Abstract
There are increasing numbers of attempts to surgically separate conjoined twins. Almost every type of conjoined twins have been separated, with varying results. Surgeons must often make the decision as to the desirability and feasibility of separation. These decisions are complicated by ethical problems that involve patient privacy, the allocation of shared organs, and in some instances the necessity for one twin to die to save the other. Although life as a conjoined twin would appear to be intolerable, there are historical as well as current instances of conjoined twins who have progressed to adulthood as relatively well-adjusted individuals. Thus, in some situations, it may be better not to operate on these patients. At one time or another, when individual cases have been studied by theologians, all faiths have agreed that the sacrifice of one twin to save the other is ethical. When one twin is clearly stronger than the other and has the best chance for long-term survival, it also appears to be desirable to give that twin the shared organs that allow gastrointestinal and genitourinary function and ambulation. It is now possible to predict the pattern of shared organs in most cases based on an external examination. It is no longer necessary to subject these patients to prolonged, invasive tests, which may be dangerous and provide at best incomplete information. The surgeon should take great care to protect his patients' privacy and resist efforts by the media to create a “television circus” over these patients.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Guttmacher AF, Nichols BL (1967) Teratology of conjoined twins. Birth Defects 3: 4
Luckhardt A (1941) Report of the autopsy of the Siamese twins together with other interesting information covering their life. Surg Gynecol Obstet 72: 118–125
Smith JD (1988) Psychological profiles of conjoined twins. Praeger, Westpoint CT, p 147
Miller K, Doman JMR (1996) Two lives undivided. Life 19: 44–56
Bondeson J (1992) The Biddenden Maids, a curious chapter in the history of conjoined twins. J R Soc Med 85: 217–221
Hoyle RM (1990) Surgical separation of conjoined twinsq. Sung Gynecol Obstet 170: 549–561
Muraskas J (1994) Letter to the editor. J Perinat 14: 168
Paris JJ (1993) Ethical issues in separation of the Lakeberg Siamese twins. J Perinatol 13: 423–424
Drake D (1977) One must die so the other may live. Nurs Forum 16 (3): 229–249
Annas GJ (1987) Imperiled newborn Siamese twins: killing one to save the other. Hastings Cent Rep 17: 27–29
Cambio D (1994) These twins survived separation. RN 57: 54–55
Pepper CK (1967) Ethical and moral considerations in the separation of conjoined twins. Birth Defects 3: 128–134
Chavarria AP, Shipley PG (1924) The Siamese twins of Espanola. Ann Med Hist 6: 297–302
Koop CE (1974) Separating the Siamese twins, the surgeons story. Med World News 8: 90–95
Chen WJ, Hong SL, Shu-Hsun C, et al (1994) Separation of ischiopagus tripus conjoined twins. J Pediatr Surg 29: 1417–1420
Hung WT, Chen WJ, Chen HT, et al (1986) Successful separation of ischiopagus tripus conjoined twins. J Pediatr Surg 21: 920–923
Spitz L, Stringer EM, Kiely PG, Smith P (1994) Separation of brachio-thoraco-oinphalo-ischiopagus bipus conjoined twins. J Pediatr Surg 29: 427–481
Little J, Bryan E (1986) Congenital anomalies in twins. Semin Perinatol 10: 50–64
Harper RG, et al (1980) Xiphopagus conjoined twins, a 300 year review of the obstetric morphopathologic, neonatal and surgical parameters. Am J Obstet Gynecol 137: 617–629
Paradowskin W, Jaworska M, Reszke S, Lodzinski K (1969) Conjoined twins, and twin parasites; clinical analysis of three examples. J Pediatr Surg 4: 688–693
O'Neill J, Holcomb G, Schnaufer L, Templeton J, Bishop H, et al (1988) Surgical experience with thirteen conjoined twins. Ann Surg 208: 299–312
Spencer R (1992) Conjoined twins: theoretical embryologic basis. Teratology 45: 591–602
Donaldson JS, Luck SR, Vogelzang R (1990) Preoperative CT and MR imaging of ischiopagus twins. J Comput Assist Tomogr 14: 643–646
Rickets RR, Zubowicz VN (1987) Use of tissue expansion for separation and primary closure of thoracopagus twins. J Pediatr Sung Int 2: 365–368
Zuker RM, Filler RM, Roopnarine L (1986) Intra-abdominal tissue expansion: an adjunct in the separation of conjoined twins. J Pediatr Surg 21: 1198–1200
Spitz L, Stringer EM, Kiely PG, et al (1994) Separation of brachiothoraco-omphalo-ischio-pagus bipus conjoined twins. J Pediatr Surg 29: 427–481
Able LW (1967) The surgical separation of the Bay City twins. Birth Defects 3: 69–79
de Vries PA (1967) Separation of the San Francisco twins. Birth Defects 3: 75–79
Spencer R (in press) Conjoined twins: embryology, pathogenesis, and review of the literature. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Raffensperger, J. A philosophical approach to conjoined twins. Pediatr Surg Int 12, 249–255 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01372143
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01372143