Surgical Practice, The Royal College of Surgeons of England, 1995.
The Patients Charter, HMSO, London, 1992.
Brown LA, Coghill SB, Powis SAJ: Audit of diagnostic accuracy of FNA cytology specimens taken by the histopathologist in a symptomatic breast clinic.Cytopathology 2:167–176, 1991.
Dixon JM, Clarke PJ, Crucioli V,et al: Reduction of the surgical excision rate in benign breast disease using fine needle aspiration cytology with immediate reporting.Br J Surg 74:1014–1016, 1987.
Dixon JM, Lamb J, Anderson TJ: Fine needle aspiration of the breast: importance of the operator.Lancet ii:564, 1983.
Anonymous: Guidelines for surgeons in the management of symp-tomatic breast disease in the United Kingdom.Eur J Surg Oncol 21(Suppl A): l-13, 1995.
Gordon PB, Goldeberg SL, Chan NHL: Solid breast lesions: diagnosis with US-guided fine-needle aspiration biopsy.Radiology 189:573–580, 1993.
Britton PD, Flower CD, Freeman AH,et al: Changing to core biopsy in an NHS breast screening unit.Clin Radiol 52:764–767, 1997.
Chare MJ, Flowers CI, O’Brien CJ,et al: Imageguided core biopsy in patients with breast disease.Br J Surg 83:1415–1416, 1996.
Howisey RL, Acheson MB, Rowbotham RK,et al: A comparison of Medicare reimbursement and results for various imaging-guided breast biopsy techniques.Am J Surg 173:395–398, 1997.
Young A: One-stop breast clinics.Practitioner 240:514–521, 1996.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
About this article
Cite this article
Chan, S.Y.Y., Berry, M.G., Engledow, A.H. et al. Audit of a one-stop breast clinic-revisited. Breast Cancer 7, 191–194 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02967459
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02967459