Motion perception during tilt and translation after space flight
Highlights
► Effects of spaceflight on perceived motion during passive tilt and translation. ► Magnitude of perceived roll tilt during static tilt was larger post-flight than pre-flight. ► The ability to control dynamic tilt using non-visual inertial cues was impaired immediately after the flight. ► The use of a tactile prosthesis improved manual control performance both before and after the flight.
Introduction
In darkness, the central nervous system must resolve the ambiguity of inertial motion sensory cues in order to derive an accurate representation of spatial orientation. The balance system in the inner ear (otoliths) senses both head translation and head tilt relative to gravity. During space flight, head tilt is not sensed; the brain must therefore learn new ways of orienting oneself in weightlessness, which can then lead to disturbances in perceived motion and balance control upon return to Earth's gravity [1], [2]. Adaptive changes during space flight in how the brain integrates vestibular cues with other sensory information can lead to impaired movement coordination, vertigo, spatial disorientation and perceptual illusions following gravity level transitions [3].
This ongoing study was designed to examine both the physiological basis and operational implications for disorientation and tilt-translation disturbances following short-duration space flights. Specifically, this study addressed three questions: (1) What adaptive changes occur in motion perception in response to different combinations of tilt and translation motion? (2) Do adaptive changes in tilt-translation responses impair the ability to manually control vehicle orientation? (3) Can sensory substitution aids, such as tactile cues, mitigate the risks associated with manual control of vehicle orientation?
The primary objective of this study was to evaluate how the brain adapts to conflicting motion cues by measuring changes in awareness of position. Before and after space flight, subjects were exposed to a combination of body tilt and translation on a sled or a centrifuge. Based on the results from previous post-flight studies [4], [5], [6] we hypothesized that perceived tilt will increase post-flight during static tilt, as a result of the in-flight decrease in the amplitude of the internal model of gravity. During dynamic tilt and translation, it was expected that motion perception will have specific frequency characteristics, with adaptive changes being greatest in the mid-frequency range where there is a crossover of tilt and translation [7].
The secondary objective of this experiment was to evaluate how a tactile prosthesis can be used to improve control performance. The tactile prosthesis is a simple four vibrotactile system that provide feedback when tilt position exceeds predetermined levels in either pitch or roll [8]. Subjects were tasked to use a joystick to null out tilt and translation motion disturbances with or without the help of the tactile prosthesis. We predicted that performance in the closed-loop tilt control task would be compromised following tilt-translation adaptation after space flight, with increased control errors corresponding to changes in self-motion perception [9]. Furthermore, that performance would improve with tactile feedback of tilt control errors.
In this paper we describe the equipment and experimental protocol used for this study and report the preliminary results obtained with astronaut-subjects.
Section snippets
Equipment
Our sled protocol was based on an elegant set of experiments performed by Angelaki and colleagues [10] in monkeys to demonstrate the importance of multi-sensory integration for discriminating tilt from translations. Angelaki's experimental protocols consisted of either lateral translations, roll tilts, or combined translation-tilt paradigms. With intact animals, horizontal eye movements that compensate for translation were present during translation but were negligible during pure roll tilt.
Results
The data analysis is still ongoing at this point. We present here some preliminary results obtained on six astronauts before and after Space Shuttle missions lasting 11–16 day.
When subjects on the VRC were positioned and maintained at an eccentricity of ±3.5 cm to their right or to their left during eccentric centrifugation at 400°/s, they experienced the typical illusion of being statically tilted in roll. This perception was assessed by verbal reports for the amplitude of perceived tilt.
Discussion
In agreement with previous studies [4], [5], [13] the preliminary results of this experiment show an increased sensitivity to static tilt in roll after space flight. This overestimation of body tilt in the roll plane has been attributed to a decrease in the amplitude of the internal model of gravity during adaptation to microgravity [6]. After return to Earth, the decrease in the amplitude of the internal model of gravity would carry over to the post-flight period and be responsible for the
Acknowledgments
This project was supported by NASA, ESA, CNES, and CNRS. The measures obtained during 400°/s rotation were performed as part of the Otolith experiment conducted by A. Clarke.
References (15)
Human otolith-ocular reflexes during off-vertical axis rotation: Effect of frequency on tilt-translation ambiguity and motion sickness
Neurosci. Lett.
(2002)- et al.
Otolith tilt-translation reinterpretation following prolonged weightlessness: implications for preflight training
Aviat. Space Environ. Med.
(1985) - et al.
Spatial orientation in weightlessness and readaptation to earth's gravity
Science
(1984) Fundamentals of Space Medicine
(2011)- et al.
Human ocular counter-rolling and roll tilt perception during off-vertical axis rotation after spaceflight
J. Vestib. Res.
(2007) - et al.
Perception of tilt (somatogravic illusion) in response to sustained linear acceleration during space flight
Exp. Brain Res.
(2001) The role of the otoliths in perception of the vertical and in path integration
Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci.
(1999)
Cited by (15)
Verbal reports of neurovestibular symptoms in astronauts after short-duration space flight
2018, Acta AstronauticaCitation Excerpt :These observations confirm earlier studies that suggested the gain and time constant of otolith-induced responses increase as a result of adaptation to weightlessness [8]. Tilt-translation illusions, including overestimation of tilt magnitude and misperception of the type of motion, have been observed previously during active or passive head or body movements following space flight [5–7]. These illusions are presumably due to a central reinterpretation of otolith inputs signaling head tilt to gravity, a function that is no longer effective in orbit [11,15].
Effects of motion paradigm on human perception of tilt and translation
2022, Scientific ReportsMission-critical tasks for assessing risks from vestibular and sensorimotor adaptation during space exploration
2022, Frontiers in PhysiologyEffects of Spaceflight on the Vestibular System
2022, Handbook of Space PharmaceuticalsLong-duration head down bed rest as an analog of microgravity: Effects on the static perception of upright
2022, Journal of Vestibular Research: Equilibrium and OrientationArtificially altered gravity elicits cell homeostasis imbalance in planarian worms, and cerium oxide nanoparticles counteract this effect
2021, Journal of Biomedical Materials Research - Part A