Skip to main content
SpringerLink
Log in

Application and Comparison of Tsunami Vulnerability and Damage Models for the Town of Siracusa, Sicily, Italy

  • Published:
Pure and Applied Geophysics Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Siracusa is one of the most important cities of the eastern coast of Sicily, which according to historical records and to the present knowledge of the tectonic setting, is exposed to tsunamis generated by landslides on the Malta escarpment and by local and remote (e.g., Eastern Hellenic Arc) earthquakes. For this reason, the area of Siracusa has been selected as one of the test sites to conduct specific studies within the European FP7 project ASTARTE. In this frame, this work focuses on the assessment of tsunami vulnerability of (and damage to) the building stock of the town. The analysis is carried out following two different models, namely the SCHEMA and the Papathoma Tsunami Vulnerability Assessment (PTVA-3) methods. Topographic and building stock data in the potentially flooded areas are taken from detailed digital databases produced by the region of Sicily, integrated with satellite and photographic imagery from Google Earth and further validated by field surveys. We have explored three inundation scenarios corresponding to a constant-level tsunami flooding with assumed sea level rise of 1, 3 and 5 m, and evaluated the damage to the town buildings using both methods that make use of a 5-degree scale. The main result is that the level of damage of both models is not consistent, and that consistency may be improved if one changes from a 5- to a 3-degree damage scale.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Fig. 5
Fig. 6
Fig. 7
Fig. 8
Fig. 9
Fig. 10
Fig. 11
Fig. 12
Fig. 13
Fig. 14
Fig. 15

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Aloisi, M., Bruno, V., Cannavò, F., Ferranti, L., Mattia, M., Monaco, C., and Palano, M. (2013). Are the source models of the Messina Straits earthquake reliable? Insights from a novel inversion and a sensitivity analysis of levelling data. Geophys. J. Int., 192, 1025–1041.

  • Amato, A., Azzara, R., Basili, A., Chiarabba, C., Cocco, M., Di Bona, M., and Selvaggi, G. (1995). Main shock and aftershocks of the December 13, 1990 Eastern Sicily earthquake. Annali di Geofisica, 38, 255–266.

  • Argnani, A., and Bonazzi, C. (2005). Malta Escarpment fault zone offshore eastern Sicily: Pliocene-Quaternary tectonic evolution based on new multichannel seismic data. Tectonics, 24, 1–12. doi:10.1029/2004TC001656.

  • Argnani, A., Chiocci, F.L., Tinti, S., Bosman, A., Lodi, M.V., Pagnoni, G., and Zaniboni, F. (2009). Comment on “On the cause of the 1908 Messina tsunami, southern Italy” by Andrea Billi et al. Geophys. Res. Lett. 36, 3–5. doi:10.1029/2009GL037332.

  • Argnani, A., Armigliato, A., Pagnoni, G., Zaniboni, F., Tinti, S., and Bonazzi, C. (2012). Active tectonics along the submarine slope of south-eastern Sicily and the source of the 11 January 1693 earthquake and tsunami. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 12, 1311–1319.

  • ASV, Relazione dell’Inquisitore di Malta F. d’Acquaviva al Segretario di Stato Cardinale Spada sui danni causati a Malta e in Sicilia dal terremoto dell’11 gennaio 1693 (Archivio Segreto Vaticano, Segreteria di Stato, Inquisizione, Malta 1693).

  • Atillah, A., El Hadani, D., Moudni, H., Lesne, O., Renou, C., Mangin, A., and Rouffi, F. (2011). Tsunami vulnerability and damage assessment in the coastal area of Rabat and Sale, Morocco. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 3397–3414.

  • Baratta, M., I terremoti d’Italia. Saggio di storia, geografia e bibliografia sismica italiana con 136 sismocartogrammi (Arnaldo Forni Editore, 1901).

  • Baratta, M. (1910). La catastrofe sismica calabro-messinese del 28 dicembre 1908, Relazione alla Società Geografica Italiana.

  • Barbano, M. S., Rigano, R., Cosentino, M. and Lombardo G. (2001). Seismic history and hazard in some localities of south-eastern Sicily. Boll. Geof. Teor. Appl., 42, 107–120.

  • Basili, R., Valensise, G., Vannoli, P., Burrato, P., Fracassi, U., Mariano, S., Tiberti, M.M., and Boschi, E. (2008). The Database of Individual Seismogenic Sources (DISS), version 3: summarizing 20 years of research on Italy’s earthquake geology. Tectonophysics 453, 20–43. doi:10.1016/j.tecto.2007.04.014.

  • Basili, R., Kastelic, V., Demircioglu, M.B., Garcia Moreno, D., Nemser, E.S., Petricca, P., Sboras, S.P., Besana-Ostman, G.M., Cabral, J., Camelbeek, T., Caputo, R., Danciu, L., Domac, H., Fonseca, J., Garcia-Mayofomo, J., Giardini, D., Glavatovic, B., Gulen, L., Ince, Y., Pavlides, S., Sestyan, K., Tarabusi, G., Tiberti, M.M., Utkucu, M., Valensise, G., Vanneste, K., Vilanova, S., and Wössner, J. (2013). The European Database of Seismogenic Faults (ESDF) compiled in the frame work of the Project SHARE. http://diss.rm.ingv.it/share-edsf/. doi:10.6092/INGV.IT-SHARE-EDSF.

  • Bianca, M., Monaco, C., Tortorici, L., and Cernobori, L. (1999). Quaternary normal faulting in southeastern Sicily (Italy): a seismic source for the 1693 large earthquake. Geophys. J. Int., 139, 370–394.

  • Billi, A., Funiciello, R., Minelli, L., Faccenna, C., Neri, G., Orecchio, B., and Presti, D. (2008). On the cause of the 1908 Messina tsunami, southern Italy. Geophys. Res. Lett. 35, 1–5. doi:10.1029/2008GL033251.

  • Billi A., Minelli L., Orecchio B., and Presti D. (2010). Constraints to the Cause of Three Historical Tsunamis (1908, 1783, and 1693) in the Messina Straits Region, Sicily, Southern Italy. Seism. Res. Lett. (Seism. Soc. Am.), 81, 907–915.

  • Birkmann, J., and Fernando, N. (2008). Measuring revealed and emergent vulnerabilities of coastal communities to tsunami in Sri Lanka. Disasters, 32, 82–105.

  • Boccone, P, Intorno il terremoto della Sicilia seguito l’anno 1693 (Museo di Fisica, Venezia 1697).

  • Boschi, E., Guidoboni, E., Ferrari, G., Valensise, G., and Gasperini, P., Catalogo dei forti terremoti in Italia dal 461 a.C. al 1990 (2) (I.N.G.-S.G.A, Roma 1997).

  • Bottone, D., De immani Trinacriae terraemotu. Idea historico-physica, in qua non solum telluris concussiones transactae recensentur, sed novissimae anni 1717. (ex typogr. reg. & camer. haered. de Amico, Messanae 1718).

  • Brizuela, B., Armigliato, A., and Tinti, S. (2014). Assessment of tsunami hazard for the American Pacific coast from southern Mexico to northern Peru. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci. 14, 1889–1903. doi:10.5194/nhess-14-1889-2014.

  • Burbidge, D., Cummins, P.R., Mleczko, R., and Thio, H.A. (2008). Probabilistic tsunami hazard assessment for Western Australia. Pure Appl. Geophys, 165, 2059–2088.

  • Burgos, A., Distinta relazione avuta per lettera del P. Alessandro Burgos scritta ad un suo amico, che contiene le notizie fin’ora avute de danni cagionati in Sicilia da tremuoti a 9 e 11 gennaio 1693 (Palermo 1693).

  • Camarasa Belmonte, A.M., López-García, M.J. and Soriano-García, J. (2011). Mapping temporally-variable exposure to flooding in small Mediterranean basins using land-use indicators. Appl. Geogr., 31, 136–145.

  • Cita, M.B., Rimoldi, B. (1997). Geological and geophysical evidence for a holocene tsunami deposit in the Eastern Mediterranean deep-sea record. J. Geodyn. 24, 293–304. doi:10.1016/S0264-3707(96)00030-0.

  • Dall’Osso, F., Gonella, M., Gabbianelli, G., Withycombe, G., and Dominey-Howes, D. (2009a). A revised (PTVA) model for assessing the vulnerability of buildings to tsunami damage. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 9, 1557–1565.

  • Dall’Osso, F., Gonella, M., Gabbianelli, G., Withycombe, G., and Dominey-Howes, D. (2009b). Assessing the vulnerability of buildings to tsunami in Sydney. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 9, 2015–2026.

  • Dall’Osso, F., Maramai, A., Graziani, L., Brizuela, B., Cavalletti, A., Gonella, M., and Tinti, S. (2010). Applying and validating the PTVA-3 Model at the Aeolian Islands, Italy: assessment of the vulnerability of buildings to tsunamis. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 10, 1547–1562.

  • De Martini, P.M., Barbano, M.S., Smedile, A., Gerardi, F., Pantosti, D., Del Carlo, P., and Pirrotta, C. (2010). A 4000 yrs long record of tsunami deposits along the coast of the Augusta Bay (eastern Sicily, Italy): paleoseismological implications. Marine Geology, 276, 42–57.

  • De Martini, P.M., Barbano, M.S., Pantosti, D., Smedile, A., Pirrotta, C., Del Carlo, P., and Pinzi, S. (2012). Geological evidence for paleotsunamis along eastern Sicily (Italy): an overview. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 12, 2569–2580.

  • Dominey-Howes, D., and Papathoma, M. (2007). Validating a Tsunami Vulnerability Assessment Model (the PTVA Model) Using Field Data from the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami. Nat. Hazards, 40, 113–136.

  • DISS Working Group (2010). Database of Individual Seismogenic Sources (DISS), Version 3.1.1: A compilation of potential sources for earthquakes larger than M 5.5 in Italy and surrounding areas. http://diss.rm.ingv.it/diss/, © INGV 2010–Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia–All rights reserved; doi:10.6092/INGV.IT-DISS3.1.1.

  • Eckert, S., Jelinek, R., Zeug, G., and Krausmann, E. (2012). Remote sensing-based assessment of tsunami vulnerability and risk in Alexandria, Egypt. Appl. Geogr., 32, 714–723.

  • Favalli, M., Boschi, E., Mazzarini, F., and Pareschi, M.T. (2009). Seismic and landslide source of the 1908 Straits of Messina tsunami (Sicily, Italy). Geophys. Res. Lett. 36, 1–6. doi:10.1029/2009GL039135.

  • Fritz, H.M., Phillips, D.A., Okayasu, A., Shimozono, T., Liu, H.J., Mohammed, F., Skanavis, V., Synolakis, C.E., and Takahashi, T. (2012). The 2011 Japan tsunami current velocity measurements from survivor videos at Kesennuma Bay using LiDAR. Geophys. Res. Lett. 39, 1–6. doi:10.1029/2011GL050686.

  • Gardi, A., Valencia, N., Guillande, R., and André, C. (2011). Inventory of uncertainties associated with the process of tsunami damage assessment on buildings (SCHEMA FP6 EC co-funded project). Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 883–893.

  • Geist, E.L., and Parsons, T. (2006). Probabilistic analysis of tsunami hazards. Natural Hazards, 37, 277–314.

  • Gerardi, P., Barbano, M.S., De Martini, P.M., and Pantosti, D. (2008). Discrimination of Tsunami Sources (Earthquake versus Landslide) on the Basis of Historical Data in Eastern Sicily and Southern Calabria. Bull. Seism. Soc. Am., 98, 2795–2805.

  • Grilli, S.T., Harris, J., and Tajalli Bakhsh, T., 2011. Literature Review of Tsunami Sources Affecting Tsunami Hazard Along the US East Coast, NTHMP Progress report, Res. Rept. CACR-11-08, Center for Applied Coastal Research, University of Delaware, Newark.

  • Guidoboni, E., Comastri, A., and Traina, G., Catalogue of Ancient Earthquakes in the Mediterranean Area up to 10th Century (Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica, Roma 1994).

  • Guidoboni E., Ferrari G., Mariotti D., Comastri A., Tarabusi G., and Valensise G. (2007). CFTI4Med, Catalogue of Strong Earthquakes in Italy (461 B.C.–1997) and Mediterranean Area (760 B.C.–1500). INGV-SGA. http://storing.ingv.it/cfti4med/.

  • Gutscher, M.A., Roger J., Baptista, M.A., Miranda, J.M., and Tinti, S. (2006). Source of the 1693 Catania earthquake and tsunami (southern Italy): new evidence from tsunami modelling of a locked subduction fault plane. Geophys. Res. Lett. 33. doi:10.1029/2005GL025442.

  • Kastens, K. A. and Cita, M. B. (1981). Tsunami-induced sediment transport in the abyssal Mediterranean Sea. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 92, 845–857.

  • Leone, F., Lavigne, F., Paris, R., Denain, J.C., and Vinet, F. (2010). A spatial analysis of the December 26th, 2004 tsunami-induced damages: lessons learned for a better risk assessment integrating buildings vulnerability. Appl. Geogr., 31, 363–375.

  • McCoy, F.W., and Heiken, G. (2000). Tsunami Generated by the Late Bronze Age Eruption of Thera (Santorini), Greece. Pure Appl. Geophys., 157, 1227–1256.

  • Martinelli, G. (1909). Osservazioni preliminari sul terremoto calabro-messinese del mattino del 28 dicembre 1908, Bollettino Bimensuale della Società Meteorologica Italiana, serie III, 28, 3–11.

  • Mercalli, G., Contributo allo studio del terremoto calabro-messinese del 28 dicembre 1908 (Cooperativa Tipografica, Napoli 1909).

  • Monaco, C., and Tortorici, L. (2000). Active faulting in the Calabrian arc and eastern Sicily. J. Geodyn. 29, 407–424.

  • Pagnoni, G., Armigliato, A., and Tinti, S. (2015). Scenario-based assessment of buildings damage and population exposure due to tsunamis for the town of Alexandria, Egypt. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., submitted revision.

  • Papadopoulos, G. A., and Dermetzopoulos, T. (1998). A tsunami risk assessment pilot study in Heraklion, Crete. Natural Hazards, 18, 91–118.

  • Papathoma, M., Dominey-Howes, D., Zong, Y., and Smith, D. (2003). Assessing tsunami vulnerability, an example from Herakleio, Crete. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 3, 377–389.

  • Papathoma, M., and Dominey-Howes, D. (2003). Tsunami vulnerability assessment and its implications for coastal hazard analysis and disaster management planning, Gulf of Corinth, Greece. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 3, 733–747.

  • Piatanesi, A., and Tinti, S. (1998). A revision of the 1693 eastern Sicily earthquake and tsunami, J. Geophys. Res. 103, 2749–2758.

  • Piatanesi, A., Tinti, S., and Bortolucci, E. (1999). Finite-element simulations of the 28 December 1908 Messina Straits (southern Italy) tsunami. Phys. Chem. Earth Part A. 24, 145–150.

  • Piatanesi, A., Lorito, S., and Romano, F., Il grande maremoto del 1908: analisi e modellazione, In Il Terremoto e il Maremoto del 28 dicembre 1908: analisi sismologica, impatto, prospettive (ed. Bertolaso, G., Boschi, E., Guidoboni, E., Valensise, G.) (INGV-DPC, Roma-Bologna 2008).

  • Platania, G. (1909a). Il maremoto dello stretto di Messina del 28 dicembre 1908. Boll. Soc. Sism. Ital., 13, 369–458.

  • Platania, G. (1909b). I fenomeni marittimi che accompagnarono il terremoto di Messina del 28 dicembre 1908, Rivista Geografica Italiana, 16, 154–161.

  • Polonia, A., Bonatti, E., Camerlenghi, A., Lucchi, R.G., Panieri, G., and Gasperini, L. (2013). Mediterranean megaturbidite triggered by the AD 365 Crete earthquake and tsunami. Sci. Rep. 3, 1285. doi:10.1038/srep01285.

  • Reese, S., Cousins, W.J., Power, W.L., Palmer, N.G., Tejakusuma, I.G., and Nugrahadi, S. (2007). Tsunami vulnerability of buildings and people in south Java–field observations after the July 2006 Java tsunami. Nat. Hazards Earth Sys., 7, 573–589.

  • Ribeiro, J., Silva, A., and Leitão, P. (2011). High resolution tsunami modelling for the evaluation of potential risk areas in Setúbal (Portugal). Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 2371–2380.

  • Ridente, D., Martorelli, E., Bosman, A., and Chiocci, F.L. (2014). High-resolution morpho-bathymetric imaging of the Messina Strait (Southern Italy). New insights on the 1908 earthquake and tsunami. Geomorphology, 208, 149–159.

  • Ryan W.B.F., and Heezen B.C. (1965). Ionian Sea submarine canyons and the 1908 Messina turbidity current. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 76, 915–932.

  • Sirovich, L., and Pettenati, F. (1999). Seismotectonic outline of South-Eastern Sicily: an evaluation of available options for the earthquake fault rupture scenario. J. Seismology, 3, 213–233.

  • Scicchitano, G., Monaco, C., and Tortorici, L. (2007). Large boulder deposits by tsunami waves along the Ionian coast of south-eastern Sicily (Italy). Mar. Geol. 238, 75–91.

  • Scicchitano, G., Costa, B., Di Stefano, A., Longhitano, S.G., and Monaco, C. (2010). Tsunami and storm deposits preserved within a ria-type rocky coastal setting (Siracusa, SE Sicily). Zeitschrift für Geomorphol. Suppl. Issues 54, 51–77. doi:10.1127/0372-8854/2010/0054S3-0019.

  • Shaw, B., Ambraseys, N.N., England, P.C., Floyd, M.A., Gorman, G.J., Higham, T.F.G., Jackson, J.A., Nocquet, J.M., Pain, C.C. and Piggott, M.D. (2008). Eastern Mediterranean tectonics and tsunami hazard inferred from the AD 365 earthquake. Nat. Geosci. 1, 268–276.

  • Smedile, A., De Martini, P.M., and Pantosti, D. (2012). Combining inland and offshore paleotsunamis evidence: the Augusta Bay (eastern Sicily, Italy) case study. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 12, 2557–2567.

  • Sørensen, M.B., Spada, M., Babeyko, A., Wiemer, S., and Grünthal, G. (2012). Probabilistic tsunami hazard in the Mediterranean Sea. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 117, 1–15. doi:10.1029/2010JB008169.

  • Tinti, S. (1991). Assessment of tsunami hazard in the Italian Seas, Nat. Hazards, 4, 267–283.

  • Tinti, S., and Armigliato, A., Tsunamigenic earthquakes, In Problems in Geophysics for the New Millennium (ed. Boschi E., Ekström G., Morelli A.) (Editrice Compositori, Bologna 2000) pp. 27–46.

  • Tinti, S., and Armigliato, A., Impact of large tsunamis in the Messina Straits, Italy: the case of the 28 December 1908 tsunami, In Tsunami Research at the End of a Critical Decade (ed. Hebenstreit, G.T.) (Kluwer, Dordrecht 2001) pp. 139–162.

  • Tinti, S., Armigliato, A., and Bortolucci, E. (2001). Contribution of tsunami data analysis to constrain the seismic source: the case of the 1693 eastern Sicily earthquake. J. Seismology, 5, 41-61.

  • Tinti S., Maramai A., and Graziani L. (2004). The new catalogue of the Italian tsunamis, Nat. Hazards, 33, 439–465.

  • Tinti, S., Armigliato, A., Pagnoni, G., and Zaniboni F. (2005a). Scenarios of giant tsunamis of tectonic origin in the Mediterranean. ISET Journal of Earthquake Technology, 42, 171–188.

  • Tinti, S., Manucci, A., Pagnoni, G., Armigliato, A., and Zaniboni F., (2005b). The 30th December 2002 tsunami in Stromboli: sequence of the events reconstructed from the eyewitness accounts. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 5, 763–775.

  • Tinti, S., Pagnoni, G., and Zaniboni F. (2006). The landslides and tsunamis of 30th December 2002 in Stromboli analysed through numerical simulations. Bull. Volcanol., 68, 462–479.

  • Tinti, S., Argnani, A., Zaniboni, F., Pagnoni, G., and Armigliato, A. (2007). Tsunamigenic potential of recently mapped submarine mass movements offshore eastern Sicily (Italy): numerical simulations and implications for the 1693 tsunami. Abstract n.8235, IUGG XXIV General Assembly.

  • Tinti, S., Armigliato, A., Pagnoni, G., Tonini, R., and Zaniboni, F., Atlante delle zone esposte al rischio di maremoto nell’area di Catania (Compositori, Bologna 2010).

  • Tinti, S., Tonini, R., Bressan, L., Armigliato, A., Gardi, A., Guillande, R., Valencia, N., and Scheer, S. (2011). Handbook of tsunami hazard and damage scenarios. JRC Scientific and Technical Reports, pp. 1–41, doi: 10.2788/21259.

  • Tonini, R., Armigliato, A., Pagnoni, G., Zaniboni, F., and Tinti, S., (2011). Tsunami hazard for the city of Catania, eastern Sicily, Italy, assessed by means of Worst-case Credible Tsunami Scenario Analysis (WCTSA). Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci, 11, 1217–1232.

  • Valencia, N., Gardi, A., Gauraz, A., Leone, F., and Guillande R. (2011). New tsunami damage functions developed in the framework of SCHEMA project: application to European-Mediterranean coasts. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 2835–2846.

  • Valensise, G., and Pantosti, D. (1992). A 125 kyr-long geological record of seismic source repeatability: the Messina Straits (southern Italy) and the 1908 earthquake (Ms 7 1/2). Terra Nova, 4, 472–483.

  • Zaniboni, F., Armigliato, A., Pagnoni, G., and Tinti, S. (2014). Earthquake or landslide-tsunami? Discriminating the source type by the effects on the coast. Abstract presented at the EGU General Assembly 2014, EGU2014-10025, Geophysical Research Abstracts, Vol. 16.

Download references

Acknowledgments

The authors are indebted to Dr Francesco Rallo who provided some of the data and some preliminary analyses for this research. The research conducted in this paper is the follow-up of a research initiated during the European FP6 project TRANSFER (Contract No. 037058). It is mostly financed by the on-going FP7 project ASTARTE—“Assessment, Strategy And Risk Reduction for 740 Tsunamis in Europe” (FP7-ENV2013 6.4-3, Grant 603839).

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Department of Physics and Astronomy (DIFA), Sector of Geophysics, University of Bologna, viale Berti Pichat 8, 40127, Bologna, Italy

    Gianluca Pagnoni & Stefano Tinti

Authors
  1. Gianluca Pagnoni
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. Stefano Tinti
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Gianluca Pagnoni.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Pagnoni, G., Tinti, S. Application and Comparison of Tsunami Vulnerability and Damage Models for the Town of Siracusa, Sicily, Italy. Pure Appl. Geophys. 173, 3795–3822 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00024-016-1261-8

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00024-016-1261-8

Keywords

Search

Navigation